Report: Everglades restoration may harm Florida Bay
The widely held perception that the murky, ailing Florida Bay will recover when the Everglades restoration sends more fresh water there could be wrong, a group of scientists wrote in a report released August 8th.  

 9-Aug-02

  Recent Developments

•  News         
•  Press Releases
•  Litigation
•  Legislation
•  Regulations
•  Case Law
•  Law Review Articles
•  Reports
•  Research
•  Conferences
•  Links


      September  2002             July  2002

                           News Archives


 

August   2002 

 

Everglades Village News

Daytona Beach News Environment   |   Sun-Sentinel:  Everglades Site   |    Commons-Everglades Discussion    |   Sun-Sentinel Everglades Discussion   |   SFWMD News Releases

SFWMD Currents weekly e-newsletter
http://www.sfwmd.gov/misce/cyber/index.html

 

  News

31-August-02

Editorial- Times Recommends: 'Dr. Andy' for Agriculture
Florida's agriculture commissioner will play a more important role in state government than many residents realize. Not only will the person in that job oversee agriculture and consumer programs, he or she will be one of three Cabinet members in the newly reorganized state government. So voters in the upcoming Democratic primary should look for a candidate with broad interests and a sense of balance. Andy Michaud comes closest to being that candidate.
Michaud, 43, an Orlando-area veterinarian, has a strong technical background for the job. He spent part of his youth on a dairy farm and worked with cattle and horses before opening an animal hospital near Orlando. 
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Corps to begin 'pulse' release today:
The release of fresh water from Lake Okeechobee into the St. Lucie River will occur for the next 10 days.

Predictions that Lake Okeechobee's already high water level will continue to rise prompted the Army Corps of Engineers to decide Friday to begin releasing fresh water into the St. Lucie River today.The "pulse," or low-volume, release will be conducted for 10 days at anaverage flow of 730 cubic feet per second into the St. Lucie Canal, according to a statement issued by the corps. The canal flows into the South Fork of the St. Lucie River.The impending lake release and ongoing releases of contaminated water from agricultural canals were debated vigorously during a meeting of the Rivers
Coalition on Friday in Stuart. Read more...

Copyright  © 2002  TC Palm  All rights reserved.

Letter to the editor: On Everglades cleanup, stress how people can help
The Post is doing a good job reporting on the Everglades restoration. Now that the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan has been adopted, the hard part of implementation is beginning. The articles and editorials point out the complexities and uncertainties of the plan. Public agencies and governments are important participants, but another important participant is missing from all I have read -- South Florida residents.
Although it is easy to blame agriculture and government, we have a direct responsibility for the degradation of the Everglades, since many of the actions that led to the "draining and ditching" were done to enable people to live here. Today, our actions continue to affect the Everglades, Lake Okeechobee, the Lake Worth Lagoon and the entire watershed by the way we use water and maintain our landscape. Studies show that 65 percent of non- point pollution of water comes from stormwater runoff. 
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Commentary- Outlook: Florida's Incredible Hulk is an unsustainable development
Islands of Adventure, one of two giant theme parks owned by Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, contains a ride called The Incredible Hulk. Named after a Marvel comic superhero, the coaster accelerates its cargo of screaming joy riders from 0 to 40mph in two seconds and then throws them into a stomach churning confusion of loop the loops, corkscrews and near vertical drops. In less than 40 seconds, the ride is over, the passengers spill out on to the pavement and stagger off in search of other thrills, their heads still spinning from the G forces they have just been subjected to. The spectacle is both awesome and appaling at the same time. Awesome, because nobody could help but marvel at the degree of human advancement in technology, logistics, mass spending and leisure time that has made such rides possible. Appaling, because there could hardly be a more potent symbol of wasteful, self-indulgent overconsumption than a Florida theme park. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  Guardian UK  All rights reserved.

Water district has new goal: Preserve land
Huge tracts of wilderness and wetlands in Orange County would be purchased under a plan that was proposed with so little fanfare this week that even the would-be participants didn't hear about it.  Henry Dean, director of the South Florida Water Management District, on Tuesday unveiled his idea to fuel Orange County land conservation with $10 million a year from his agency. He urged the neighboring St. Johns Water Management District, which covers most of Central Florida, to kick in some cash.  In an interview Friday, Dean said his proposal grew from an announcement by County Chairman Rich Crotty, who pledged to buy environmental lands with proceeds of a tax on hotel room charges.  Crotty revealed on Friday the amount he has in mind is about $5 million annually, which would bring the total for annual conservation buying to at least $15 million.  Officials at the St. Johns district were surprised by the proposal -- they said they hadn't heard of Dean's proposal -- and they questioned its wisdom.  Copyright  © 2002 Orlando Sentinel  All Rights Reserved.

 

Eastern North Carolina Faces Water Crisis
The last few years have been tough for eastern North Carolina. Thousands of textile and manufacturing jobs have left. The poor region is still recovering from Hurricane Floyd, which caused an estimated $6 billion in flood damage in September 1999. Now it is facing another water problem: there is not enough. Groundwater is disappearing in 15 counties, and the remedy is likely to cost the hard-pressed communities hundreds of millions of dollars. For decades, the two huge aquifers have been dropping as the demands for water increased. In some places, sea water has been drawn in, tainting the aquifers' fresh water. "Most of our wells drop 5 feet a year, but we had some that dropped 20 feet," said Ralph Clark, city manager in Kinston, N.C., a town of 23,700 in Lenoir County. State regulators announced this summer that some water systems in the area would have to reduce their use of groundwater as much as 75 percent in the next 16 years. A study by the North Carolina Rural Economic Development Center, a nonprofit agency to improve the quality of life in rural areas, estimated that new water sources for the 15-county region would cost $153 million to $247 million. Officials in Lenoir County plan to spend $60 million on a new water system. Other communities are also looking for new water sources. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

 

Protest for Poor at U.N. Forum in South Africa  

Protesters demonstrated in South Africa's Alexandra township yesterday before a United Nations meeting on development. They came from many countries, but most were South Africans seeking help for the poor.

 From the top of the hill, the protesters today could see the gleaming buildings of stone and steel where world leaders will meet in the coming days to debate a new plan to reduce poverty and preserve the environment. More than 100 presidents and prime ministers are scheduled to discuss ways to save dying lakes and retreating forests and to uplift impoverished nations. But today, surrounded by teetering shacks, mounds of garbage and children in tattered shoes, thousands of people marched through the streets to demonstrate their distrust and disillusionment with promises by governments to help the poor and protect the environment. There were Malawians protesting hunger in Africa, Paraguayans warning about the dangers of dams, Palestinians complaining about Israel's policies and Americans assailing President Bush's decision not to participate in this meeting. But most of the protesters were poor, ordinary South Africans who hoped to deliver a message to the leaders attending the United Nations World Summit on Sustainable Development. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

 

Goals Clash at the Summit Meeting on Global Warming   

         

Critics want President Bush at the U.N. World Summit in Johannesburg, but countries besides the U.S. are also   balking at approving an agreement on the environment

          

The photograph appears in a full-page advertisement in The International Herald Tribune under the headline "Put a Face on Global Warming and Forest Destruction." It is a picture of President Bush, whose country is accused by protesters and some delegates at an international conference here of derailing any hope of progress at the talks to reduce poverty and protect the environment. "Corporate criminals!" the protesters shout as they assail American officials for opposing targets and deadlines intended to promote development while preserving the environment. But in the private negotiating rooms at the United Nations World Summit on Sustainable Development here, the United States is far from the only country balking at approving a strong, ambitious agreement. Saudi Arabia, Canada, Japan and Australia, for instance, also oppose deadlines for the conversion from oil and gas power to windmills, solar panels and other forms of renewable energy. The European Union objects to eliminating subsidies for activities that threaten natural resources, like commercial fishing. Developing countries have joined the United States in pressing to water down language that would have committed nations to significantly reducing the threat that dangerous chemicals pose to health and the environment. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

U.S. Approves Water Plan in California, but Environmental Opposition Remains
With California facing a year-end federal deadline to reduce its dependence on Colorado River water, the Interior Department has given its go-ahead to a $1 billion, 50-year plan to store and pump water from beneath private land in the Mojave Desert. The Bush administration's decision removes a major obstacle to the project, proposed by a private company, Cadiz Inc., to help the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California make up future water shortfalls. The plan still faces opposition, which has been led by Senator Dianne Feinstein, Democrat of California, on environmental grounds. It has not yet been approved by the water district's board. Still, as the state scrambles to line up new water sources before the deadline, the ruling has given new life to the Cadiz project. The project is one of several unconventional options on the table, including a proposal by the City of San Diego to pay tens of millions of dollars to farmers in the Imperial Valley so the Colorado water to which they are entitled can go to urban users instead. The reason for the scramble is a multistate agreement from 1999 that requires California to reduce its overuse of Colorado River water, which now exceeds the state's allocation by 20 percent.  Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

 

30-August-02

Commentary: Water Management?
About two months ago the Philippe Cousteau Foundation was asked to help school systems in South Florida develop an educational curriculum for over one million 14 through 18 year old students. Our task was to create an educational documentary. I gathered my team together and, in the spirit of my father’s films, we set out on an expedition to explore a very special part of Florida. Little did I know that what initially seemed a straightforward investigation of a national treasure unique to South Florida would eventually lead me to explore issues that are significant to all of us.
When most people think of Florida they think of roller coasters, golf courses and Mickey Mouse. Many of them don’t realize that there is something more precious, more beautiful and more incredible than any theme park.
Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  Cousteau Foundation  All rights reserved.

State whittles down its list of polluted waters:
The list determines which waterways may be protected. A critic calls the new list a ruse to overlook dirty water.

The state's top environmental regulator signed off Thursday on an updated list of polluted waterways in need of cleanup that removes some sections of Tampa Bay from consideration.
David Struhs, secretary of the state Department of Environmental Protection, hailed the new "impaired waters" list as "a workable, common- sense environmental plan." Lots of other states have studied Florida's process and may emulate it, he said. That scares Linda Young of the Clean Water Network. "If Florida gets away with what they're doing, a lot of other states are going to do it too," Young said. "Florida is leading the way in undermining the Clean Water Act in this country."
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Citrus interests wage war on Barley:
The environmental activist and Democratic agriculture candidate is labeled a threat to the "growers' survival.''

Florida's citrus industry has declared war on environmental activist Mary Barley.
Barley is just one of three candidates running in the Democratic primary for commissioner of agriculture and consumer services Sept. 10, hoping to take on Republican incumbent Charles Bronson. But her candidacy has galvanized the $1.3-billion industry. Two industry groups, who say they aren't working together, have launched a double- barrelled attack on her. On Thursday, Florida Citrus Mutual notified its 11,500 members that Barley is such an "alarming political threat" that the grower organization's 21 directors had voted unanimously to tap into an emergency fund to fight her and help Bronson.
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Ag interests attack commissioner candidate
Florida's agricultural giants wasted no time this week unleashing a hard-hitting attack ad against environmental activist and Democratic agriculture commissioner candidate Mary Barley.
The day after a lawsuit challenging Barley's right to run in the Sept. 10 Democratic primary was dropped, a nonprofit advocacy group called Florida's Working Families, but backed by wealthy citrus, sugar and other
ag interests, began airing statewide a scathing 30-second television spot blasting Barley, a millionaire developer and former Republican, for being a turncoat.
Florida's Working Families was formed Aug. 19 and is financed in part by citrus growers Ben Hill Griffin Inc. and Alico; Zipperer Farms, a Fort
Myers flower distributor; and two equipment companies, FMC Corp. of Lakeland and Enerfab of Cincinnati. 

Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Waters restoration roadmap taking shape:
Targets identified, prioritized

Florida is one step closer to cleaning up the state's impaired waters with the final approval by the Department of Environmental Protection of a priority list of water bodies that need restoration. Culminating months of public evaluation, DEP Secretary David B. Struhs signed the final order
identifying the first round of targeted water bodies. The list of impaired waters will be forwarded to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for approval by October 1, 2002.Over the next five years, hundreds of water bodies will be evaluated in accordance with federal and state law using the latest science. A plan for restoration will be established for those demonstrated to be impaired. Read more...

Copyright  © 2002  Florida Department of Environmental Protection  All rights reserved.

SOUTH FLORIDA WATER MANAGEMENT DISTRICT PROPOSED
MULTI-MILLION-DOLLAR LAND-BUYING PARTNERSHIP IN ORANGE COUNTY

To "leave a meaningful legacy to the people of Florida, particularly Orange
County," South Florida Water Management District Executive Director Henry Dean proposed the creation of a land-buying partnership uniting the District, Orange County, St. Johns River Water Management District and the Florida Department of Environmental Protection.
"For the first year, I am prepared to recommend to my board that the South Florida Water Management District earmark $10 million for this effort," Dean said this week while presenting the District's 2003 proposed budget to the Orange County Commission. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  South Florida Water Management District  All rights reserved.

Environmentalists vs. the Poor? 

The following are letters:

To the Editor: Re "The Environmentalists Are Wrong," 

As the majority of countries here at the United Nations World Summit on Sustainable Development understand, there need not be a contradiction between economic growth and environmental sustainability. Among the crucial questions we're addressing is how to ensure that globalization works to benefit the have-nots as well as the haves, and how to develop economically and protect the earth at the same time. As Mr. Lomborg points out, people in the poorest countries need many things: clean drinking water, basic health care and family planning services. But they also need a healthy environment in which to live and work, just like the rest of us. This won't just magically occur as an inevitable byproduct of unrestrained economic development, but it will if we make it a priority. STEPHEN MILLS Johannesburg, Aug. 27, 2002 The writer is international program director of the Sierra Club.  Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

The Curse of Factory Farms 
Factory farms have become the dominant method of raising meat in America. Agribusiness loves the apparent efficiency that comes with raising thousands of animals in a single large building where they are permanently confined in stalls or pens. Most of the human labor can be automated. It takes less land, because the animals live cheek by jowl their entire lives. And it allows the concentration of enormous stocks of animals in the hands of a few corporations whose goal is usually complete vertical integration - the control of production from birth through butchering and packaging. These plants, called confined animal feeding operations, or CAFO's, now exist in 44 states. The question is how to minimize their harmful environmental effects and prevent them from putting a final squeeze on smaller farmers, especially those who raise animals in more traditional, grass-based ways. Factory farms have taken root mainly where zoning laws were lax or nonexistent, or in states where citizens were prevented from filing suits against agricultural operations. The inevitable byproduct of huge concentrations of animals is huge concentrations of manure, which is stored in open lagoons and eventually sprayed on farmland, though there is usually far more manure than local fields can absorb. In such quantities, manure becomes a toxic substance. Spills are always a risk, as is groundwater contamination. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

U.S. Shows Off Aid Projects at U.N. Development Meeting 
Moving to demonstrate a commitment to the developing world, the United States showcased a series of multimillion-dollar projects today aimed at helping poor countries reduce poverty and protect their natural resources. The United States announced that it planned to spend more than $1 billion over the next four years to improve water efficiency on farms and in factories, to provide electricity to the poor, to help communities combat deforestation and to ease hunger in Africa. The European Union has also promised to expand access to water and energy. American officials hoped the announcement would quiet the relentless storm of criticism that has erupted here at the United Nations Summit on Sustainable Development. The United States has refused to agree to firm time frames for reducing agricultural subsidies, for reducing the number of people in need of sanitation and for embracing wind and solar power, among other things. But the Americans' announcement, which was warmly welcomed by the United Nations, was described as inadequate by environmental groups and advocates for the poor. Most of the money for the projects will come from existing programs, and critics condemned the plan as an attempt to divert attention from the reluctance of wealthy nations to reduce trade subsidies, which many economists say hurt farmers in poor countries. Read more....
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

29-August-02

Sprawling South Top U.S. Water Waster, Study Says
The South leads the nation in wasting water through unchecked
urban growth, according to environmentalists who blame sprawl for worsening water shortages during droughts. A study released Wednesday by American Rivers, the Natural Resources Defense Council and Smart Growth America found that 11 of the 20 cities with the greatest conversion of open land into development were in the South. In the Tampa Bay area, nearly 200,000 acres were developed between 1982 and 1997. That development - with roads, parking lots, driveways and roofs - blocks between 7.3 million and 17 million gallons of rain water a year from seeping into the aquifer, the report said.

Get the report (You need Adobe Acrobat to open this file.) 
Read the Executive Summary
Read the press release
Questions & Answers sheet
 
Photo essay
(Reporters -- downloads available)

Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune / Associated Press  All rights reserved.

New-Generation Cousteau Focuses on the Everglades
Cousteau debuted his recently completed film to Palm Beach County science and math teachers. "The Journey Through the Everglades" film will serve as a pilot for a quarterly series of educational programs which will be launched in the next year or so.
The Philippe Cousteau Foundation worked with the South Florida Water Management District, Everglades National Park, Newspapers in Education and numerous other groups to produce the educational documentary which examines on-going Everglades restoration projects. The film will eventually be viewed by an estimated 30,000 students in Palm Beach County and will be a template for similar projects across the country. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  South Florida Water Management District  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Swimming advisories should send message
With one fell swoop last week, the health department brought back one of our worst nightmares: "Health warning" it read in bold, capital letters. Higgs, Simonton and South beaches were all posted with signs advising beach-goers to stay out of the water.  It certainly hasn't been as bad as 1999, when Key West public beaches were lined with barricades and fliers warning bathers from going in the water.  Yet, as the water testing has spread through the Keys, we've found out it's not just a Key West problem.  This summer has seen warnings at John Pennekamp State Park in Key Largo, Harry Harris Park in Tavernier and Coco Plum city beach in Marathon.  So let's don't stick our collective heads in the sand, as we lounge on Keys beaches.  We've still got serious problems. In Key West, especially, we know that every time it rains, we are likely to see water-quality test results showing unhealthy levels of fecal-linked bacteria.  
Copyright  © 2002  Keys news  All rights reserved.

