©  Wilfredo Lee, Associated Press 2003

80-yr-old jurist fights to preserve his Everglades legacy
District Judge William Hoeveler poses near an oil painting of the Everglades that hangs over 
his desk in his chambers in Miami. Best known as the federal judge who sent Manuel Noriega to 
prison, the 80-year-old jurist returned to the headlines this spring by saying a new Everglades law heralded by Gov. Jeb Bush was "clearly defective" even before it was signed.
 

08-June-03

  Recent Developments

•  Recent home         
•  Press Releases     
•  Litigation       
•  Legislation        
•  Regulations           
•  Case Law 
•  Law Review Articles      
•  Reports         
•  Research           
•  Conferences 
•  Links 

Judge Hoeveler News Page


July 2003             May 2003

                           News Archives

News - June  2003   

Other sources

Commons-Everglades Archives List  |  Daytona Beach News-Journal Special Reports  |  Everglades Village News  |  Sun-Sentinel:  Everglades Site  |  SFWMD News Releases      

                  
Environmental News Network                 


  News

 

30-June-03

Entry to wildlife terrain limited
Vetoed funding leads to restricted visitors and admission fees on publicly managed lands
By Richard Raeke, Times Staff Writer
© St. Petersburg Times


INGLIS - Since 1948, hunters and bird-watchers have flocked to state-managed land near here to enjoy a bit of paradise. Anyone could go there, free of charge. Thousands took advantage of it each year. Now far fewer will get the chance, and it's going to cost them. Gov. Jeb Bush last week vetoed funding for the Gulf Hammock Wildlife Management Area in Levy County and three others like it around the state, totaling 82,573 acres. Now, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, which oversees the area, plans to limit visitors to 400 and charge $275 to enter the publicly managed land. "This hit us like a brick wall," said Bob Tourigny, spokesman for the 600-member Gulf Hammock Hunters Association. Public access will be so limited and the price so high that "what we have is a state-run hunting club," said Francis Proveaux, president of the association. The group formed three years ago to fight a proposed sale of the 24,625 acres, which are owned by Plum Creek Timber Co. and leased by the state. It is the oldest wildlife management area in Florida. Three other privately owned, publicly managed wildlife areas also lost state money: Lochloosa in Alachua County, Fort McCoy in Marion County and Relay in Flagler County. Five other wildlife areas already are operating under the permit system.  Read more

NOTICE OF AVAILABILITY OF PROPOSED TOTAL MAXIMUM DAILY LOADS FOR WATERS AND POLLUTANTS INCLUDED ON THE FLORIDA SECTION 303(d) LIST
© Environmental Protection Agency
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has developed proposed total maximum daily loads (TMDLs) for numerous water quality limited segments located in the Indian River Lagoon Basin, of the State of Florida, which are identified on the State of Florida's 1998 Section 303(d) list. The proposed TMDLs have been developed in accordance with Section 303(d)(1)(C) of the Clean Water Act (Act), 33 U.S.C. Section 1313(d)(1)(C), and with the federal regulations at 40 C.F.R. Section 130.7(c)(1).  Read more

 

29-June-03

Sassers from coast, Glades gets frosted
By Dan Moffett, Editorial Writer
© Palm Beach Post
Pahokee ranks among the state leaders in shortages except when it comes to measurements for poverty. The town has a surplus of those. There is the 25 percent unemployment rate and the $10,346 average income and the property values that are so low that one mill of taxation raises a paltry $67,000. But the best measure is the town's Burger King. It's now a Chinese restaurant. When your economy can't support one Burger King, you know you're in trouble. "We have no money. We have jack," says J.P. Sasser. Mr. Sasser, who runs an auto body shop down the road in Belle Glade, is mayor of Pahokee. He was elected last year after campaigning on a platform of aggressive engagement. He believes the town has no choice but to go out and grab help from whomever will give it. He will earn $18,000 as mayor over his two-year term, more than a quarter-mill. A lifelong resident of Pahokee, Mr. Sasser, 47, has made a priority of improving the town's drinking water, which, besides being smelly and yellow, often is rich in cancer-causing chemicals. He and his counterparts from Belle Glade and South Bay are aggressively engaging the Palm Beach County Commission to build a $35 million water treatment plant. Pahokee is so down right now, it can't get much higher than Catch 19 or 20. But still, Mayor Sasser is Yossarian with a Cracker drawl.  Read more