 

Judicial circuit official fighting manatee rules in court
Twentieth Judicial Circuit Court Administrator Doug Wilkinson is on trial - along with two lawyers and seven others - who are battling manatee protection rules.  Wilkinson, 48, intentionally violated state restrictions on Feb. 19, 2000, as an enforcement officer watched so he could fight the rules that went into effect in Lee County in November 1999.  Like many other boaters and fishermen, Wilkinson believes the rules do little to protect manatees and endanger boaters by forcing too many of them - in big boats and small boats - into the same crowded channels.  "I felt it was dangerous to do that," Wilkinson said. "I thought, 'It's insane to put all these people together.' "  State officials expanded Lee County's manatee protections areas on Nov. 30, 1999, adding 40 square miles of waters in which boaters must either travel at idle speed or go no faster than 25 mph in channels. 
Copyright  © 2002  Fort Meyers News Press  All rights reserved.

 

Lack of Basics Threatens World's Poor 
Delegates at the United Nations Summit on Sustainable Development today emphasized the importance of bringing water and sanitation to the millions around the world who struggle without those essential services. The United Nations says that 1.1 billion people lack clean drinking water and that 2.4 billion need access to sanitation. More than 2.2 million people in poor countries die each year from illnesses associated with dirty water and poor sanitation. Officials here have agreed to try to halve the number of people without access to clean water by 2015. But as the officials gathered for today's plenary discussion, it became clear that meeting that target would not be easy. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

Water for a Thirsty World  
Water is a vital resource for sustaining human life, growing crops and running many industrial activities. It is disturbing that in many areas of the world the demand for fresh water is rising faster than the supply, leaving about a billion people without access to clean drinking water. Regional water shortages have raised the specter of armed conflict, forced relatively affluent societies to finance huge water projects and left some of the world's most impoverished nations in deepening misery. A four-part series in The Times this week illuminated some of the causes and effects of dwindling water supplies just as the United Nations conference on sustainable development in Johannesburg is beginning to grapple with how to mitigate the problems. Only a little more than half the world's available fresh water is used each year. But by 2015, according to U.N. estimates, at least 40 percent of the world's population will live in countries where it is difficult or impossible to get enough water to satisfy basic needs. It is imperative to accelerate programs that can remedy the shortfall. The potential for conflict over water shows up forcefully in the Euphrates River Valley, where Turkey, with the advantage of an upstream position and a sturdy army, has commandeered much of the river's water through a $30 billion program for building dams and irrigating fields. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

At Development Talks, U.S. and Its Allies Clash Over Issues of Energy and Pollution 
For days now, the battle between rich and poor nations has dominated the United Nations talks here on the environment and development, with marches and fiery debates over how to reduce poverty. But one of the fiercest struggles has been raging behind the scenes as the United States and the European Union clash over strategies to preserve the planet. The allies are battling over the question of targets and time frames for the conversion from oil and gas to windmills and solar panels, for the cleanup of garbage and hazardous pollutants and for the preservation of endangered plants and animals. The European Union says these talks must produce a strong plan with firm deadlines so the world's leaders can be held accountable for their actions. The United States opposes targets and deadlines, saying it would rather finance specific projects than support goals that might ultimately prove meaningless. The negotiators on both sides are still cordial. But everyone agrees that the dispute has aggravated tensions that have been simmering since President Bush angered his European colleagues last year by refusing to ratify an international treaty aimed at preventing global warming. Nowhere is that rift more visible than in the debate over renewable energy. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

South's Fast-Growing Areas Find Water Supply Shrinking

At High Rock Lake, south of Winston-Salem, N.C., the water level at a dock was so low last month that grass had grown where water used to be.

A regional drought that is the worst on record is taking a heavy toll in the Carolinas, where some of the country's fastest-growing cities and suburbs are proving unexpectedly vulnerable to water shortages. Over the last four years, North and South Carolina have come up short by the equivalent of a year's supply of rain, and now cities like Charlotte and Raleigh, N.C., as well as dozens of smaller towns, are paying the price in the form of mandatory restrictions intended to reduce water use by as much as 20 percent. The water shortages, so severe that one parched North Carolina town has had to borrow water by fire hose, have been driven most directly by abnormalities in the climate, among the most severe in a drought that is now affecting more than a third of the United States, water experts and city planners say. But those abnormalities have been compounded by sprawling growth, which has sent water use spiraling ahead even of population increases and has cut into supplies of water that would have otherwise recharged aquifers, rivers and streams. In Charlotte, for example, the number of water users served by the local utility has increased 36 percent since 1992. But average daily water use has increased 56 percent, shrinking the cushion that planners had expected might prevent water rationing in rain-scarce years. Now, with accumulated rainfall since 1998 running more than 40 inches below normal, water managers in the region say the lesson of the drought is that more must be done sooner to promote conservation, even in normally rain-kissed climates like that of North Carolina, which averages 40 inches a year. "As we grow, we need to manage our water supplies more carefully," said John N. Morris, director of North Carolina's division of water resources. In a study released today, three national environmental organizations called attention to the connection between suburban development and water shortages. Read more....
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

28-August-02

Cabinet accepts sanctuary report
Five years after the state signed on, Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary officials heard only good words from the Florida Cabinet.
"I did a site visit to the sanctuary last week, and from my perspective, things looked pretty good," said Gov. Jeb Bush, accepting an annual review from sanctuary staff Tuesday in Tallahassee. Five years ago, controversy over sanctuary rules raised the possibility that the Florida Cabinet would not allow state waters – accounting for 65 percent of the existing Keys sanctuary – to be administered by a federal agency. The Cabinet eventually agreed after insisting on state veto powers over most major sanctuary decisions regarding waters near the Keys. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  Keynoter  All rights reserved.

New hydrology model could improve permitting
A new hydrology model may give better answers to water permitting issues in central Florida.
"It should revolutionize the way we look at the impact (on water)," said Doug Leonard, executive director of the Central Florida Regional Planning Council. The model, which was developed by the CFRPC, environmental consultant T. Mitchell Gurr and three phosphate mining companies, was unveiled Monday at a meeting in Bartow. Leonard said the triad brought in computer software from Brigham Young University in Utah and adapted it for Florida. The software originally was used to study the systems that impact the Colorado River
basin. Now it's being used on the Peace River.

Copyright  © 200News Sun All rights reserved.

Clean Water Workshop To Be Held Thursday
Environmental groups are teaming up to present a workshop Thursday aimed at protecting state waters.  The Ocean Conservancy, Oceana and the Clean Water Network are sponsoring the event at 7 p.m. at Moccasin Lake Nature Park Interpretive Center off Drew Street, between U.S. 19 and McMullen Booth Road.  The Clean Water Act, passed 30 years ago, has still not been fully enacted in Florida, and some environmentalists fear that as the state begins another attempt to evaluate Florida waters, it could lead to weaker protections for Florida rivers and estuaries.  The workshop will focus on a program called Total Maximum Daily Load, designed to protect rivers and estuaries. 
Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune  All rights reserved.

         Related Links,

            Florida Department of Environmental Protection
            Water Resource Management Programs
            Total Maximum Daily Loads
            http://www.dep.state.fl.us/water/tmdl/index.htm

            City of Clearwater - Parks & Recreation/Moccasin Lake Nature Park
            http://clearwater-fl.com/City_Departments/ parksrec/facilities/mlnp.html

            The Clean Water Network
            http://www.cwn.org/

            Southeast Clean Water Network
            http://www.cwn-se.org/

            Ocean Conservancy
            http://www.oceanconservancy.org/

            Oceana Welcomes You
            http://www.oceana.org/

 

State Moves to Preserve Polk Land;
Bush, Cabinet vote to spend $16 million to buy key habitat land east of Lake Wales.

Gov. Jeb Bush and members of the Florida Cabinet voted Tuesday to push ahead with ambitious plans to preserve thousands of acres in southeastern Polk County that are habitat for red-cockaded woodpeckers, scrub jays and other wildlife.  Bush and the Cabinet voted to spend $16 million in state money to purchase the Rolling Meadows Ranch while also signaling their strong support to acquire even more land near Lake Kissimmee.  Bush and the Cabinet rebuffed pleas from members of the River Ranch Property Owners Association who wanted the state to drop its plans to seek up to 39,000 acres between Lake Kissimmee State Park and the Avon Park Bombing Range.  The vote to spend the state money to purchase the Rolling Meadows Ranch, owned by Andrew Machata, came quickly with little debate or dissent. The nearly 6,000-acre parcel, which lies south of Lake Hatchineha, is being purchased for $38 million -- with the state putting up nearly half of the money and the rest coming from the South Florida Water Management District.  
Copyright  © 2002  The Ledger All rights reserved.

 

Agency Keeps Public Hearing Barely Visible
A public hearing isn't much of a public hearing when hardly anyone knows about it.  That's what happened when the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission scheduled a public hearing on the management plan for Hilochee Wildlife Management Area in Polk and Lake counties.  To discover that the future of public recreation on nearly 13,000 acres in the Four Corners area was on the table, you had to look for legal ads in odd places and be prepared for a two-hour drive to Tavares in northern Lake County where the Aug. 15 hearing was held.  Another hearing is planned sometime somewhere in Tallahassee, even less convenient. No hearing is planned in Polk County.  In case you've never heard of Hilochee, it consists of two sites.  The Polk County section, which is not open to the public, is a 6,175-acre tract, the bulk of which is south of Interstate 4 between County Road 557 and U.S. 27.  The Lake County section, which is open to the public, for a $3 day-use fee, is a 6,755-acre site on both sides of County Road 474 west of U.S. 27 in southern Lake County.  
Copyright  © 2002  The Ledger All rights reserved.

 

Army Corps of Engineers reveals Golden Gate flood control plans
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers unveiled a new proposal Tuesday for how to put natural water flows back through an abandoned subdivision in rural Collier County, but everyone is not sold on the idea.  The big question is whether the plan for Southern Golden Gate Estates does too much flood control and not enough environmental restoration.  "We should be moving closer together," said U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service biologist Kim Dryden, a member of the state and federal team planning the project. "It sounds like we're going further away."  For months, project planners have been tweaking proposals for the restoration of the 60,000-acre stretch of old roads and canals that runs between U.S. 41 East and Interstate 75. The state Department of Environmental Protection has nearly completed buying up the area.  The problem now is how to return the old subdivision to nature without making flooding worse on private property in a chunk of Golden Gate Estates north of I-75 beyond the buyout boundary.  
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

 

Tortugas shining light in Florida's damaged reefs
In this fecund forest, multihued toadstool shapes rise from a bountiful floor where strange things jostle for space, feathery boughs dance on a soft current, and wary eyes glint from a thousand dark crevasses.  The pale light that filters from above reveals scaly plates creeping over a stony plateau and downy fingers reaching skyward. Crimson boulders glow, lit by some internal fire.  Unlike the legendary Nottinghamshire lair of Robin Hood, this fantasy land called Sherwood Forest is not a royal hunting ground and hideout for wily outlaws but a real and rare tract of pristine coral reef under 80 feet of subtropical Florida waters forbidden to maritime hunters.  Some scientists see it as a refuge of hope in a spiraling undersea crisis.  "This is one of the best remaining coral reef habitats in the United States and the best nursery habitat in the United States," said Billy Causey, a marine biologist who as superintendent of the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary is chief guardian of the Dry Tortugas reefs.  Read more . . .  
Copyright  © 200 Environmental News Network All rights reserved.

 

FLORIDA KEYS PROTECTION CONTINUES AS GOVERNOR & CABINET ACCEPT MANAGEMENT PLAN
Governor Jeb Bush and Cabinet members concurred that a Five-Year Management Plan for the 2,900-square-mile waters within the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary is providing the protection for which it was designed.  "Good things have been happening in the Sanctuary over the past five years," said Department of Environmental Protection Secretary David B. Struhs. "The plan is clearly working. 'No Discharge Zones' along with 'No Take Zones' have improved water quality, protected reefs, and increased the number of reef fish."  In 1990, following the grounding of three large vessels on Florida Keys coral reefs, the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary and Protection Act was passed by Congress.  This law created the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, providing federal authority to implement regulations to protect marine resources in the Florida Keys.  
Copyright  © 200Florida Keys All rights reserved.

 

Letter to the Editor: Change in Ag Reserve plan will preserve more farmland
The medial have reported on a proposed amendment to the Palm Beach County comprehensive plan that would add a roadway frontage for a residential development to use when seeking development approval. This amendment would not increase density or the potential for any new development in the Agricultural Reserve Area.  The amendment is consistent with the policy to add new roads to preserve and protect agriculture. If the count commission approves the amendment, an additional 650 acres will be preserved for agriculture, adjacent to county-owned preserve, bringing the total of public and private reserves in the central Ag Reserve east of State Road 7 to 2,082 acres.  If it is approved, GL Homes has committed to provide land for several services identified as needs in the AG Reserve Master Palm, These include a park of 47 acres, sites schools and a civic center.  
Copyright  © 2002  
Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

 

Forecast for Future: Deluge and Drought
It has been a summer of extremes. Rains have deluged Europe and Asia, swamping cities and villages and killing some 2,000 people, while drought and heat have seared the American West and Eastern cities. What is going on? The floods and droughts could simply be flickers in the inherently chaotic weather system, some experts say. But many warn that such extremes will be increasingly common as the world grows warmer. Such a shift could pose big problems in places where water is already a strained resource, they say. "Their water use is already finely balanced, and based on hydrology they think they're going to get, and climate change is telling us they're going to get something different," said Dr. Peter H. Gleick, the director of the Pacific Institute, a private environmental research center in Oakland, Calif. A warmer world is more likely to be a wetter one, experts warn, with more evaporation resulting in more rain, in heavy and destructive downpours. But in a troublesome twist, that world may also include more intense droughts, as the increased evaporation parches soils between occasional storms. "In a hotter climate, your chances of being caught with either too much or too little are higher," said Dr. John M. Wallace, a professor of atmospheric sciences at the University of Washington. And the globe is getting warmer. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

Diplomat Tries to Bring Together Rich and Poor
The big man in pinstripes walks into the convention center here and the diplomats take notice. The Japanese delegation asks for a few minutes of his time. South African officials whisper in his ear. In their offices nearby, senior American officials praise his leadership. The unlikely celebrity, who has a cellphone glued to his ear, chuckles at all the fuss. He is John Ashe, a 48-year-old engineer (with a doctoral dissertation called "Electric-Field-Induced Deformation of Biological Cells") and an ambassador for one of the world's smallest countries, Antigua and Barbuda (population 67,000). He is, as he cheerfully admits, little known outside the world of international environmental conferences. But here, at the United Nations' World Summit on Sustainable Development, Mr. Ashe is one of the most influential diplomats. He is chairman of the meeting's trade and finance committee - the man charged with bringing together the rich and poor nations, which are feuding over how to reduce poverty while preserving the environment. Mr. Ashe honed his skills as a negotiator in conferences on global warming and climate change, where he has represented Antigua and other small island nations for more than a decade. But this job, diplomats say, might call for a miracle worker. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

Saving Water, U.S. Farmers Are Worried They'll Parch
Ronnie Hopper grows cotton, and he has learned firsthand that water is precious. The water that he pumps from underground costs him five times as much as it used to, so he does his best not to waste a drop. He has installed new, high-efficiency center-pivot sprinklers, designed to eliminate losses to evaporation. He has cut back on his planting on his 2,000-acre farm to concentrate water on fields that can use it best. He is even considering drip irrigation, water by the trickle. Mr. Hopper has reason to be parsimonious. Though he lives atop one of the world's largest aquifers, the Ogallala, which spans eight states, it is falling every day. Here in dry northwest Texas, the problem is particularly acute, with declines of at least three times the average. "Putting more wells in this particular ground would be like putting more straws in a glass," Mr. Hopper said, ruddy-faced in the Texas sun. People have warned of the threat to the aquifer, which supplies roughly a quarter of the United States' irrigated farmland, for more than 20 years, and it is still in danger. But the experience of farmers like Mr. Hopper offers reasons both for hope and caution for those struggling to save scarce water elsewhere, and to arrest drastic declines in other underground supplies in places like India and China. In a shift of much significance, per capita water use - on the rise in most of the rest of the world - is now declining in the United States. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved

 

27-August-02

Manatee plans in jumble
A federal sanctuary will govern part of Blue Waters part of the year.  Two proposed state sanctuaries would partly overlap part of the time. For years, local manatee lovers have complained that the endangered animals have been harassed in the Homosassa Blue Waters.  They said protections were needed to safeguard the lumbering herbivores.  Now, as another winter season creeps closer, it seems Blue Waters may get a double dose of safeguards.  Late last week, prompted by a federal judge, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service announced plans to establish an emergency manatee sanctuary at Blue Waters and other spots around the state. The federal sanctuary at Blue Waters will operate Oct. 1 through March 31.  Next month, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission will be asked to consider establishing two smaller sanctuaries at Blue Waters.  Those sanctuaries would be in effect between Nov. 15 and March 31.  The areas would not completely overlap: The federal sanctuary is much larger, encompassing a bigger part of the area that has been used in recent years as a manatee interaction spot just outside Homosassa Springs Wildlife State Park. The federal sanctuary also will include the closed part of the river inside the park and the spring run now inhabited by the state park's wild manatee herd.  
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.