Florida judge fights to preserve Everglades
By Catherine Wilson - Associated Press Writer
© Lawrence Journal-World
Miami — The legacy of William Hoeveler may be 15 years spent policing a complex lawsuit mired in biology and hydrology that is intended to restore the Everglades to its bygone days as a free-flowing, slow-growth marsh. Best known as the judge who sent Panamanian dictator Manuel Noriega to prison in 1992, the 80-year-old jurist returned to the headlines in the spring by saying a new Everglades law heralded by Gov. Jeb Bush was "clearly defective" even before it was signed. The law would extend some of the deadlines for Everglades restoration. Stiffened by a stroke and back trouble but still ramrod straight in person and in deed, the judge insists the federal and state governments are bound by their commitments to him in a 1992 consent decree -- no matter what state lawmakers concoct. Read more

28-June-03

High court enters pollution dispute
By Neil Santaniello, Staff Wrtier
© Sun-Sentinel
The U.S. Supreme Court said Friday it would consider whether water managers could pump polluted water from western Broward suburbs into the Everglades without a federal permit that would require the water to be cleaned. Gaining that review was a victory for the South Florida Water Management District, which seeks to reverse lower-court rulings mandating a Clean
Water Act permit for a trio of major flood-control pumps used to drain Weston, Pembroke Pines, Cooper City and other areas. The key question water managers operating the pumps have put before the justices: If you move polluted water from one place to another, but don't
pollute that water yourself, and it fouls the water it is added to, are you a polluter? Regarding the district's S-9 pumping station in Everglades Holiday Park, a federal district and appellate court so far have said yes, siding with the environmental group Friends of the Everglades and the Miccosukee Tribe, which inhabits the Everglades. Both sued the district, saying the powerful pumps one-half mile west of U.S. 27 and Griffin Road muscle phosphorus, pesticides and other pollutants to a destination they would not flow to naturally: marshes
south of Interstate 75. The district has argued the permit program is for individual polluters,
such as wastewater-treatment plants, not Florida agencies that pass water from point to point under their obligation to whisk away storm water that could flood homes and streets.
Read more

Letter to the Editor: Big Sugar's nerve
By Sally L. Spencer, Boca Raton
© Sun-Sentinel
I am not going to keep quiet anymore. How dare Big Sugar impugn the motives and character of a person of Judge William Hoeveler's stature? He represents the very best there is in human nature. No amount of money buys him -- or would. They just made me and many others warriors against the sugar industry. Shape up, Sugar.  Read more

U.S. justices to hear Glades pumping permit case
Miccosukees filed polluted water suit
By Frank Davies
© Miami Herald
The U.S. Supreme Court announced Friday that it would consider a case ordering South Florida water managers to get a federal permit for pumping polluted water into the Everglades. The South Florida Water Management District argued that it did not need a permit under the federal Clean Water Act for its flood-control pumping station in western Broward County that keeps nearby subdivisions dry. The floodwaters pumped into the Everglades are polluted by other sources, so permits were not applicable, the district maintained. A federal appellate court last year ruled against the district and for the Miccosukee tribe and Friends of the Everglades, an environmental group. The Miccosukees said the pumping station was sending polluted water onto their land.  Read more

 

27-June-03

Lawsuits say U.S. actions threaten Florida panthers
By Times Staff Writer
© St. Petersburg Times
A pair of lawsuits filed by environmental groups Thursday accuse federal officials of allowing developers and miners to destroy crucial habitat for the endangered Florida panther. One lawsuit challenges a permit approved by the Army Corps of Engineers and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service that allows Florida Rock Industries to open a 6,000-acre limestone mine in Fort Myers in panther habitat. In exchange, Florida Rock will set aside 800 acres for preservation. The other suit filed by the National Wildlife Federation and two other groups targets blanket permits issued by the Corps of Engineers for some types of development without individual environmental reviews. The permits are intended to be used when there will be minimal impact on the environment. The groups say they have been used for development in Lee and Collier counties that has been harmful to panthers.  Read more