TRUSTEES OF THE INTERNAL IMPROVEMENT TRUST FUND
Agenda - August 27, 2002
Substitute Page Twelve
Substitute tem 5
McIlvane Marsh Acquisition Project
Collier County is currently facing an unprecedented urban growth rate, with Naples leading the nation in metropolitan growth. Changes in land use within the primary watersheds that drain into the Rookery Bay estuary and adjacent water have been identified as the highest priority resource issue that threatens the long-term preservation of the RBNERR. The coastal habitats in Collier County have been impacted by alterations in hydrology and habitat, and development and channelization of natural systems.  Historically, freshwater traveled across the surface of the land, percolating through wetland flow ways, before entering McIlvane Marsh. An old road, known locally as the Belle Meade grade, now runs through this area with some smaller roadbeds feeding off from it. The roads have disrupted the natural hydrology and caused a shift in plant communities: mangroves encroach on the saltmarsh on the saline side and wax myrtles and other shrubs invade the saltmarsh on the freshwater side. This shift in plant communities has been further exacerbated by fire suppression.  Read more . . . 
Copyright  © 2002  Florida Department of State  All rights reserved.

                Related Articles,

                November 18, 2002
                U.S. FISH AND WILDLIFE SERVICE GRANTS FUND WETLAND CONSERVATION PROJECTS IN 15
                STATES

                November 30, 2002
                State gets $1 million to buy Collier County marsh

 

Guest Editorial: Challenging law good for citizens, too Sierra Club, others have right view for Florida.
We appreciate the opportunity to explain how Sierra Club diverges from the Palm Beach Post on the question of our litigation against a new state law restricting citizen rights of standing to protest local and state permitting decisions.  The attack on citizen standing, by Senator Jim King, R-Jacksonville, was attached during this year's legislative session to a bill providing for a portion of state financing for restoration of our Everglades. On Aug. 14, three months after Governor Bush signed this bill, Sierra Club and other plaintiffs sued to overturn the new law on constitutional grounds.  The Palm Beach Post opines that the state portion of Everglades funding is needed now, and that tomorrow--or some uncertain point in the future--is enough time for the governor and Legislature to restore what citizen rights were taken away, and that by spoiling "the party", some self-interested environmentalists, not even from this part of the state, are putting the Everglades at risk.  
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Mbeki's Plea: End 'Inertia'


Agence France-Presse  
President Thabo Mbeki of South Africa called for an end to the 
rift between the world's rich and poor at the opening today of
the World Summit on Sustainable Development.

Following are excerpts from remarks prepared for delivery yesterday by President Thabo Mbeki of South Africa to open the World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg. A full version is available here.    

The 1992 Rio Earth Summit produced several landmark agreements aimed at halting and reversing environmental destruction, poverty and inequality. Agenda 21 placed at the center of the challenges facing humanity, the appropriate framework for sustainable development.
. . . It is no secret that the global community has, as yet, not demonstrated the will to implement the decisions it has freely adopted.  The tragic result of this is the avoidable increase in human misery and ecological degradation, including the growth of the gap between North and South. It is as though we are determined to regress to the most primitive condition of existence in the animal world, of the survival of the fittest. It is as though we have decided to spurn what the human intellect tells us, that the survival of the fittest only presages the destruction of all humanity.  
Read excerpts...
website:  World Summit on Sustainable Development (www.johannesburgsummit.org)  
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

World Development Forum Begins With a Rebuke

Tens of thousands of officials, environmentalists and advocates for the poor converged on this old mining city today to devise an ambitious blueprint to promote development while protecting natural resources.  Participants from all over the world flocked to the United Nations' World Summit on Sustainable Development in flowing African robes, Indian saris and pinstriped suits. They celebrated the spirit of global solidarity and vowed to hammer out a plan to protect rain forests, to clean polluted air and to help millions of people escape from poverty.   
Read more...
website:  World Summit on Sustainable Development (www.johannesburgsummit.org)  
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.
 

Chinese Will Move Waters to Quench Thirst of Cities


The New York Times
At huge cost — $58 billion — China plans to 
rechannel water from the Yangtze basin to the 
north. Zhou Ying carries water after school 
each day in northwest China.


The booming cities of northern China are parched and constrained by a growing shortage of water. Yet in China's rainy south, the mighty Yangtze River pours vast volumes, unused, into the sea.  So why not, Chinese leaders have long asked, cross the country with new canals, bringing that "wasted" water to where it is vitally needed for the country's progress?  In a world short of fresh water, one of the gravest challenges facing governments is that needs and supplies are often far apart. Now China, with water scarcity reaching the critical stage in sprawling showcase cities like Beijing and Tianjin, has embarked on one of history's great water-moving projects.  At huge cost and great risk to the environment, the government plans to rechannel vast rivers of water from the Yangtze basin to the thirsty north, over three pathways of nearly 1,000 miles each. The official price tag of $58 billion, nearly half to be spent in the next eight years, is more than twice that of the Three Gorges Dam, China's most recent mega-project now nearing completion.  Some officials speak of delivering new waters to a "green Beijing" in time for the 2008 Olympics, an indication of the political overtones of the project as well as the crash timetable.  "We have to sacrifice so that people in Beijing can drink water," said Zhang Jize, a 32-year-old farmer and father of two daughters who is among 370,000 people the plan will uproot.   
Read more...
Running Dry series,  http://www.nytimes.com/pages/world/worldspecial/index.html
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

Water Supply As Land-Use Issue On Table
The Southwest Florida Water Management District today will discuss ways to make water supply a larger part of counties' land-use planning. The district's governing board would like county commissions to consider the availability of water when making decisions on their comprehensive plans. Swiftmud, as the district is commonly known, approves or denies water use permits for developments, while county commissions make land-use and zoning decisions. The Swiftmud meeting begins at 9:30 a.m. at the district headquarters, 2379 Broad St., about 5 miles south of Brooksville on U.S. 41. 
Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune  All rights reserved.

Letter to the editor
State simply reevaluating quality of all water bodies

Regarding Sally Swartz's Aug. 14 column "State plays dirty on clean water,": The state is not redefining water-quality standards, nor is it taking 600 water bodies off the list of impaired waters. The process being implemented to identify and clean up polluted water bodies is based on science. The department is implementing a comprehensive, five-year plan to identify
water bodies that do not meet water-quality standards for their intended uses, such as fishing, swimming or as a source of drinking water. Each year, the department will identify impaired waters in specific basins in each of the state's watersheds. The process will continue for five years until all water bodies in Florida have been evaluated. The department will repeat this cycle every five years to continuously reevaluate and restore our waters.

Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Letter to the editor
Choose water over development

Re "Mining industry targets Everglades": The mining industry has won in Florida by promising to help the Everglades. I can see that we need limestone to further development; however, if the mining company ruins our groundwater, as it is suggested it might do, how will people be able to live in all the new developments? People cannot survive without water. Will South Florida be able to desalinate ocean water for drinking? When you politicians vote, think past the immediate gain. Look at what your decision may bring us in 10 years. This mining company is from Australia. What do they care if the people of South Florida have adequate drinking water? 

Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.

 
26-August-02
U.N. Forum Opens in Africa


Associated Press
Dancers performed yesterday in Johannesburg 
at a welcoming ceremony for the United Nations' 
World Summit on Sustainable Development.

A call for an end to the rift between the world's rich and poor marked the opening here today of the United Nations World Summit on Sustainable Development. 
"A global human society based on poverty for many and prosperity for a few, characterized by islands of wealth, surrounded by a sea of poverty, is unsustainable," President Thabo Mbeki of South Africa told delegates to the 10-day meeting.  "There is every need for us to demonstrate to the billions of people we lead," he said, that "we do not accept that human society should be constructed on the basis of a savage principle of the survival of the fittest."  The meeting is expected to attract more than 100 presidents and prime ministers from Africa, Europe, Asia and Latin America, who will devise a plan to protect the globe's atmosphere, lakes, forests and wildlife and focus on the link between poverty and environmental degradation. Officials hope to build on the ambitious, but poorly executed, agenda set at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro 10 years ago.  Leaders from the United States, Europe and developing nations have already agreed that reducing poverty must be a central element of the plan. But the question of how to do that and to ensure the survival of the globe's natural resources has left rich and poor nations bitterly divided. The dispute is likely to dominate the political negotiations here. In this continent of immense natural beauty and desperate poverty, the debate could hardly be more relevant.  
Read more...
website:  World Summit on Sustainable Development (www.johannesburgsummit.org)  
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

The Environmentalists Are Wrong
With the opening today of the United Nations World Summit on Sustainable Development in Johannesburg, we will be hearing a great deal about both concepts: sustainability and development. Traditionally, the developed nations of the West have shown greater concern for environmental sustainability, while the third world countries have a stronger desire for economic development. At big environmental gatherings, it is usually the priorities of the first world that carry the day. The challenge in Johannesburg will be whether we are ready to put development ahead of sustainability. If the United States leads the way, the world may finally find the courage to do so. Why does the developed world worry so much about sustainability? Because we constantly hear a litany of how the environment is in poor shape. Natural resources are running out. Population is growing, leaving less and less to eat. Species are becoming extinct in vast numbers. Forests are disappearing. The planet's air and water are getting ever more polluted. Human activity is, in short, defiling the earth - and as it does so, humanity may end up killing itself. There is, however, one problem: this litany is not supported by the evidence.  Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

 

Linking Poverty Aid to the Environment


Associated Press
South African President Thabo Mbeki, right, 
greeted Nitin Desai, U.N. Secretary General of 
the World Summit on Sustainable Development, 
which began today in Johannesburg.

The smoke settles over the rickety shacks and shabby houses as soon as this city wakes. Thousands of poor people without electricity burn scraps of wood in rusty tin cans to keep warm. Others burn coal in old stoves that belch soot and fumes into the cold morning air.  Poverty in crowded cities like this one and in sleepy villages as well is threatening the air, the waters and the forests of the developing world. On Monday, the United Nations' World Summit on Sustainable Development will be held here to try to focus the world's attention on the environment in these poor countries.  The 10-day meeting is expected to attract more than 100 presidents and prime ministers from Africa, Europe, Asia and Latin America, who will devise a plan to protect the globe's atmosphere, lakes, forests and wildlife and focus on the link between poverty and environmental degradation. Officials hope to build on the ambitious, but poorly executed, agenda set at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro 10 years ago.  
Read more...
website:  World Summit on Sustainable Development (www.johannesburgsummit.org)  
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

As Multinationals Run the Taps, Anger Rises Over Water for Profit     

      

SAN ISIDRO DE LULES, Argentina — When Jorge Abdala's water bill jumped to 59 pesos a month from 24 a few years ago, he went looking for someone to blame. He soon found his villain: a French multinational company at the forefront of a global effort to privatize government-run water systems.  Mr. Abdala, a soft-spoken 54-year-old, scarcely seems the revolutionary. Scrambling for a living like most of his neighbors in this sprawling town tucked up under the Andes, he runs a meager catering business out of his kitchen.  But the protests Mr. Abdala organized here forced the company, now known as Vivendi Environnement , to abandon its long-term contract to overhaul and manage the waterworks of the Tucumán Province, where Mr. Abdala and roughly one million other Argentines live.  "Our main demand was, simply, `Go home!' " he said, shifting to the edge of his seat in the living room of his simple one-story home. "We kept presenting facts showing that they were not making any investments, just raising the price of water. And any investments they made were with government money."     
Read more...
Running Dry series,  http://www.nytimes.com/pages/world/worldspecial/index.html
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

Ten Years Later, The Memories Are Still Vivid

 

 

 

With winds of 145 mph, a 10-mile wide eye and 16.9 feet storm surges, made Andrew the nations most costly natural disaster and left South Floridians fearful and battered. Andrew first made U.S. landfall on August 24, 1992 at 5:00 a.m., and for the next several hours, pounded South Florida with wind gusts up to 170 mph, as it moved west at 18 mph. According to The Weather Channel, Andrew reached hurricane strength 300 miles east of the central Bahamas, and crashed through the islands. Its 120 mph winds induced a massive surge, in which four people drowned. The hurricane gained strength as it swirled through the warm waters of the Florida Straits. Along Florida's east coast, a massive evacuation had already begun. According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), massive evacuations were ordered in Florida as it became evident that likelihood of Andrew making landfall in those regions increased. Read More...
Copyright  © 2002  NBC6  All rights reserved.

Previous Stories:

   August 22, 2002: After 10 Years, Hurricane Andrew Gains Strength
      http://www.nbc6.net/News/1623854/detail.html

   August 22, 2002: Hurricane Andrew: Ten Years After
      http://www.nbc6.net/News/1618270/detail.html

   August 22, 2002: Visual Echoes Of Andrew
      http://www.nbc6.net/News/1624502/detail.html

   August 21, 2002: Miami Sportscaster Recalls Post-Andrew Plane Crash
      http://www.nbc6.net/News/1622278/detail.html

   August 19, 2002: Memories Of Hurricane Andrew
      http://www.nbc6.net/News/1464051/detail.html

 

25-August-02

Manatees gain 3 havens in Tampa Bay in winter
In response to a judge's order, a federal agency limits human activity around three power plants and Blue Waters in winter.
To protect manatees, parts of Tampa Bay near three power plants will be put off-limits to boaters, swimmers, divers and anglers for half the year, from Oct. 1 to March 31, federal officials announced Saturday.
During that time, boats would be limited to slow or idle speeds in the areas adjacent to Tampa Bay's three power plants -- in Tampa, Apollo Beach and Weedon Island -- as an additional step to spare manatees from being harassed, hurt or killed, federal officials said. The headwaters of the Homosassa River in Citrus County, an area known as Blue Waters, will also be put off-limits to all forms of human activity from Oct. 1 to March 31, federal wildlife officials said. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's announcement came as a response to a federal judge's order that the agency pinpoint waterways around the state where "there is substantial evidence that there is imminent danger of a taking of one or more manatees," meaning they would require emergency action to protect them.
 
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

To find out more

For information on the sanctuaries and refuges, go to
http://northflorida.fws.gov/Manatee/manatees.htm

Restoring the Everglades
The Army Corps of Engineers and the South Florida Water Management District are conducting test and buying water-storage land in preparation for an $8.4 billion project to restore proper water flow in the Everglades. Here's a look at the plan and why it is needed:The Everglades are fed from water that overflow Lake Okeechobee's southern shore. Originally 60 miles wide, this sheet of shallow water slowly made its way south across Florida's flat grasslands. 

Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.


In Race to Tap the Euphrates, the Upper Hand Is Upstream


Ruth Fremson/The New York Times
Zuheyya Aygul returns from a nearby irrigation
canal in southern Turkey.


The Euphrates River is close by, but the water does not reach Abdelrazak al-Aween. Here at the heart of the fertile crescent, he stares at dry fields.  The Syrian government has promised water for Mr. Aween's tiny village. But upstream, in Turkey, and downstream, in Iraq, similar promises are being made. They add up to more water than the Euphrates holds.  So instead of irrigating his cotton and sugar beets, Mr. Aween must siphon drinking and washing water from a ditch 40 minutes away by tractor ride. Just across the border, meanwhile, Ahmet Demir, a Turkish farmer, stands ankle deep in mud, his crops soaking up all the water they need.  It was here in ancient Mesopotamia, thousands of years ago, that the last all-out war over water was fought, between rival city-states in what is now southern Iraq. Now, across a widening swath of the world, more and more people are vying for less and less water, in conflicts more rancorous by the day.  
Read more...
Running Dry series,  http://www.nytimes.com/pages/world/worldspecial/index.html
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

Lake Istokpoga's phosphorus levels are still rising
Editor's Note: This is another in the series on the effect of phosphorus on
Lake Istokpoga and the Everglades watershed.
Sebring - Florida has few natural resources, but it does have plenty of phosphorus, the stuff that makes plants grow. Too much of it make plants grow until they choke lakes and other waterways. The most recent example was the Lake Istokpoga tussock removal projects that ended about a year ago and opened about 1,300 acres to watercraft navigation and recreational fishing. It cost about $3 million. Since then, hundreds of samples have been taken by Dr. Jenifer Brunty, a Highlands County natural resources specialist, and Paul Ritter, a staff environment analyst for the South Florida Water Management District.c
Copyright  © 200News Sun All rights reserved.

S.A.F.E.R. making waves in 'Glades
The fight to keep Everglades canals from being filled in is far from over, but things are looking a lot better thanks to the efforts of the South Florida Anglers For Everglades Restoration. When S.A.F.E.R. first formed a little more than a year ago, the agencies in charge of overseeing the restoration of the Everglades didn't even know that people fished in the water conservation areas of the 'Glades. Not filling in the canals was not even considered by those looking at options for restoring the historical flow of water in the Everglades. The members of S.A.F.E.R., most of whom represent South Florida bass clubs, are committed to restoration with recreation. The canals that they fish offer some of the best bass fishing in the country and have a significant economic impact in terms of bait, tackle, gas, food, drinks, ice and the like. When nearly 100 boats competed in a S.A.F.E.R.-sponsored bass tournament in May, several people pointed out that the boats and tow vehicles alone at Everglades Holiday Park represented several million dollars. 

Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Everglades restoration threatened
If Everglades restoration is really about restoring the Everglades, Congress should act quickly to clear an obstacle that threatens to delay some of the restoration's most important environmental benefits. This little epic is a maddening example of the politics that swirl so densely around restoration, especially when a local dispute over Everglades policy gets caught up in a national political culture war. This kind of thing is likely to dog the $8 billion federal-state project through its life. More specifically, this impasse reinforces the suspicion that the project is more about making sure cities and farms have enough water than about restoring the much-altered South Florida environment. Part of the restoration plan calls for filling some canals and breaching certain levees to allow water to run essentially where it did under natural conditions, south into what is now Everglades National Park. But that element in the project may be delayed by at least two years because of a festering controversy over a separate project, also designed to restore natural water flows. The separate project, known as Mod Waters, or "Modified Water Deliveries," is caught up in a 13-year-old property rights dispute that has become a national cause to opponents of big government. 

Copyright  © 2002  Fort Meyers News Press  All rights reserved.

Reserve project on table
When it is no longer a dusty path leading to vegetable fields, nurseries and a few modest homes, Acme Dairy Road will stir memories of south county's agricultural heritage by its name only. But before asphalt pours over this dusty road and bulldozers clear the surrounding countryside, the debate between progress and preservation will come to a head at a County Commission meeting Wednesday morning. At issue is how GL Homes will be allowed to develop a 1,500-home community on 1,500 acres of Agricultural Reserve land off Boynton Beach Boulevard, between Florida's Turnpike and the future extension of Lyons Road. GL Homes is asking commissioners to amend the county's comprehensive plan so that the main entrances to its subdivisions can be built on Acme Dairy Road. The current plan allows main access to new developments along only five roads in the reserve: Boynton Beach Boulevard, Atlantic Avenue, U.S. 441, Clint Moore Road and parts of Lyons Road. 

Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.

Environmentalists Criticize Endangered Species List
The state's official roster of endangered species, facing widespread criticism from environmentalists, may be overhauled again. Bald eagles could be dropped, bobwhite quail added and gopher tortoises bumped up into a classification of higher concern. The state Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission will decide early next month what to do with the list it uses to prioritize efforts for saving animals from extinction. "We want it to be scientifically rigorous, and we want it to be objective," said Brian Millsap, a commission biologist in Tallahassee and an administrator of the wildlife list. "It may always be controversial at some level, and we may have to accept that." Decisions about bald eagles, bobwhite quail and gopher tortoises could be put off for a couple of years, depending on whether the commission board opts for partial or wholesale revisions to list guidelines. 
Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune / Associated Press  All rights reserved.

Related Links:

FLORIDA'S ENDANGERED SPECIES, THREATENED SPECIES AND
SPECIES OF SPECIAL CONCERN
Official Lists
Publication Date: 1 August 1997
http://www.floridaconservation.org/pubs/endanger.html

 

24-August-02

 

Editorial: Environmentalists Are Right To Seek Ditching Of Errant Law
A coalition of Florida environmental groups is seeking to overturn a state law that curtails citizens' ability to contest government decisions. The challenge is being made on technical grounds. The groups rightly say the law violates the Florida Constitution's single-subject rule, which states that two or more unrelated subjects can't be in one law. The slippery effort to muffle citizens' legal voice was tagged onto an Everglades restoration bill in the closing hours of the Legislature. This was typical of the bullying tactics of Sen. Jim King, who was determined to pass the measure. The Jacksonville Republican is scheduled to become the next Senate president. King initially sought to virtually eliminate citizens' ability to legally contest a development permit by narrowly defining the parties eligible to file a challenge. While the measure was moderated during the late-session push, it still represents an affront to the public. 
Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune  All rights reserved.

DEP's deeper problem
A state appeals court ruled this week that the Department of Environmental Protection can't decide on a permit for a new phosphate mine in Manatee County because of prejudicial comments made by DEP Secretary David Struhs. As welcome as the ruling is, a much deeper problem at the DEP -- the agency's failure to provide, or even seek, an independent analysis of the impact of phosphate mining -- remains unaddressed by state officials. In a 2-1 decision Thursday, the 1st Court of Appeal in Tallahassee ruled that Struhs and his agency must disqualify themselves from acting on a request by IMC Phosphates for a permit to mine 3,000 acres northeast of Bradenton. The ruling centers on statements that Struhs made last spring after an administrative law judge ruled that DEP's review of the application complied with department rules and state law. Although the matter was still in litigation and DEP had not delivered a final decision on the permit, Struhs issued a press release celebrating the administrative law judge's ruling. Struhs said, among other things, that the public could "feel comforted" by the judge's decision. 

Copyright  © 2002  Herald Tribune  All rights reserved.

Researchers: Latest dark water events not troubling
Spotting black water off Southwest Florida's coast over the summer apparently isn't all that remarkable or worrisome. Researchers looking into recent reports of dark water off Sanibel Island and in the Ten Thousand Islands are ascribing those events to relatively harmless algae blooms that tend to crop up during the rainy season.



Sanibel Island pilot Jim Anderson said he took this picture around 10 a.m. Aug. 1. The view is across the northward bend of Sanibel Island, looking toward the Gulf of Mexico. The black mass of water was within yards of shore and stretched to sea almost a mile, Anderson said. He did not know how far south it went. Photo courtesy of Jim Anderson

The masses of water, which have dissipated over the last two weeks, bear little organic resemblance to the mysterious expanse of black water that appeared last January between Cape Romano and the Florida Keys, they say. That earlier black water event consisted of a mixture of red tide, other algae blooms and river runoff, researchers concluded. At least one coral expert has said the event is the No. 1 suspect in the devastation of coral in that region. 
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

 

 

23-August-02

Anonymous donor may help FGCU build engineering school
An engineering school may be on the horizon for Florida Gulf Coast University. FGCU President William Merwin said Thursday in his annual "State of the University" address that an anonymous donor is seriously considering giving a gift that would make an engineering program and school possible. "It's not in the bag yet, but it's possible we'll have a major engineering program," Merwin said in his morning speech to the faculty. "I'm thinking, for us, along the lines of environmental engineering, software engineering and biotechnological engineering." Merwin, who became FGCU's second president in 1999, told of the university's accomplishments and milestones in its five-year history. He also told about projects coming up in its future in his annual speech, which he delivered to staff members Thursday afternoon. Merwin specifically addressed some issues raised early this year in a Faculty Climate Survey, such as FGCU's mission statement and a communication gap between himself and the faculty. The mission statement, he said, is undergoing revision and will be considered by the FGCU Board of Trustees. He plans to hold quarterly forums with the faculty in a town-hall format and meet with each of the university's five colleges.  


Bush Defends Logging Initiative as a Better Means of Management Against Forest Fires  
Stepping through the blackened cinders left by one of the worst forest fires in Oregon's history, President Bush asserted today that his proposal to allow more logging in national forests would prevent catastrophic blazes and lift local economies.  Mr. Bush denounced critics who described his plan as a giveaway for the timber industry.  "What the critics need to do is come and see firsthand the effect of bad forest policy," Mr. Bush said as he walked through a charred stand of Douglas fir and ponderosa pine on Squires Peak, trailed by a clutch of cameras and reporters. "That's what they need to come and see."  "And by the way, there's nothing wrong with people being able to earn a living off of effective forest management," Mr. Bush continued. "There are a lot of people in this part of the state who can't find work."  Mr. Bush flew here this morning from his ranch in Texas for an evocative backdrop to press his proposal to allow more logging of national forestland. He said his plan would remove small trees that have contributed to one of the worst forest fire seasons in the nation's history.  Air Force One flew low and slowly over the Biscuit fire, which started on July 27 and quickly became the largest fire in the state's history at 471,000 acres, banking to starboard to give Mr. Bush a view.   Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

Letter to Editor 
Atlas Shrugged, and where is full cost accounting?

What Ms. Pena fails to mention in her justification of sustaining low-density residences on a flood plain, all part of the historic Everglades,  is the cost to the rest of the taxpayers to acquiesce to the non-buyout position.  Taxpayers have a right to know how much they are paying and for what. A full cost accounting would reveal that we, the people, will have to pay something  on the order of $200,000 to  $500,000 per residency over the 50 year life cycle of the Conceptual Everglades Restoration Plan to execute the non-buyout option.   A range has to be given because of all costs considerations and some crystal ball projections:   (1) The capital investment  to install more levees, canals and pumps per square mile in the history of draining Florida Wetlands; (2) the inevitable adverse environmental impact from (1);  (3) the cost of fossil fuel to run the pumps over a 50 year life cycle, and probability of having to go to alternative fuels; (5) Hurricane damage and intense flooding which will inevitably come, and the fact that water managers have indicated there is no possibility of much flood protection here;  (6) Septic tanks in the water table; (7) more infrastructure that is sure to follow; and (8), the further trashing of Everglades National Park as more negative value to public lands that are also the property of the taxpayer. 

Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

 

22-August-02

Officials Agree: Polk Needs Water Plan
It will include policies on source development and conservation.
Polk County should have a water plan a year from now, county commissioners agreed Wednesday.
The discussion occurred as commissioners approved a charge for the next stage of the deliberations of the Polk County Water Policy Advisory Committee. "We need a master plan," said Commissioner Don Gifford, who has pushed the commission to become more active on water issues. Gifford and other commissioners envision a plan that could be incorporated into the county's growth plan. It will include policies on how to develop more sources of water, such as reservoirs or aquifer storage, and increased emphasis on water conservation.
In addition, Gifford said there should be some long-range planning on the disposition of reuse water, much of which is now planned to offset the use of groundwater for lawn and agricultural irrigation. That could renew the debate over how receptive Polk County should be to new power plants, all of which create additional water demands of millions of gallons per day, and what kinds of land uses the county should encourage or discourage with an eye toward future water demand.  
Copyright  © 2002  The Ledger All rights reserved.

U.S. environment groups see threat to green rules
U.S. environmental groups said on Thursday
they fear President George W. Bush may weaken more rules protecting air, land and water after he announced a plan to ease regulations for logging in fire-prone forests.
The groups expect the administration to move to open up more Western land to oil and gas drilling, and to push to roll back water pollution programs
and air pollution limits on utilities.
"Given Bush's track record on everything from global warming to forest protection to energy policy, their record says that they are listening to
the special interests at the expense of the environment," said Tiernan Sittenfeld, spokeswoman for the U.S. Public Interest Research Group. 

Copyright  © 2002  Forbes  All rights reserved.

 

21-August-02

Environmental groups sue to stop expansion of mining in Everglades
The Army Corps of Engineers ignored years of warnings and criticism - and four federal laws - in approving rock mining permits across 5,000 acres of sensitive Everglades wetlands, claims a federal lawsuit filed Tuesday. Three environmental groups filed the suit in U.S. District Court for the Washington, D.C., circuit in an attempt to have those permits revoked.
The Sierra Club, the Natural Resources Defense Council and the National Parks Conservation Association also accuse the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service of ignoring its duties as the Corps' environmental overseer by allowing the permits, despite many documented concerns its officials had expressed about them. The permits at issue are in an area of western Miami-Dade County known as the Lake Belt, a major component of the $8 billion Everglades restoration plan Congress approved in 2000. The Lake Belt envisions turning two major mining pits into water storage areas once the miners are done there, in 35 to 50 years.

Commercial catches down again
For commercial fishermen in the Keys, the official numbers offer no consolation, only confirmation of what they already knew: Last year was a disaster. Key West had a nearly $10 million drop in income from its commercial fishery from 2000 to 2001, according to figures released by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. The Key West fishery, which is defined by NOAA as all of the Florida Keys, pulled in $50.6 million in 2000, compared to $40 million in 2001, NOAA said. The reason, of course, is lobster – more specifically, the lack of them. Last year was the worst in decades for lobster landings. Catches of the spiny crustacean normally are between 5 million and 7 million pounds. Only slightly more than 3 million pounds were hauled in last year. Shrimp and lobster account for the majority of the overall fishery in the Keys in terms of income, followed by stone crab and assorted finfish like kingfish and Spanish mackerel. Though the Key West fishery usually ranks fairly low among national seafood p orts in total volume, it is a consistent finisher in the Top 10 in terms of income because of the local high-value products – lobster, shrimp and stone crab. Even so, there is reason for concern there, as well. 
Copyright  © 200Florida Keys Keynoter All rights reserved.

Suit Challenges Everglades Limestone Mining
Environmental groups are suing two federal agencies to block limestone mining on more than 5,000 acres of Everglades wetlands. The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), Sierra Club and National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA) said they fear the mining project, which has been approved by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, would threaten Everglades National Park and the historic environmental restoration projects now getting underway in southern Florida. The groups filed suit Tuesday in federal district court in Washington DC against the Corps and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) challenging the agencies permitting of a massive mining operation on the national park's border. The approvals are part of the mining industry's long term plans for a total of over 22,000 acres of mining in the eastern Everglades, an area the size of the city of Miami. Despite its own conclusion that the mining "will have an irreversible significant impact on the environmental resources of this region," the Corps has issued 12 permit approvals to 10 companies since announcing its decision on April 11, 2002.
Copyright  © 2002  Environment News Service (ENS)  All Rights Reserved.               

EDITORIAL: Everyone should be able to challenge government
Good luck to the coalition of Florida environmental groups that sued to restore the public's right to challenge government decisions.
At issue is a provision sneakily attached in the closing hours of a legislative session earlier this year to a critical funding bill for Everglades restoration, and signed into law with that bill by the governor. The groups challenging the measure say it violates a constitutional ban on dealing with completely different subject areas in the same bill. It would be nice to see the courts start enforcing this potentially valuable but oft-skirted part of the constitution. The provision limits the ability of citizens and organizations to challenge development permits. The measure is a naked favor for business interests who want to be free of citizen challenges. Only organizations that have been in existence for at least a year and have 25 or more members living in the county where the permit is sought can challenge the project. That rules out many local citizen groups formed just to fight a project. It also denies project opponents the assistance they need from state and federal organizations in fighting powerful developers. This is one of the worst, most anti-democratic measures the Legislature and governor have approved in recent years. If the courts fail to act on the basis of the state Constitution, the issue should be brought back up for repeal when the Legislature meets again. Beyond that, what's needed is legislation - maybe even a constitutional amendment, although we wince at suggesting more of those - that would limit legislators' ability to sneak pernicious measures like this into the law at the last minute in a session. Copyright  © 2002  Fort Meyers News Press  All rights reserved.

Environmental Groups Sue to Block Florida Mining
Environmental activists sued the Bush administration yesterday to try to stop a limestone mining plan that would destroy 15,000 acres of wetlands in the Florida Everglades, saying the plan would literally and figuratively undermine the largest environmental restoration project in U.S. history. The Army Corps of Engineers approved the first permits for the 50-year Lake Belt mining plan in April, even though its own documents had said the plan "will have an irreversible significant impact on the environmental resources of this region." Half the Everglades has been drained or paved, and the National Park Service, the Environmental Protection Agency and other federal, state and local agencies have warned that the plan to sacrifice another swath of wetlands the size of Miami could cause severe additional damage. 

Copyright  © 2002  Washington Post  All rights reserved.

 

Attack of the grasshoppers: Giant, toxic insects are invading Central Florida
A plague of monstrous grasshoppers too nasty-tempered and toxic to be eaten by predators and too big to be bothered by conventional pesticides are on the rampage in Central Florida this summer. However, the Treasure Coast has been spared an outbreak of the 4-inch creatures that chow down on citrus trees, vegetable gardens and flower smorgasbords throughout the Southern United States. At least, for now. "I saw one today, but I have not heard anyone say that they have been a serious problem," said Carol Cloud Bailey, agricultural extension office director in Martin County. It's a problem of horror-movie proportions that lurks in the grasses of Lake and other Central Florida counties. The Eastern lubber grasshoppers, also seen near the St. Lucie County agricultural extension office, are ugly, king-sized and laugh at the idea of bug spray.  

Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Question persists: Did she sign oath?
An elections clerk raises additional questions about paperwork filed on behalf of a statewide candidate. New questions emerged Tuesday over a disputed document submitted to elections officials on behalf of Democrat Mary Barley, a millionaire environmentalist running for agriculture commissioner. Barley is accused in a lawsuit of submitting a forged document to elections officials. The suit seeks to remove her from the Sept. 10 Democratic primary. In Tuesday's development, a clerk at the Florida Division of Elections said in a sworn statement that she was standing at a counter July 26 when a man presented Barley's required paperwork. The clerk, Kelly Davio, told the man a loyalty oath required of all candidates was missing.
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Groups try to halt Everglades mining
A lawsuit says the work will destroy water flow and drive out endangered wood storks. Three environmental groups filed suit Tuesday to stop politically influential mining companies from continuing to blast big pits in the Everglades. The suit seeks to overturn permits recently issued by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for mining limestone from 5,000 swampy acres in western Miami-Dade County over the next 10 years. "It's the ugliest of politics doing the worst to the environment," said Barbara Lange, Everglades co-chair for the Sierra Club's Miami group. The suit was filed against the Corps of Engineers and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in federal court in Washington, D.C., by the Sierra Club, Natural Resources Defense Council and National Parks Conservation Association.  

Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Commentary:  Grasshopper plague story doesn't have legs
By Frank Cerabino       
No summer would be complete without a natural menace on the loose. 
Last summer we got carried away with shark attacks. West Nile Virus shows signs of being an up-and-comer. And this summer there was that Asian fish in Maryland that defies its limits by walking from pond to pond. (The Lois Frankel Fish -- at least that's what I call it.)  But now we have a late addition to an already crowded field of summer plagues.  I'm talking about giant grasshoppers. Orange and yellow ones with reddish spots. Said to grow 4 inches long, although they're mostly shorter than that.  Read more . . . 
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times, AP online  All rights reserved.


Bush, Citing Fire Hazards, Wants Logging Rules Eased
President Bush will ask Congress to relax environmental laws so that the timber industry can accelerate cutting efforts across millions of acres of national forest land increasingly prone to devastating wildfires, senior administration officials said today.  The plan is to be made public on Thursday, when Mr. Bush travels to southern Oregon to view recent fire damage there. But word of its basic thrust has already ignited a new political fight, with environmentalists condemning what they called a White House effort to promote rejuvenated logging under the guise of fire prevention.  After two summers in three in which the West has suffered devastating wildfires, Congress has already thrown its support, backed by hundreds of millions of dollars, behind a national plan to remove more brush and undergrowth from public lands to make them less susceptible to blazes.  Read more . . . 
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times, AP online  All rights reserved.


NY Times Editorial:   
New Threats to Clean Water
The environmental community and the Bush administration are at odds again, this time over proposed changes in a key part of the Clean Water Act. The changes would give states greater leeway in deciding which waterways need to be cleaned and how rapidly to do the job. The administration says that such flexibility is necessary to make the act work. Environmentalists fear yet another rollback of existing protections.  The specific regulation at issue is known, forbiddingly, as the T.M.D.L. program — for total maximum daily load. The Clean Water Act has done an admirable job of regulating so-called end-of-pipe pollution from readily identifiable sources like factories and waste treatment plants. The T.M.D.L. regulation is aimed at controlling polluted runoff from more diffuse sources like farms, timber operations and city streets. This runoff is the main reason that 40 percent of the country's waters — some 20,000 rivers, lakes and estuaries altogether — are still too polluted for fishing or swimming.  
Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

20-August-02

Mangrove expert backs proposal to help get marina project moving
By Eric Staats
A scientist's report about sick mangroves at the proposed Hamilton Harbor marina site on Naples Bay could help move a tangle of lawsuits over the project toward settlement. The four-page report by University of Miami professor Samuel Snedaker, a recognized mangrove expert, backs a 2-year-old proposal by developer Collier Enterprises to put the sick mangroves into a special zoning category where city codes make it easier to get marina approvals. In 1999, marina foes challenged the Naples City Council's decision to approve Hamilton Harbor. A newly elected City Council yanked approvals for Hamilton Harbor in 2000, unleashing a $25 million lawsuit and a $19 million property rights claim against the city by Collier Enterprises.
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved

New chief buoys water district
Maybe it was an omen. More than a year into a ruinous drought, South Florida's lawns were crackling. And tempers were rising among the water managers handling the crisis -- not just about the dry spell, but the infighting that had overtaken their agency. Enter Henry Dean. It rained nearly 3 inches the week of July 11, 2001, when Dean officially took over as executive director of the South Florida Water Management District. Within three months, watering restrictions were history. And by all accounts, Dean's reign has brought a cooling of tensions at the 16-county agency in charge of running an $8.4 billion Everglades restoration, which ranks as the world's biggest ecological repair job. At the very least, it's been more than a year since disputes among senior district managers prompted the board to squabble in front of school children.  

Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Taming the untouchable corps
There are not many issues that the liberal Tom Daschle of South Dakota and the conservative Robert Smith of New Hampshire agree on. But when Congress reconvenes, these two senators, along with the campaign finance mavericks John McCain and Russell Feingold, are determined to challenge the self-interest of many of their colleagues by instituting a top-to-bottom overhaul of the Army Corps of Engineers. Their objectives are twofold. One is to make sure that the Army Corps' multibillion-dollar construction budget is spent on vital infrastructure, not wasteful pork-barrel projects ordered up by individual members of Congress. Read more...

Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

NY Times Science Special:  Managing Planet Earth

Several articles    

http://www.nytimes.com/indexes/2002/08/20/science/index.html   
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

Judges Discuss Environmental Issues
BENONI, South Africa (AP) -- Some of the world's top judges swapped ideas Tuesday on how to best enforce environmental laws at a meeting ahead of the World Summit on Sustainable Development.  The U.N.-sponsored conference brought together judges from countries as diverse as Costa Rica and Tanzania to discuss ways to enforce environmental legislation, such as establishing an international environmental court or setting up training programs for judges in environmental science and policy.  ``The fragile state of the global environment requires the judiciary, as the primary guardian of the rule of law, to boldly and fearlessly implement and enforce international and national laws,'' a resolution adopted by the group read.   
Read more...
website:  World Summit on Sustainable Development (www.johannesburgsummit.org)  
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times online  All rights reserved.

 

19-August-02

Farming's uncertain future
Steven Borek Jr. is a farmer, and a farmer he wants to stay. Like his father, who died when the boy was 3, and his grandfather before that, Borek has tilled thousands of acres of Homestead's rich soil, coaxed beans, tomatoes and corn from its depths, and risen before countless sunups to shelter his family's crops from ferocious frosts. ''My son wants to farm; he's just like his father,'' said Steven's mother, Teena Borek. Together, mother and son farm 315 acres -- 95 percent of it leased. A decade ago, they worked 1,000 acres but were forced off most of it by rising rent and plummeting crop values. ''But I'm afraid for him in farming because the chances economically are very slim.'' Subject to and subjugated by nature, vulnerable to consumer whims and changing trade winds, the fragility of farming is nothing new. But in southern Miami-Dade County, home to a $1 billion agricultural industry, a recent University of Florida report confirms what the scores of potato, tomato and corn farmers already know: The region's row crop industry is dying, and the chances for large-scale farms' survival have never been as slim. 
Copyright  © 2002  Miami Herald  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Sugar's bow comes early
Last week, the sugar-cane growers south of Lake Okeechobee awarded their annual self-congratulations for putting less pollution into the Everglades than they were a decade ago. Under the Everglades Forever Act, the growers and taxpayers are financing a system of marshes to reduce phosphorus in water that flows from the farms into the Everglades, where it kills natural vegetation and harms wildlife.  
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Sign-waving protesters decry runway project
Residents of five neighborhoods just south and west of the Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport took to the streets on Sunday, protesting the proposed south runway expansion project that will face a County Commission vote on Tuesday.
Standing at the intersection at Griffin Road and Northwest 10th Avenue, a gateway to the airport on the north and Dania Beach's Melaleuca Gardens neighborhood to the south, about 20 opponents of runway expansion waved signs and shouted slogans at passing motorists from 10 a.m. until noon.  
Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.

Bonita YMCA seeks land donations to help in building mitigation
Got a low-lying piece of land in south Lee County or north Collier you're not doing anything with? If so, the Bonita Springs YMCA wants to talk to you.
YMCA board members hope to work out a creative arrangement that would give a property owner a tax deduction and give the Y a place to do mitigation work necessary to earn a South Florida Water Management District permit. The process would work like this: The landowner would give his property to the YMCA and be able to claim the donation as a deduction at tax time. 
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

Area gets big return on district water taxes
Several fixes to the environment - such as the Lake Trafford restoration, a Caloosahatchee River reservoir and the rehydrating of southeast Lee County - are bringing millions of dollars back to Southwest Florida for the next year. The five-county region will get back $76.1 million in projects and administration for the $46.1 million property owners are expected to pay to the South Florida Water Management District in the 2002-03 fiscal year, according to preliminary budget estimates.  
Copyright  © 2002  Fort Meyers News Press  All rights reserved.

Editorial: We need to protect our river: Caloosahatchee can't be left out of Everglades project
As the Everglades restoration project looks more and more like a water grab by Central Florida and east coast interests, it's vital for Lee County to stake a claim to water for the Caloosahatchee River and its estuaries. It's good that county commissioners have asked the South Florida Water Management District for just such a guarantee for the river. The river, linked to the rest of the sprawling South Florida Water Management District through Lake Okeechobee, has not traditionally loomed large in the district's distant West Palm Beach headquarters.  
Copyright  © 2002  Fort Meyers News Press  All rights reserved.

Land by Lake Apopka has new chance at life
Four years ago, horrified biologists scrambled to pick up hundreds of birds that suffered convulsions and died after the big farms around Lake Apopka were flooded in a marsh-restoration effort. For the first time since that disaster -- one of the nation's worst pesticide poisonings of wildlife -- authorities Thursday again will divert water onto Lake Apopka farmland. Without ceremony, water managers will open floodgates, putting back on track ambitious work to restore the terribly polluted lake's marshes and shallows. 
Copyright  © 2002  Orlando Sentinel  All Rights Reserved.

Runway meeting in holding pattern
An airliner departs Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport with the city skyline below. Broward County officials on Monday abruptly postponed a meeting that could have determined whether the south runway expansion is built at Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport. The topic has become too controversial and political to be decided by a subcommittee without a full airing before the County Commission, said County Administrator Roger Desjarlais, who canceled the meeting. ''I just wanted to give the board the opportunity to have the conversation,'' Desjarlais said. ``From a timing perspective, it's much better.''  
Copyright  © 2002  Miami Herald  All rights reserved.
 

Everglades plan aims to reverse history
At dusk, Jim Raines likes to drive to this quiet spot on the city edge, sit on his pickup's tailgate and listen to Florida primeval: sea breezes rustling the saw grass, the endless buzz of
mosquitoes and the thick bubbles bursting out of the muck of an alligator- infested swamp.
"Spooky, ain't it," he muses, as a big splash is heard deeper inside the 11,655-square-kilometre swamp known as the Florida Everglades. "Probably a 'gator going after a critter. Sitting here, it gets you back to nature." Getting back to nature is an increasingly difficult thing to do in Florida. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  Globe and Mail  All rights reserved.

 

18-August-02

Commissioners ready to take new look at 951 extension
Lee County commissioners stand ready to hire an engineer for the extension of Collier Boulevard/County Road 951, a project that might eventually run all the way from Immokalee Road in Collier to Alico Road in Lee. Collier kicked in $250,000 toward the $2.5 million cost of a Project Development and Environmental study. The counties are working together on what could be the fourth north-south arterial road connecting the two. 
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

Editorial Reply: Criticism of environmental agencies missed the mark
Your newspaper's commitment to reporting on issues pertaining to threats to marine resources of Southwest Florida and the Keys is appreciated. However, The Ocean Conservancy must disagree with your conclusion that state and federal environmental agencies have shown a "lack of concern or even acquiescence" in the face of algae blooms, coral loss and last winter's blackwater event.  
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

 

17-August-02

Wildlife Habitat Accord Reached
Bald eagles, sandhill cranes and many other species of wildlife will be the winners in a deal announced this week that would create a 18,182-acre ribbon of wildlife habitat stretching from Lake Kissimmee to Lake Pierce in eastern Polk County. The proposed $38 million deal funded by the state and the South Florida Water Management District would involve the purchase of 5,830-acre Rolling Meadow Ranch, owned by Andrew Machata.  
Copyright  © 2002  The Ledger All rights reserved.

Judge Asks Government to Make Report on Florida Manatee Protection
A judge ordered federal officials to list waterways where manatees are in danger in Florida and report on how these areas are being turned into emergency protection zones.
U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan, in a ruling Friday, said U.S. Department of Interior and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service officials must present him with the list of waterways where manatees face imminent danger of being killed by boats by Aug. 23.
Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Mining requires regulation; Lee should step up efforts to manage thriving industry
Lee County's thriving rock-mining industry has hit some bumps lately, bringing home again the urgent need for better county regulation of this business.
Residents in a southeast county neighborhood persuaded county commissioners this month to keep a mining operation out of their area. The commissioners may have been sensitized to residential concerns by an earlier and bitter controversy over another operation near the Briarcliff neighborhood, where structures were cracked, well levels lowered and ponds drained. The industry can be forgiven for feeling nervous.  
Copyright  © 2002  Fort Meyers News Press  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Development density: Towers are just too much
Too much. That is the rap on twin condo towers of up to 10 stories apiece on the edge of Rookery Bay between Naples and Marco Island. Collier County's volunteer environmental board says so. So does The Conservancy of Southwest Florida, which runs a nature center amid the sprawling preserve. Now, the developer says it is willing to skip the condos and sell. If the price is right, that would be great. 
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

 

16-August-02

Suburban runoff may drive up Everglades cost
Runoff from suburbs such as Wellington could nearly double the cost of cleaning pollution entering the Everglades, consultants told stunned water managers Thursday. Estimated costs range from $338 million to $728 million over 50 years for cleansing the suburban drainage and finishing a cleanup of runoff from sugar farms, according to the consultants' reports. That's on top of the $867 million water managers have already planned to spend cleansing the farming region's phosphorus-laden runoff. Up to $635 million of that extra money would be needed to cleanse the runoff from south Wellington's subdivisions and horse farms, Broward County suburbs such as Weston, and land including Seminole Indian territory west of the Everglades. Big difference: Unlike the original $867 million, nobody knows where those extra dollars will come from. The consultants' studies also indicated it could be difficult, if not impossible, to meet the state's December 2006 deadline for cleansing all water that flows into the Everglades.
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Swinging at Legislature, hitting the Everglades
Florida's biggest environmental battle is restoration of the Everglades. So it makes no sense for environmental groups to bring the  Everglades-threatening lawsuit they filed Wednesday. For all their self-righteous rhetoric, they are thinking of themselves, not the Everglades.
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Everglades restoration hung up over homes
A long-running land dispute west of Miami is halting a crucial part of the Everglades restoration, just as many of the project's supporters have warned for years. The Army Corps of Engineers said this week it is suspending all planning on efforts to re-create a natural water flow in the heart of the Everglades by 2016, possibly the most ecologically important element of the $8.4 billion restoration.  
Copyright  © 2002  Chicago Tribune All rights reserved.

A lonely road to nowhere fills up: Sawgrass plans major expansion
By: Michael A.W. Ottey
It was once the $200 million-dollar road to nowhere, built on the edge of
swamp country, and underused. Now, the Sawgrass Expressway is slated for expansion.
A nearly eight-mile stretch of the expressway -- between Atlantic and Sunrise boulevards -- will be widened by two lanes, for a total of six. Motorists should expect delays when the work begins the first week of September and runs through late 2004 or early 2005.  
Copyright  © 2002  Miami Herald  All rights reserved.


15-August-02

'Glades ruling freezes planning
The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers said Wednesday it will suspend planning for a major piece of the $8.4 billion Everglades plan -- a piece that truly aims to turn back the clock to play by nature's rules, not those of engineers. The reason: a tiny Miami-Dade County community called the 8-1/2 Square Mile Area. Corps officials said their decision was prompted by a federal judge's ruling in July the agency did not have congressional authorization to follow its plan to buy out about 100 residences in the 8-1/2 Square Mile Area. The buyout covers less than one-quarter of the area's existing homes. The corps had intended to take that private property by eminent domain, while protecting other residences with a flood wall and canal, so it could send more water to the east side of adjacent Everglades National Park. But with that water route south of the Tamiami Trail in court-ordered limbo, the corps argues it cannot logically map out changes to water flow upstream, in a portion of the central Everglades called Water Conservation Area 3. "It just doesn't make sense to go forward," said Richard Bonner, deputy district engineer for the corps. "It could result in wasting taxpayers' money."
Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel / Associated Press  All rights reserved.

Impasse over homes stymies Everglades project
A long-running land dispute west of Miami is halting a crucial part of the Everglades restoration -- just as many of the project's supporters have warned for years. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers announced this week that it is suspending all planning on efforts to recreate natural flow in the heart of the Everglades by 2016, possibly the most ecologically important element of the $8.4 billion restoration. The work can't continue until Congress, the courts or somebody decides what to do about more than 300 homes on the marshy eastern fringes of Everglades National Park, corps restoration Project Manager Dennis Duke said Wednesday. The corps and South Florida water managers have at various times proposed buying out the sometimes-waterlogged community -- known as the 8 1/2 -Square-Mile Area -- or building a levee to protect residents from the floods that would result from restored flows. A federal judge last month rejected the corps' most recent plan, which would have forced out 102 homeowners while protecting the rest. The corps has yet to decide whether to appeal the ruling, and attempts in Congress to support the buyout have gone nowhere. "We need to know what the final solution is," Duke said. He said the delay in the Everglades planning could take from two months to two years. 
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Everglades Revival Work Halted
The component is designed to help reconnect the River of Grass by removing some man-made barriers to its original water flows. But Corps officials said they will have to delay the effort -- known as the "Decompartmentalization and Sheet Flow Enhancement" component of Everglades restoration, or "Decomp" -- by at least two years, unless Congress acts quickly to jump-start a stalled related Everglades project. In a recent series of Washington Post articles, some public officials and environmental activists questioned whether Everglades restoration would actually restore the Everglades. They complained that the $7.8 billion plan focuses more on providing water for South Florida residents and agribusinesses, citing its 180,000 acres of new reservoirs and 333 new underground wells. But Decomp is one of its purest environmental elements, as it would fill in some of the canals and degrade some of the levees that block the world's most famous wetland. "This is the project that would provide the greatest ecological benefits," said Elizabeth Crisfield, a hydrologist at Everglades National Park. "It's really disappointing. This has so much potential to make the Everglades a free-flowing ecosystem again." 
Copyright  © 2002  Washington Post  All rights reserved.

Related Links,

   Washington Post Special Report: Everglades -- The Swamp
   http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/nation/specials/everglades/

14-August-02

Conservationists blast road plan
County says area needs reliever road
(Note: This article is not available online.) A proposal to build a road to ease traffic for Arceage residents is fueling a battle between conservationists and the county.
Palm Beach County commissioners are expected to review a revised plan for the Acreage Reliever Road during the August or September meeting, said Commissioner Tony Massilotti. Representatives of local Audubon Society and Sierra Club chapters told the commission during a July meeting that the plan was unacceptable, said Steven Bell, who recently became co-chair of the Environmental Coalition. The coalition, which is in the process of reforming after it disintegrated several years ago, met recently to discuss issue of concern by members of several preservation organizations, Bell said. Second on the coalition's list of three primary issues is the preservation of the Pond Cypress Preserve, Bell said. "Pond Cypress Preserve is a beautiful piece of property," said Bell. "The want to put a road through it, which is unacceptable." The road will not go up the state's right of way, but will be moved further west," Massilotti said. "The Sierra Club provided three alternatives and none impacted the preserve," said Bell who is also a member of the club. Read More....
Copyright  © 2002 Wellington/Royal Palm Beach Forum All rights reserved.


Related Links,

Palm Beach County Government / Board of County Commissioners
http://www.co.palm-beach.fl.us/

Palm Beach County Natural Area's Fact Sheet Fox Natural Area
http://www.pbcgov.com/erm/divisions/support/education/pdf/fox.pdf

Satellite image of the general area
http://www.evergladesvillage.net/sat/everglades/sections/section19.jpg

Audubon Society of the Everglades
http://home.earthlink.net/~audubon.eglades/

Sierra Club Loxahatchee Group - An Environmental Group serving Sierra Club members in southeast Florida's Palm Beach, Martin, St. Lucie and Okeechobee counties.
http://www.sierraclub.org/chapters/fl/loxahatchee/

Can-Do Thinking on the Everglades 
This summer The Post ran an exhaustive multi-part series totaling more than 18,000 words titled "The Swamp." The series seemed crafted largely to undermine support within the remarkable coalition brought together to restore the River of Grass. While it would be hubris to suggest that the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan is perfect, I believe its goals can be achieved and are worth the effort to achieve them. The tone throughout the entire series can best be described as defeatist. The future of the Everglades is "riddled with uncertainties." Its past is "a history of spectacular failures and scandals." Even in its pristine natural state, the Everglades is the "Devil's Garden," "a sweltering slog" and a "waterlogged wheat field." Those who admire its beauty, respect its ancient and delicate balance or cherish hopes for its renewal are dismissed as romantics.  This defeatism infects all of the specific points the series attempts to make about the supposed flaws in the Everglades restoration plan. I feel it is imperative to address a few of them and correct these major misrepresentations. 
Copyright  © 2002  Washington Post  All rights reserved.

10-August-02

U.S. Seeks to Limit Conservation Law
The Bush administration is arguing that a major environmental law does not apply to the vast majority of oceans under United States control, a move that environmentalists say could allow military maneuvers, oil and gas pipelines, commercial fishing, ocean dumping and scores of other activities to escape public environmental review.  In a federal court case in Los Angeles that involves the testing of a new type of sonar system by the Navy, the Justice Department said that the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 — landmark legislation that requires federal agencies to review the environmental implications of their projects — did not apply beyond the nation's territorial waters, which traditionally extend three miles from shore.  Read more . . . 
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times, AP online  All rights reserved.

Activists: Permit Bucks Order
Angry conservation groups say David Struhs, secretary of Florida's Department of Environmental Protection, defied a court order by issuing a discharge permit to a Palatka paper mill. Struhs disagrees, saying he complied with the order before he signed the permit. The DEP secretary is responsible for approving or rejecting agency permits. The Palatka permit allows Georgia Pacific Corp. to pipe waste to the St. Johns River. As part of the agreement with DEP, the company promises to make improvements to lower the levels of dioxin, a cancer-causing chemical, in its waste water. Struhs is required by state law to make an impartial decision, weighing evidence from opponents and supporters of any agency permit. But conservation groups say Struhs has repeatedly shown a bias in favor of the permit, citing DEP news releases and Struhs' public statements in support of it. The groups asked a judge to disqualify Struhs from issuing the permit. On Tuesday, an appeals court ordered Struhs to show why the petition filed by the conservation groups should not be granted. The next day, Struhs issued the permit anyway. ``It looks like he thumbed his nose at the court of appeals,'' said Linda Young of the Clean Water Network, one of the groups challenging the permit. ``Not only did he deny our motion to disqualify himself, he issued a final order.'' DEP had a different interpretation. Agency spokesman Bob Sparks said what the court really ordered Struhs to do was rule on the environmental groups' motion to disqualify him. ``Late Tuesday, he met the requirement of that order and did decide it,'' Sparks said. ``He decided to rule against the motion to disqualify himself.'' Timothy Keyser, an attorney representing the Putnam County Environmental Council and the Stewards of the St. Johns River, disagreed, saying he believes Struhs is in contempt of court.
Copyright  © 2002  Tampa Tribune  All rights reserved.
 

Officials mull third Lake O release
Water from Lake Okeechobee stopped flowing into the St. Lucie River on Friday as the second round of releases in the past month came to an end.  Water managers will discuss on Tuesday whether a third 10-day cycle of discharges is necessary to further curb the rise of Lake Okeechobee. Though the just-completed releases appear to have accomplished that goal temporarily, officials said another round is likely in the coming weeks or even months.  The lake was 14.54 feet above sea level Friday, up just a hundredth of an inch since the most recent cycle of discharges started Aug. 1.  "It's a combination of the weather and the releases," said Tommy Strowd, operations director for the South Florida Water Management District. "Had we not done the releases, the lake would be two-tenths of a foot higher. In that sense, they've really done what they were intended to do: keep the lake from getting too high, too early." More than 4.7 billion gallons of water flowed out of the floodgates at the St. Lucie Lock during each of this summer's two rounds of "pulse" releases. An additional 10.3 billion gallons were flushed down the Caloosahatchee River on the west coast during each of the two discharges.  The second round of releases appeared to have a greater impact on the lake than the first, which started in mid-July. Lake Okeechobee rose 4 inches during that first cycle, and most of the water that flowed into the St. Lucie River originated in the canal's own drainage basin rather than in the lake itself.  During this month's releases, however, nearly 3.6 billion gallons flowed from the lake into the St. Lucie Canal through the floodgates at Port Mayaca.  "I think the pulses have done pretty much what we wanted them to do and what we expected them to do," said Paul Millar, head of the water management district's local office.
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

Fish kill strikes Hobe Sound beaches
Up to 100 dead puffers, porgies and sheepshead fish washed ashore on the beaches of the Hobe Sound National Wildlife Refuge on Friday, and officials and beachgoers don't know why.  Investigators with the Florida Marine Research Institute in Tequesta gathered samples of ocean water and the dead fish, which were scattered among stray flip-flops and dried seaweed along the uncrowded beach north of Jupiter Island. Fish kills in rivers and canals are often caused by heavy rains, pollution and algae blooms. The cause of fish kills in the ocean are much more difficult to determine even by the scientists. Still, everyone on Friday had a theory. Margo Stahl, manager of the wildlife refuge, said she thought the fish kill was related to the freshwater discharges from Lake Okeechobee, which ended Friday. "Everyone's curious to what impact it might be having," she said. "There is now a presence of dead fish washing up on our beach. We are obviously concerned."  The dead fish, swarming with bugs but not yet stinking, were seen as far north as the southern boundary of the St. Lucie Inlet State Preserve and as far south as the northern boundary of Hobe Sound public beach. Workers with the St. Lucie Inlet State Preserve were also monitoring the beach, said John Griner, park manager.   "We've had some fish kills, but nothing that big," Griner said. "It's because fresh water is coming out of the lake. They get pushed out of the inlet."  But Tommy Stroud, director of water operations for the South Florida Water Management District, said he doubted the low-volume releases from the lake in the past month was to blame.  "The fact that we really let out just a minor amount of water, it's hard for me to see any causal connection," he said.   "These are not the massive discharges we saw in '97 and '98."
Copyright  © 2002  TC Palm  All rights reserved.

 

9-August-02 

Exploitation costs the Earth
Saving natural resources saves money.


Cash costs of logging out-
weigh gains.
© Science/H.Eva

In terms of hard cash, natural habitats are worth far more if left intact than if they are exploited, a new report shows. This is true even if the converted habitat brings apparent economic gains.  In net terms, every year's loss of natural habitat from practices such as logging and farming costs around $250 billion in each subsequent year, the report finds.  "The economics are absolutely stark," says ecologist Andrew Balmford of the University of Cambridge, UK, who led the research team. "We thought that the numbers would favour conservation, but not by this much."  
Copyright  © 20
02  Nature All rights reserved.

Everglades Restoration May Affect Florida Bay
Report Cites Algae Growth, Sea Grass Loss
The National Academy of Sciences warned yesterday that the $7.8 billion effort to revive the Florida Everglades might trigger algal blooms and kill sea grasses in nearby Florida Bay, challenging widely held assumptions that the largest environmental project in American history would restore the degraded bay to a gin-clear fishermen's paradise. The peer-reviewed report by a panel of scientists concludes instead that the Everglades project's impact on the 1,000-square-mile bay remains highly uncertain. It cites "persuasive" evidence that the impact "may be perceived as undesirable." In general, the academy calls for far more research into the bay's complex problems and potential solutions. This could create a dilemma for the project's leaders. They have promoted their plans to boost southerly water flows through the Everglades as a "win-win" for the shallow bay and dying coral reefs nearby. "In the past, the mantra has been that this is a win-win for everyone, but we're saying that may not be so," said Scott Nixon, a coastal marine ecologist from the University of Rhode Island who is on the academy's panel. "People need to be told what's going on here, or else they might end up saying: Holy moly, how did this happen? We want the bay back how it was!" Terrence "Rock" Salt, executive director of the South Florida Ecosystem Restoration Task Force, said he appreciates the academy's recommendations and generally supports its science. But he emphasized that the restoration's goal for Florida Bay is not gin-clear water or bigger catches for commercial shrimpers and recreational tarpon fishermen. The goal is to restore the original water flows and let nature do the rest. "The scientists have been telling us for several years that restoring the natural flows may result in more algae blooms and turbidity," said Salt, a former Army Corps of Engineers colonel who works for the Interior Department. "But that remains our goal."

 

Everglades Restoration May Affect Florida Bay Report Cites Algae Growth, Sea Grass Loss
The National Academy of Sciences warned yesterday that the $7.8 billion
effort to revive the Florida Everglades might trigger algal blooms and
kill sea grasses in nearby Florida Bay, challenging widely held assumptions
that the largest environmental project in American history would restore the
degraded bay to a gin-clear fishermen's paradise.The peer-reviewed report by a panel of scientists concludes instead that the Everglades project's impact on the 1,000-square-mile bay remains highly uncertain. It cites "persuasive" evidence that the impact "may be
perceived as undesirable." 
Copyright  © 2002  Washington Post  All rights reserved.

 

Economic Reasons for Conserving Wild Nature

  Andrew Balmford, 1* Aaron Bruner, 2 Philip Cooper, 3 Robert Costanza, 4dagger Stephen Farber, 5 Rhys E. Green, 16 Martin Jenkins, 7 Paul Jefferiss, 6 Valma Jessamy, 3 Joah Madden, 1 Kat Munro, 1 Norman Myers, 8 Shahid Naeem, 9 Jouni Paavola, 3 Matthew Rayment, 6 Sergio Rosendo, 3 Joan Roughgarden, 10 Kate Trumper, 1 R. Kerry Turner 3

On the eve of the World Summit on Sustainable Development, it is timely to assess progress over the 10 years since its predecessor in Rio de Janeiro. Loss and degradation of remaining natural habitats has continued largely unabated. However, evidence has been accumulating that such systems generate marked economic benefits, which the available data suggest exceed those obtained from continued habitat conversion. We estimate that the overall benefit:cost ratio of an effective global program for the conservation of remaining wild nature is at least 100:1.

Abstract (membership access only)
  http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/abstract/297/5583/950
Full text (membership access only)
  http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/297/5583/950

 Supporting Online Material:  This file is in Adobe Acrobat PDF format. If you have not installed and  configured the Adobe Acrobat Reader on your system, please see Help with Printing for instructions.
  http://www.sciencemag.org/help/print_help.dtl#acroread

 Download supplement

  http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/data/297/5583/950/DC1/1
  http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/297/5583/950/DC1

Copyright  © 200www.sciencemag.org All rights reserved.

 

 

Everglades fix could foul Florida Bay
 Restoring the Everglades could harm Florida Bay instead of saving it, a scientific report warned Thursday. The $8.4 billion restoration plan promises to send more fresh water through the Everglades into the bay, reversing an increase in salt levels that many scientists blame for the bay's ecological collapse in the late 1980s. But the added fresh water could carry pollutants that would fuel algae blooms and wipe out sea grasses that shelter shrimp and lobster, according to the report from the National Research Council. Fishing in the bay, which lies between the Everglades and the Florida Keys, is an $18-million-a-year industry, restoration planners have estimated. The report also doubts that the restoration would re-create the clear water the bay enjoyed in the decades before the late 1980s, as some bay advocates had hoped. "The thinking was that more water is going to be good for the Everglades, and more water is going to be good for Florida Bay," said Scott Nixon, vice chairman of the research council's Committee on Restoration of the Greater Everglades Ecosystem. Nixon, a professor at the University of Rhode Island Graduate School of Oceanography, said people have not understood what restoring Florida Bay means. "People may think it will be restored to gin-clear water with more sea grass, but that may not be the way the bay moves." The report calls for more research into how the restoration would affect the bay, including studies of the bay's history, the likely effects of population growth and basic questions about how water enters and flows through the bay. Thursday's report is the second from the Everglades committee that raises sharp questions about the $8.4 billion plan. A report last year questioned plans to store hundreds of billions of gallons of runoff and canal water underground, saying studies are needed to prove that the water won't contaminate the Floridan Aquifer. John Ogden, a scientist in charge of the restoration, said the project's planners in South Florida have suggested scrutinizing the bay to watch for the kind of harm the report warns about.
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

 

Humanity Loses $250 Billion a Year in Wild Habitat 

Balmford

Zoologist Andrew Balmford (Photo courtesy University of Cambridge)

The economic value of wild ecosystems far outweighs the value of converting these areas to cropland, housing or other human uses. A study in today's issue of the journal "Science" says habitat destruction costs the world the equivalent of about $250 billion each year. The research team estimates that a network of global nature reserves would ensure the delivery of goods and services worth at least $400 trillion more each year than the goods and services from their converted counterparts. This means the benefit to cost ratio is more than 100 to one in favor of conservation - a "strikingly good investment," the researchers wrote. "The economics are absolutely stark. We thought that the numbers would favor conservation, but not by this much," said lead author Andrew Balmford of the University of Cambridge Zoology Department. Although habitat destruction continues unabated throughout the world, mounting evidence suggests that this trend is a bad economic bargain. 



Logs cut from Pavuvu Island, Solomon Islands, 
ready for export to Japan. (Photo courtesy Greenpeace)

From tropical forests to ocean reef systems, about half of an ecosystem's total economic value is lost when that ecosystem is converted from its wild state to human use, according to the "Science" study. Balmford and colleagues compared the difference in the value of economic benefits provided by relatively intact ecosystems and by converted versions of those ecosystems. Although they reviewed more than 300 case studies of such conversion, they only identified five examples that met their rigorous standards for comparing benefits. "A single year's habitat conversion costs the human enterprise, in net terms, on the order of $250 billion that year, and every year into the future," the team concludes. Logs cut from Pavuvu Island, Solomon Islands, ready for export to Japan.

Trees destroyed for short term rice cultivation in Thailand (Photo by A. Wolstad courtesy FAO

 The economic value of an ecosystem can be measured in terms of the "goods and services" - including climate regulation, water filtration, soil formation, and sustainably harvested plants and animals - that the ecosystem provides. Pricing these goods and services is difficult, since they include items that are not bought and sold as part of a market driven, conventional economy. Economists assign values to non-marketed services using a range of techniques, from estimating the cost of replacing these products to assessing how much individuals and nations would be willing to pay for each ecosystem service.


child

Cambodian child gathers wild fruit. (Photo by G. Bizzarri courtesy FAO)


 

 

 

 


Copyright  © 2002  Environment News Service (ENS)  All Rights Reserved.     

 

World's wealth still relies on nature
Economists find wilderness worth more than farm land
 
Preservation of the world's remaining wilderness could be the ultimate bargain. Scientists and economists calculate that forests, wetlands and other natural ecosystems are worth far more to human economies than the farm or building land that could replace them. They report today in the US journal Science that the wilderness converted to human use each year actually costs economies $250bn a year, every year. Put another way, it would cost the world $45bn to extend and effectively protect threatened areas of temperate and tropical forest, mangrove swamps, coral reefs and so on. But in return, these global reserves would supply humans with at least $4,400bn in "goods and services". This is a benefit-cost ratio of around 100-1. And that, they say, is a low estimate of the likely benefits of better and more sustained conservation. "The economics are absolutely stark. We thought the numbers would favour conservation, but not by that much," said Andrew Balmford of the University of Cambridge. David Constanza of the University of Vermont said: "We've been cooking the books for a long time by leaving out the worth of nature. Economics has traditionally focussed on the market. But we have been finding that a lot of what is valuable to humans takes place outside of the market." Humans depend on insects to pollinate crops, on forests to recycle carbon dioxide, slow erosion and prevent floods, on estuarine swamps as fish hatcheries and to buffer towns from storms and tidal surges. Ultimately, natural ecosystems provide humans with food, water, air, shelter, fuel, clothing and medicines. In 1997 economists tried to put a price on the things nature supplies, and arrived at a total of £33 trillion a year. This year, with backing from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds and the Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, British and US scientists did their sums again. They surveyed 300 case studies of what happened when the natural environment was converted to human use, and chose five for closer analysis. These included the intensive logging of a Malaysian forest, a Cameroon forest converted to small scale agriculture and commercial plantation, a mangrove swamp in Thailand turned to shrimp farming, a Canadian marsh drained for agriculture, and a Philippine coral reef dynamited for fishing. In each case the value of the natural ecosystem - as storm and flood protection, for sustainable hunting and tourism, or to soak up carbon dioxide - outweighed the returns from human use. The Malaysian forest would have been 14% more valuable left standing. The Canadian marsh would have returned 60% if left alone for hunting, trapping and fishing. The research is published as world leaders prepare for the Johannesburg summit on sustainable development. Two thirds of the world's fisheries are already harvested beyond sustainability. One fifth of the world's topsoil has been lost in the last 50 years, along with one fifth of agricultural land and one third of forests. Forest destruction has slowed, according to Science today - but an area twice the size of Belgium is still vanishing each year. "Natural capital is going to be more valuable as it becomes more scarce. In many cases we have passed the point where development is worth more to us than conservation," said Professor Constanza. 
Copyright  © 2002 Guardian All rights reserved.

 

 

 

Report: Everglades restoration may harm Florida Bay

The widely held perception that the murky, ailing Florida Bay will recover when the Everglades restoration sends more fresh water there could be wrong, a group of scientists wrote in a report released Thursday.   The report also questions whether the bay's former "gin clear" quality with its extensive sea grass beds was really the original, natural state of the bay before cities and farms were built on the peninsula. The group, called the Committee on the Restoration of the Greater Everglades Ecosystem, or CROGEE, acts as an independent advisory panel to the South Florida Ecosystem Restoration Task Force, comprised of state and federal agencies overseeing the multibillion-dollar   restoration.   The report concludes that the restoration plans, as they exist now, could actually harm the bay instead of improving it.   The report concluded that none of the current assumptions about why the sea grass died and how the water got murky can be trusted, and that more research is needed to "reduce the uncertainties" about the long-term effects of the restoration on the bay.   It suggests that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers cover these issues in an ongoing review of the bay and the Florida Keys. It acknowledges that "the effort required for all these tasks is daunting."  The task force requested a report to examine how the $8 billion restoration would affect the water quality in Florida Bay and the Keys, whose ecosystems are intimately connected to the Everglades.   First, the report questions the conclusion that too much salt water in the bay caused the die-off of its turtle grass beds. And simply adding fresh water through Taylor Slough and Craighead Basin to the east and Shark River Slough to the west might not be the answer, the report said. That's because the fresh water is likely to bring with it nutrients such as phosphorus and nitrogen, which could contribute to more harmful algae blooms that are already choking the bay. Those blooms could in turn be carried through the Keys and to their famed coral reefs, which are already suffering, the report said.   "People have assumed that the (restoration) will help conditions in Florida Bay," said Wayne Huber, a hydrology expert at Oregon State University in Corvallis, one of the report's principal authors. "They say it will alleviate the problems of sea grass die-off, it will alleviate the problems of hypersalinity, it will alleviate the problems of algal blooms. None of those conclusions can be made right now," Huber said. "There ought to be a detailed study to determine better the impacts of the restoration on Florida Bay."  The director of the restoration task force said its members would follow up on the report.   "This report was requested by the task force as part of its independent scientific review," said Terrence "Rock" Salt. "We appreciate their work and we will take their recommendations very seriously."   Salt emphasized, however, that "the goal to restore the quantity, timing and distribution of fresh water to the Everglades has not changed."   He also said the task force was never under the impression that the bay had to return to its gin-clear quality to recover. If its original quality was murky, he said, so be it.
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.
Read Report 

Everglades restoration plan may backfire, harm Florida Bay
It has been popularly viewed as the Rx for an ailing Florida Bay: more fresh water, enough to keep the marine lagoon at the south end of the Everglades gin-clear, not too salty and broadly carpeted with seagrass. But a report issued by a panel of highly regarded scientists Thursday has concluded the 1,000-square-mile bay probably won't see the big fresh water boost some have expected would come with a $7.8 billion program to restore the upstream Everglades. In fact, it isn't clear how much fresh water would make its way into the bay as a result of the restoration plan led by the Army Corps of Engineers and South Florida Water Management District, the National Research Council report says. Even if that influx of fresh water is achieved, the report points out, it could shoot more phosphorus and nitrogen into the bay. Those nutrients could fuel the kinds of things it had been hoped the restoration would stave off: mega-blooms of algae and clouded water that can kill turtle grass and other sea grasses in the bay, harming marine life. Ironically, the research council says in a statement, efforts to return the shallow bay "to a clear, densely vegetated state actually may run counter to its natural conditions. Historical accounts suggest the bay may have been a murky body of water prior to the last century." Florida Bay is intimately connected to the Everglades and a vital piece of that larger ecosystem. A host of marine creatures nest, nurse and feed there. Inhabitants include the crocodile and manatee, sea turtle, dolphin, roseate spoonbill and other wading birds. The bay churns out a lot of seafood that lands on Floridians' dinner plates: pink shrimp, a $59 million fishery; stone crabs, and the Caribbean spiny lobster. It is a nursery for 22 species of commercial and recreational fish. There has been a kind of mantra spawned by the restoration that pouring more fresh water into the Everglades would help the bay's health. That win-win scenario may not pan out, said Scott Nixon, vice chairman of the Committee on Restoration of the Greater Everglades Ecosystem, the research council group that wrote the report.
Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.
Read Report  

A Times Editorial: Bad Boys vs. manatees
In Florida, headlines about manatees are routine. If the lovable sea cows aren't in the news because of their popularity with tourists and wildlife lovers, they're at the center of some controversy or court battle about whether the government is doing enough to protect the ancient and endangered species.In Florida, headlines about manatees are routine. If the lovable sea cows aren't in the news because of their popularity with tourists and wildlife lovers, they're at the center of some controversy or court battle about whether the government is doing enough to protect the ancient and endangered species. Now the lumbering mammals have been thrust into the spotlight of a major motion picture. But the manatees' participation is involuntary and hazardous, and they have Gov. Jeb Bush to blame for placing them in harm's way.
Copyright  © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.

Everglades murk may get worse: A panel of top scientists warns the plan to restore the Everglades might harm the water quality of Florida Bay.
A panel of top scientists warns the plan to restore the Everglades might harm the water quality of Florida Bay. For the second time, an esteemed group of scientists is picking apart the $8-billion plan for restoring the Everglades. In its latest criticism, a National Academy of Sciences panel said Thursday that a plan for restoring the flow of water through what is left of the Everglades is not likely to achieve an important benefit touted by its political backers: the transformation of murky Florida Bay into the fishing paradise it was in the 1970s. The report is only the panel's most recent criticism of the massive effort to replumb the River of Grass. Last year the panel raised questions about using an untested form of water storage, questions that prompted the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the South Florida Water Management District to launch new studies of whether it would really work. The panel's latest report focuses on Florida Bay, at the southern tip of the Everglades, and says the Everglades plan could actually worsen the bay's condition. While the plan calls for restoring the flow of fresh water through the Everglades, there is no assurance the water will be cleaned up before it reaches Florida Bay. As a result, increasing the flow is likely to dump nitrogen and phosphorous into the shallow estuary, the panel from the National Academy of Sciences said. That will feed algae blooms that would decrease water clarity, making the bay even murkier than it is now, the panel predicted. "It could be we need to do more with water quality protection," said David Rudnick, a senior scientist with the South Florida Water Management District, one of the agencies implementing the restoration plan. The Everglades plan's implied promise to bring back gin-clear water "may not be realistic, and there's some uncertainty about whether it's even possible," said Stephen Humphrey, dean of the College of Natural Resources and Environment at the University of Florida and part of the 15-member panel reviewing the project.
Copyright © 2002  St. Petersburg Times  All rights reserved.
Read Report  

Everglades Restoration May Affect Florida Bay Report Cites Algae Growth, Sea Grass Loss

The National Academy of Sciences warned yesterday that the $7.8 billion
effort to revive the Florida Everglades might trigger algal blooms and kill
sea grasses in nearby Florida Bay, challenging widely held assumptions
that the largest environmental project in American history would restore the
degraded bay to a gin-clear fishermen's paradise.
he peer-reviewed report by a panel of scientists concludes instead that the Everglades project's impact on the 1,000-square-mile bay remains highly uncertain. It cites "persuasive" evidence that the impact "may be
perceived as undesirable." In general, the academy calls for far more research
into the bay's complex problems and potential solutions. This could create a dilemma for the project's leaders. 
Copyright  © 2002  Washington Post  All rights reserved.

 

More Water for the Everglades May Not Help Florida Bay

 A plan to restore the Everglades ecosystem may cause
cloudiness in nearby Florida Bay, says a new report from the National Academies'
Water Science and Technology Board. Some calculations question the amount of
fresh water that will actually reach the bay under the plan, and recent observations suggest that an influx of fresh water would bring additional nitrogen and phosphorus, encouraging algae growth that would cloud water and harm seagrass. Read  more...
Copyright  © 2002  National Academies  All rights reserved.

Citizen survey: Growth is Lee's biggest problem
The three most important issues facing Lee County are growth, growth and growth, concludes a citizen survey released this week, yet the thing that Lee County government does worst is manage growth.   Eighty percent of those surveyed said Lee County is growing too fast. Forty percent believe the county does a poor job of managing growth through land use, planning and zoning.   A whopping 82 percent characterized the county's growth management as fair or poor, with only 18 percent calling it excellent or good. Seventy three percent see too much growth as a moderate or major problem.   "I think what it says is they have concerns about growth," County Manager Don Stilwell said. "We need to balance it, and that's what we're doing with our smart growth effort." Lee County government created a Smart Growth Advisory Committee 10 months ago. The committee's been reviewing the way the county manages growth, and is expected to recommend a slate of changes next year.  
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

Pompano activist sues for voter approval on public land sale
The divisive issue of whether the sale of seaside public land should be decided by the voters is now in the hands of the courts. M. Ross Shulmister, a city activist and attorney, has filed a lawsuit in Broward County Circuit Court to stop the city from giving up a piece of land for high-rise development without holding a public referendum. Shulmister contends the city's charter requires a referendum before selling public land. "If you set precedent that you don't have to follow the charter, what's to stop the city from selling off the golf course or other parks without a referendum?" he asked. The debate centers on a piece of the pier parking lot that is one of the locations the city wants to sell for redevelopment. The land was labeled several ways, including "recreational." The city's charter says voter approval is required to sell recreational property. But the charter also says a public referendum is not needed if the land is relabeled to "Community Redevelopment Agency redevelopment," which is what commissioners agreed to do in June. Shulmister wants the court to invalidate the new designation and to issue an injunction to prevent sale of the land unless a referendum is held. Residents have accused City Hall of ignoring the charter so they can push their redevelopment plans through without public input.
Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.

8-August-02

Economists say it pays to save nature 
A study has found wild ecosystems are around 100 times more economic than ones converted to human use. Research published in the journal Science found goods and services such as climate regulation, water filtration and tourism earn more money and cost less in upkeep. Experts say a network of global nature reserves would deliver 100 times more in goods and services than converted land. In terms of pure cash that adds up to at least £2,800 billion more earned than from factories, housing or roads. The study by the American Association for the Advancement of Science also found half of an ecosystem's economic value is lost when it is converted to human use. Their report claims a single year's habitat conversion costs, in net terms, on the order of £160 billion that year, and every year into the future. The case studies looked at included the logging of a Malaysian tropical forest and a tropical forest in Cameroon converted to agriculture and commercial plantations. They also looked at a mangrove system in Thailand converted for shrimp farming, a Canadian marsh drained for agriculture and a Philippine coral reef dynamited for fishing. Lead author Andrew Balmford, of the University of Cambridge, said: "The economics are absolutely stark. We thought that the numbers would favour conservation, but not by this much." They say there should be more taught about the worth of ecosystems, more effort made to establish that worth and fewer subsidies encouraging development.
Copyright  © 2002 Ananova All rights reserved.

 

CROGEE's report on the science of Florida Bay has been released. 

Florida Bay Research Programs and Their Relation to the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan
(2002)
Board on Environmental Studies and Toxicology (BEST), Water Science and Technology Board (WSTB)

It's available on the National Academies website at

http://books.nap.edu/books/0309084911/html/index.html
Nancy Klingener
Florida Keys Program Manager
The Ocean Conservancy
(formerly the Center for Marine Conservation)
513 Fleming St. #14
Key West, FL 33040
305-295-3370 (phone)
305-295-3371 (fax)
www.oceanconservancy.org

Appeals court upholds Florida ruling on water runoff
A federal appeals court panel has upheld a Florida ruling that a sugar cane farm is not illegally polluting Lake Okeechobee through its management of a water management system. A group called Fishermen Against the Destruction of the Environment sued Closter Farms Inc., claiming that runoff from the cane fields and adjacent properties was polluting the lake in violation of the Clean Water Act because it had no permit. A federal judge in Florida ruled for Closter Farms, saying that "though Closter Farms is polluting Lake Okeechobee, it has complied with the established legislative scheme." Three judges of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that ruling Wednesday. "Because the evidence fails to show any pollutants discharged into the lake other than those that fall within the agricultural exemptions to the Clean Water Act, we find that no permit is required," said the opinion written by Judge Gerald Bard Tjoflat. He was joined by Senior Judge Phyllis A. Kravitch and C. Roger Vinson, the chief U.S. District Judge for the Northern District of Florida, sitting by designation. The judges said any pollutants that originated in non-agricultural properties adjacent to Closter Farms — including the Palm Beach/Glades Airport, the Pahokee Wastewater Treatment Plant, a Palm Beach County park and State Road 715 — either were covered by a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit or were exempt.
Copyright  © 2002  Naples News  All rights reserved.

Editorial: Get Miami-Dade land for sake of Everglades
In the effort to retrofit the water system that affects the southern one- third of Florida, an 8.5-square-mile piece of land might seem inconsequential. What happens on that land, however, will carry a strong message, real and symbolic, for the rest of the project.  The property juts out into the Everglades from western Miami-Dade County. On it are 400 homes, most of them illegal, allowed there by that renegade enterprise known as Miami-Dade County. It would be a local issue except for the fact that the property figures prominently in the $8.4 billion Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project.  Development has taken half of the original Everglades. To restore what remains depends on recreating natural water patterns. To do that, water must flow clockwise, southeast from near Lake Okeechobee, then back to the southwest near Miami-Dade. The so-called 8.5 Square Mile Area blocks that flow. A bill in Congress contained a compromise: condemnation of 102 houses, less than ideal but enough to suffice. Also, the compromise would have satisfied a federal judge's requirement that federal and state money pay for the buyout. But last month, Rep. James Hansen, R-Utah, removed the compromise from the legislation, which then passed the House. As The Post reported Friday, Rep. Hansen received $26,000 in campaign contributions from individuals with an interest in blocking this and other decisions regarding federal stewardship of South Florida land. Rep. Hansen's office denied that the contributions were a factor, but the comment from his office that he favors property rights isn't a persuasive explanation for why a Utah congressman cares about 102 homes in South Florida.  If the government can't take the 8.5 Square Mile Area, any controversial land purchases will be even harder. Without taking land -- for water flow and water storage -- Everglades restoration will be more of a subsidy for sprawl development, not the landmark environmental renewal project that prompted lawmakers from around the country to approve the federal government's 50 percent share.  Two years ago, Rep. Clay Shaw, R-Fort Lauderdale, sponsored the House version of Everglades restoration. He voted for the stripped-down legislation, saying that he did not want to jeopardize other Everglades money in the bill. The Senate still must act on the legislation, but Sen. Bob Graham, D-Fla., wants to include the compromise. Rep. Shaw can demonstrate his continued commitment to the Everglades by making sure that the compromise gets into a committee bill.
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

 

Third series of lake releases likely;  Officials seek to avoid large-scale discharges
Although the St. Lucie Estuary remains under stress, water managers said Wednesday that a third round of Lake Okeechobee discharges into the river is likely.  The second 10-day cycle of low-volume releases in a month will trickle to a halt Friday, the same day managers with the South Florida Water Management District, the Army Corps of Engineers and the state Department of Environmental Protection are scheduled to discuss the possibility of a third cycle. With rain lingering in the coastal and inland forecasts for the next week, water managers said they want to ensure large-volume discharges don't become necessary.  "We've seen the lake flatten out," said Tommy Stroud, director of water operations for the district. "But the conditions that caused us to release last time are still in place. It's more likely we'd have another pulse (discharge) than not."  On Wednesday, Lake Okeechobee stood at 14.56 feet above sea level as an average of 400 cubic feet or 2,992 gallons per second spilled from the St. Lucie Canal into the estuary.  Twice as much water flowed west to the Caloosahatchee River, and water managers are pumping "around the clock" to move lake water south into the conservation areas, Stroud said. Since the discharges began July 15, about 2 inches of rainwater have been sent to tide instead of being stored in the lake, Stroud said. That could be a factor in preventing large discharges such as the ones during the El Nino of 1998, he said.  However, Mark Perry, executive director of the Florida Oceanographic Society, said he was concerned by the length of time that fresh water has flowed into the brackish estuary.  Since heavy rains began in the middle of June, the C-23 and C-24 canals have been discharging stormwater straight into the estuary. Those canals are not connected to the lake.
opyright  © 2002  TC Palm  All rights reserved.

County wants historic preservation law to be voluntary
The county wants to know whether property owners can voluntarily comply with a new historic preservation law rather than have to face mandatory regulations that could make it difficult to install sprinklers, phone lines or a swimming pool.  County commissioners voted 3-2 Tuesday to ask the state Bureau of Historic Preservation whether the new regulation can be established only for property owners willing to have their land listed as an archaeological or historic site.  The tradeoff for the property owner would be potential tax breaks.  "At least it puts something on the table for the state to decide on," said Commissioner Dennis Armstrong, who supported the measure along with commissioners Doug Smith and Lee Weberman.  Weberman initially sought to delay the ordinance, saying it could cause a "hardship" for property owners who would have to get approvals from a new historic resource board to add to their holdings.  However, he relented after Armstrong suggested the county seek to make the regulation voluntary.  Even if the state allows the county to proceed with the voluntary regulation, commissioners agreed to conduct another hearing on the historic law before the code goes into effect in January. Commissioner Michael DiTerlizzi, who along with Chairwoman Elmira Gainey, voted against sending the ordinance to the state, said the proposal would stop people from being able to do "anything" with their land.  "I really feel we're stepping one step beyond where we should be," DiTerlizzi said. "Maybe you got some junk buried in your back yard and you want to build a pool, you start to build and find this junk, you don't have a pool anymore."  Gainey called the voluntary proposal, "too convoluted."  The ordinance lists about 70 privately owned properties as potential historic sites, and virtually every waterfront neighborhood in Martin County would be designated an "archaeological zone," requiring approval from a proposed Historic Preservation Board to dig more than 3 inches below the ground.  The regulations would allow county officials to look for significant cultural artifacts, left behind by American Indians or early settlers, so they can be preserved before excavation occurs, county Planner Hank Woollard said.  Among the areas identified as archaeological zones are Hutchinson Island, Sewall's Point, Jupiter Island, the Lake Okeechobee shoreline, parts of Jensen Beach, Rio, North River Shores, Palm City, Tropical Farms, Stuart, Port Salerno, Rocky Point, Hobe Sound and the Allapattah Flats.
Copyright  © 2002  TC Palm  All rights reserved.

Florida Bureau of Historic Preservation
http://dhr.dos.state.fl.us/bhp/


Florida Heritage: Real and Virtual
http://www.flahum.org/flheritage/flheritage.html

$700,000 grant to protect rare plant
Lakela's mint, a rare plant found only at six sites on the Treasure Coast, will be protected thanks to a $700,000 grant from the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service.  "That's one of the best pieces of news in months," conservationist Jane Brooks said Wednesday. "We should be proud to have a plant that's found nowhere else.  "It has beautiful pink blossoms in October, and when you crush the leaves it's very aromatic."  The $700,000 federal grant will be combined with $260,000 in cash and in- kind services from St. Lucie County to help buy 11 acres on U.S. 1 about a mile south of the Indian River County line.  "It will be used as a biological laboratory and the public will be allowed on limited occasions," Diana Waite of the county's Community Development Department said. Officials won't disclose the exact location of the six sites -- in northern St. Lucie and south Indian River counties -- for fear of vandalism.  "This is the number one site the Fish & Wildlife Service has been interested in," Waite said. "We've been working on this a long time."  The Lakela's mint properties were among top priorities listed in 1991 when the county started buying environmentally sensitive land.  The 11-acre site will be the first to be protected by public ownership, Waite said. Scrub jay habitat will also be protected.  The federal grant was given to the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services, which protects some rare plants, Waite said.  Fish & Wildlife officials distributed nearly $5 million for purchases in Florida, Georgia, North Carolina and Tennessee. The purchases are essential to protect 15 species listed as endangered by the federal government, said Sam Hamilton, southeastern regional director for the Fish & Wildlife
Service.
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved       

Putnam Trades Vote for Say on Citrus
Under a lobbying blitz from the White House and Republican congressional leaders for his vote on giving President Bush a freer hand in international trade negotiations, U.S. Rep. Adam Putnam insisted on a seat at the negotiating table for the Florida citrus industry. Putnam wound up with an entire table. In return for his last-minute support for the trade promotion authority bill Bush signed Tuesday, the administration asked Putnam to create and lead a Florida citrus industry task force to advise U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick.  "As we discussed, I would also appreciate it if you would be willing to create and lead a task force consisting of business and industry leaders to explore ways to open markets for Florida citrus and agriculture worldwide," Zoellick wrote in a letter to Putnam after the July 28 vote in the U.S. House of Representatives.  "The primary role of this task force will be to advise me, as trade negotiator, on the unique aspects of Florida agriculture on an ongoing basis," he added.  The task force was a key reason behind the switch from his vote against trade promotion authority in December, when it first came up on the House floor, said Putnam, a Bartow Republican.  "No other commodity group will have that kind of representation," said Putnam, a citrus grower. "That is a very public commitment to listen and consider our issues."  The concession probably saved Putnam and U.S. Rep. Mark Foley, R-West Palm Beach, from a political backlash they might have received from citrus industry supporters. Foley also switched his "no" in December to "yes" last month on trade promotion authority.  "These people are our key representatives," said Andy LaVigne, the executive director of Lakeland-based Florida Citrus Mutual, the largest growers' representative in the state. "They have to be at the table and have influence when negotiations occur."  Trade promotion authority, previously called "fast track," allows the president to negotiate international trade treaties that Congress can approve or reject but cannot amend. The past five presidents had this authority, but it lapsed in 1994 and wasn't renewed.  The administration argued it needs the authority to negotiate a Free Trade of the Americas Agreement (FTAA), which seeks to lower trade barriers among North and South American nations, and for the upcoming talks at the World Trade Organization (WTO), which will consider eliminating global trade barriers on agricultural products.
Copyright  © 2002   The Ledger All rights reserved.
 

Letter: The Mother of the Tribe 
Miccosukee to feds: We know the Everglades better than you
Mike Clary's article "God's Eye on the Sparrow" (July 18) should have been titled "Playing God in the Everglades." For, as he reported, government agencies have decided which parts of the Everglades and its species will be protected and which will be destroyed.  The Miccosukee Tribe of Indians has lived in the Everglades since time immemorial. Our culture and way of life are tied to the land. We fight to protect it. The agencies implementing these environmentally destructive actions have no historical familiarity with the Everglades. They pay lip service to restoration but their actions are anti-restoration. They hold water below natural levels in Everglades National Park and above natural levels on tribal lands north of the park. Their harmful conduct persists even though it has not even helped the sparrow. The government chooses to ignore the damage being inflicted on the Everglades as a result of the unnatural diversion of water for the sparrow. One ecologist would have your readers believe the problems with the sparrow plan are all bureaucratic. On the contrary, they are very real. Five years of so-called sparrow "emergencies" have closed flood gates and backed up water on tribal lands. Sustained flooding has caused irreparable harm to hundreds of thousands of acres of critical habitat for the endangered snail kite, and incalculable damage to our culture and way of life. Sadly this is the same land the government promised to preserve in its natural state in perpetuity for the benefit and use of the tribe.  The new sparrow plan will degrade 88,300 acres of tribal Everglades land and kill and injure endangered snail kites for five more years. It will also continue to adversely impact other areas of the ecosystem, including Lake Okeechobee, Florida Bay, and the coastal estuaries. Current modeling shows it will increase flooding to some urban and agricultural areas of Miami-Dade County. This embarrassing plan is the result of the government's refusal to heed the advice of the Miccosukee people, who have evolved in kinship with these lands. Decades ago government officials diked the Everglades against the advice of tribal elders. This human interference with the natural flow created conditions that allowed the sparrow to settle into an unnaturally dry area where it did not live before. Now they claim the sparrow needs the water "just right." Don't they know the natural Everglades is an environment of extremes?
Copyright  © 2002 Miami New Times All rights reserved.

Sugar farm's 'pollution' of Okeechobee is ruled legal
A federal appeals-court panel in Atlanta has upheld a Florida ruling that a sugar-cane farm is not illegally polluting Lake Okeechobee through its management of a water-management system. A group called Fishermen Against the Destruction of the Environment sued Closter Farms Inc., claiming that runoff from the cane fields and adjacent properties was polluting the lake in violation of the Clean Water Act because it had no permit. A federal judge in Florida ruled for Closter Farms, saying that "though Closter Farms is polluting Lake Okeechobee, it has complied with the established legislative scheme." Three judges of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld that ruling Wednesday. "Because the evidence fails to show any pollutants discharged into the lake other than those that fall within the agricultural exemptions to the Clean Water Act, we find that no permit is required," said the opinion written by Judge Gerald Bard Tjoflat. He was joined by Senior Judge Phyllis A. Kravitch and C. Roger Vinson, the chief U.S. District Judge for the Northern District of Florida, sitting by designation. The judges said any pollutants that originated in nonagricultural properties adjacent to Closter Farms -- including the Palm Beach/Glades Airport, the Pahokee Wastewater Treatment Plant, a Palm Beach County park and State Road 715 -- either were covered by a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit or were exempt.
Copyright © 2002 Orlando Sentinel  All Rights Reserved.       


7-August-02

Report: Poor Enforcement Leads to Water Pollution
Almost 30 percent of the nation's largest industrial, municipal and federal facilities were in serious violation of the Clean Water Act at least once during a recent 15 month period, a new report concludes.  "Permit to Pollute: How the Government's Lax Enforcement of the Clean Water Act is Poisoning Our Waters" describes shortcomings in the monitoring of water pollution and efforts to deter polluters. The study's authors at the U.S. Public Interest Research Group (U.S. PIRG) say the report points out the folly of Bush administration proposals to slash the enforcement budget at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). "It is outrageous that the Bush Administration is proposing to slash enforcement budgets when nearly 30 percent of polluting facilities are breaking the law," said U.S. PIRG environmental advocate Richard Caplan. "With widespread violations of the law, this is no time for the Bush administration to take cops off the beat." Using the Freedom of Information Act, U.S. PIRG obtained and analyzed the behavior of major facilities nationwide by reviewing violations of the Clean Water Act between January 2000 and March 2001, as recorded in the EPA's Permit Compliance System database.  The group found that 134 major facilities were in what the Act defines as "significant noncompliance" during the entire 15 month period.  The goal of the Clean Water Act was to make U.S. waterways fishable and swimmable by 1983, and to achieve zero discharge of pollutants to waterways by 1985. However, according to the most recent EPA data, 40 percent of U.S. surface waters do not meet the fishable and swimmable standard.  The U.S. PIRG report includes several recommendations to help bring about consistent compliance with federal permits and move toward the zero discharge goals of the Clean Water Act:

Permit To Pollute: How the Government's Lax Enforcement Of   The Clean Water Act Is Poisoning Our Waters. The findings of this new report demonstrate the continued disregard  by polluters for public health, the environment, and the law. http://www.pirg.org/alerts/route.asp?id2=7545


Copyright  © 2002  Environment News Service (ENS) 2002. All Rights Reserved.     

COMMENTARY: Goodbye and thanks for our time together
This is my last column. Circle appropriate response:
a) Oh no, you promised to reveal the historic significance of cheese grits and never did.
b) Hallelujah and bring on the bulldozers.
c) Ugh, who is this guy? I was looking for the movie listings.
Soon after I began this column in 1996, friends kidded me about road signs that said "Wake up with Mike." Maybe sometimes we did wake up together. But mostly you woke me up. Readers offered bright ideas about growth, nature, schools and life in general. I had fun hearing so many dreams and sharing them. I heard more people defining progress in a way that considers quality of life. Activists want a new task force to guard the Wekiva River and springs from irresponsible road building. This could reinforce the Wekiva River Protection Act. The public pays millions to fix environmental problems -- Everglades, Kissimmee River, Lake Apopka, Lake Griffin, Ocklawaha River, Cross-Florida Barge Canal -- that could have been prevented if responsible environmental policy had been followed in the first place. It's good to hear the feds took over the Rodman Dam project from the state. I hope this means the artificial reservoir finally gets flushed away and the Ocklawaha River allowed to flow in a more natural course. A rare, undredged stretch of the Palatlakaha River was saved by a grass-roots campaign for a new preserve and community farm south of Leesburg. Thanks to native-plant gardeners, many yards, golf courses and business landscapes grow less artificial and more friendly to wild critters. Two pro-environment candidates are running against two pro-development incumbents for County Commission. That's good because Lake County needs a full, open debate on the cost of sprawl. Will the commission learn from South Florida's mistakes? Classroom visits with teachers reminded me what a rich life really means. I'll be 50 in a few weeks. Sports cars were never my thing. My mid-life dream is heading back to college. I've been in the news business a long time but never realized how supportive readers could be until we spent these six years together. Thank you.
P.S.: Cheese grits were used in the South as a fancy recipe for benefit breakfasts during Reconstruction to help rebuild towns and cities. OK, now we're square.
Copyright © 2002 Orlando Sentinel  All Rights Reserved.  

6-August-02

U.S. PIRG Reports- Permit To Pollute: How the Government's Lax Enforcement Of The Clean Water Act Is Poisoning Our Waters 
Executive Summary In 1972, a severe water quality crisis compelled Congress to pass the Clean Water Act. The Cuyahoga River literally caught on fire in 1969, and a spill off the coast of California had left millions of gallons of oil along the coastline. The goals of the Act – clearly stated – were to return all waters to fishable and swimmable conditions by 1983 and to eliminate the discharge of all pollutants by 1985. Now nearly 30 years later, although the visible signs of pollution may not be as evident as a burning river, a careful examination of the facts reveals a continuing water pollution crisis in this country. Approximately 40% of our waters are still not safe for swimming or fishing, and in 2001, 49 states issued fish consumption advisories because of high levels of dangerous chemicals. In order to uncover why we have failed to meet the goals of the Clean Water Act, this report analyzes the performance of federal and state governments with respect to enforcement of the Clean Water Act. It examines the government’s listing of facilities that are in “Significant Non-Compliance” with their Clean Water Act permits, information that can only be obtained through the Freedom of Information Act. This information provides a look at facilities that are in serious and chronic violation of the law within the larger context of enforcement accountability and efficacy in deterring pollution. The findings demonstrate the continued disregard by polluters for public health, the environment, and the law. Polluters violate the terms of their Clean Water Act permits on a far too regular basis. EPA has identified certain types of infractions as being “significant,” an arbitrarily high measure to anyone living downstream from a facility discharging any amount of dangerous chemicals. Despite this high threshold for permit non-compliance, nearly 30% of major facilities examined (1,798) were in Significant Noncompliance (SNC) with their Clean Water Act permits for at least one quarter during the 15 months beginning January 1, 2000 and ending March 31, 2001.
Read More...
Copyright  © 2002 USPIRG All rights reserved.

Florida Public Interest Research Group
http://www.floridapirg.org/

State Public Interest Research Groups Working Together -- Each state
Public Interest Research Group is independent and locally based.
http://www.pirg.org/

US Public Interest Research Group (PIRG)
http://www.uspirg.org/

5-August-02

Rules clear, acts defiant
Years ago, buying Florida swamp was a national joke. Swamps were worthless and unusable. But times have changed. These days the buying and selling of Florida swamp isn't funny. Our swamps aren't worthless anymore. Science has established that they are a critical component of Florida's unique ecosystems, as well as Florida's water supply and Florida's weather. And swamps aren't unusable anymore. Over the past 100 years, human ingenuity has perfected techniques of dredge and fill to dry out the swamp, making it ready for roads, houses and stores. Beginning in the 1970s, after the importance of wetlands to our collective well-being was scientifically established, the political system responded by adopting laws to protect wet places. Congress passed the Clean Water Act, Florida passed laws, and some counties adopted wetlands protection ordinances. Under the Clean Water Act it should be difficult to obtain a dredge and fill permit to build a house, a road, or a box store because these property uses are "non-water-dependent" -- you don't need to be in a wetland to successfully build a road, a house, or a box store. The law presumes that you can find dry land to build these non-water-dependent projects on. You might think that, given the stringent protections afforded wetlands under the Clean Water Act, we could rest easy. You would be mistaken. The Clean Water Act, like most environmental laws, is not self-executing. The law has no meaning if it is not properly enforced, and it has not been rigorously enforced in Florida for years. Dredge and fill proceeds at a rapid pace in Florida, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, charged with administering the Clean Water Act, almost never rejects a permit application.
Copyright  © 2002  Sun-Sentinel  All rights reserved.



2-August-02

Decision could slow Everglades project
A Utah congressman who blocked legislation that would have allowed as many as 102 houses to be condemned as part of the Everglades restoration project received $26,700 in campaign contributions from South Florida residents two years ago. Unless the Senate and a joint conference committee restore the provision, a key component of the restoration will have to be redesigned, further delaying the $8.4 billion project. And Thursday, it became a campaign issue in the contentious congressional race between Rep. E. Clay Shaw, R-Fort Lauderdale, and Democrat Carol Roberts of West Palm Beach. The controversy revolves around a tract of land in western Miami-Dade County known as the 8 1/2 Square Mile Area. Restoration planners want to build a series of dikes and canals through the area to improve the flow of water into the eastern edge of the Everglades. But last month, U.S. District Judge K. Michael Moore ruled that plans to buy out the residents with federal money violated a law requiring the purchase to be financed by both federal and state money. Responding to the ruling, Interior Appropriations Subcommittee Chairman Ralph Regula, R-Ohio, inserted a provision in the Interior appropriations bill that would have declared it was Congress' intent to make the purchase with federal money only. But Rep. James Hansen, R-Utah, chairman of the House Resources Committee, objected when the bill came before the Rules Committee two weeks ago. He was joined by Rep. Donald Young, R-Alaska, chairman of the Transportation and Infrastructure Committee. The Rules Committee -- which proposes the rules under which bills are considered by the entire House -- acquiesced and stripped the language from the bill before it reached the House floor. "He felt it was not an appropriate use of federal power," said Marnie Funk, communications director for Hansen's subcommittee. "He objected to using the federal power of eminent domain to force them to leave their homes to create a buffer zone. He has been a strong advocate of private property rights, and this is consistent with that record."
Copyright  © 2002  Palm Beach Post  All rights reserved.

1-August-02

SFWMD faces challenges in restoring Lake O

(Note: this article is not available on line.)

The South Florida Water Management District, Corps of engineers and other agencies face three major challenges in restoring Lake Okeechobee lake stages, the spread of exotic species and high phosphorus loading. SFWMD Lake Okeechobee Division Director Dr. Susan Gray told those attending the County Coalition for Responsible Management of Lake Okeechobee July 8 meeting that the district is working with other agencies, including the Department of Environmental Protection and the Department of Agriculture to leverage their funding and their staffing to meet the challenges in restoring the lake and the Everglades. The passage of the Lake Okeechobee Protection Act in 2000 provided $23.5 million in initial funding for the Lake Okeechobee Watershed project and the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project (CERP), Dr. Gray said. Those funds financed pilot and regional projects including the $8.5 million Grassy Island land purchase and engineering and design components involved with that project, as well as projects aimed at restoring water and habitat retention components under the isolated wetlands project. Another portion of the funds were used in retrofitting culverts and other water control structures and dredging canals north of the lake. Read More...
Copyright  © 200 The Glades County Democrat All rights reserved.

Related Link,

   County Coalition for Responsible Management of
   Lake Okeechobee, St. Lucie & Caloosahatchee Estuaries

   Resolution, November 7, 2001 (1 page, PDF)

   http://www.sfwmd.gov/gover/wrac/ref_mat/aquafer/res_nov7.pdf

 


article with links

 

Revised:  11/19/03

University of Miami School of Law Library
Everglades Litigation Internet Initiative Director
1311 Miller Drive
Coral Gables, Florida 33146
(305) 284-4093
  2001 University of Miami School of Law.
All Rights Reserved.
Requests for information
Send comments / technical feedback.