Water system to cost billions
By Curtis Morgan
© Miami Herald
The massive system that fills tubs and flushes toilets in most of Miami-Dade County is in line for its biggest and most expensive expansion in decades. With a $2.5 billion price tag and plans to pump more sewage and storm runoff deep underground, it also may prove among the most controversial plumbing jobs that Miami-Dade's Water and Sewer Department has done. The plan faces scrutiny by the County Commission -- at a committee briefing set for 9 a.m. today and July 15 by the full commission -- but some commissioners already are raising questions, mainly about the big bucks. Environmentalists also have concerns, topped by the threat of sewage or runoff bubbling up and tainting drinking water. One thing is clear. Water, even in rainy South Florida, won't flow so freely in the future. Not with sprawling suburbs projected to increase demand by 42 percent in 20 years and the $8 billion effort to revive the Everglades putting nature in competition with people for a precious liquid asset. Bill Brant, director of Miami-Dade's water and sewer department, believes there will be enough water to slake the thirst of continuing growth. But he also echoes a warning that regional water managers and conservation groups have been issuing for years.  Read more

Last citrus packer is closing up
By Susan Salisbury, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
Palm Beach County's last citrus packing house will not be opening when the season starts again this fall. Gone with the $7 million state-of-the-art plant, owned by Callery-Judge Grove near Loxahatchee, are 320 seasonal jobs and 30 year-round jobs. "We analyzed the numbers and looked forward to what we expected for this coming year," said Nat Roberts, general manager of the grove. "The risks outweighed the rewards. The citrus business is not getting any prettier." Callery-Judge will continue to operate its 4,000-acre grove, said Roberts, and a staff of 20 will remain. The tangerines, grapefruit, navel oranges and other specialty fruit will be hauled for packing to other companies' facilities in the state. Declining profits in the fresh-fruit business coupled with the spread of citrus canker led to the decision, Roberts said. The grove itself eventually will be transformed into some type of development, and the land's fate is being debated by the county. But the decision to close the packing house was purely bottom-line. "What the county is deciding to do had nothing to do with the packing house," Roberts said. "It was a business decision." Doug Bournique, executive vice president of the Indian River Citrus League in Vero Beach, said more packers and growers are getting out of the business. "It's a killer combo platter of things that are forcing people like Nat, who are wonderful employers, to make a decision they don't really want to make," Bournique said. The Indian River region from central Palm Beach County to Daytona Beach has 41 packing houses, down from 45 a few years ago.  Read more

Letter to the Editor: State should detail, not hide, effects of wastewater wells
By Alan Fargo, Sierra Club
© Palm Beach Post
In the June 14 editorial "The deep well problem," The Post writes, "There are no perfect solutions for disposing of treated sewage in Florida... "; however, there is an intermediate solution to the stonewalling by Gov. Bush and Department of Environmental Protection Secretary David Struhs: Come clean now. A recent Sierra Club report documented extensive problems with the state's published information on injection wells and estimates that nearly 1 billion gallons per day of toxin-laden wastewater is being injected into Florida's deep aquifers. The Post suggests the quantity is "only" half of that: We don't know the exact number because the DEP won't respond to our requests. Information published by this state agency is so poorly organized and so incomplete that this aspect of the state's responsibility to the environment and public health literally has disappeared into a black hole. The state is shrouding the wastewater issue in layers of technical committees and jargon, while quietly strong-arming the federal environmental agency, the EPA, to relax its pollution limits on underground injection wells. The EPA is now considering a rule change to the Safe Drinking Water Act to accommodate Florida. We know why.  Read more

The favorite mammal
Editorial
© Palm Beach Post
If the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has any doubts about creating three new manatee protection zones in Florida, the agency should consider the overwhelming public comments it has received supporting plans for the safe areas. Of more than 5,000 people throughout Florida and the U.S. who sent letters and e-mails to the Fish and Wildlife Service, 4,532 favor the protection areas and 1,006 are opposed. Those figures show overwhelming support from the public for protecting the endangered sea cow. But public support hasn't always translated to manatee-friendly policies from agencies under pressure from boaters and fishermen. The Fish and Wildlife Service will announce its final rule on the safe havens in July. Some boaters and fishermen and groups that claim to represent them have opposed setting aside manatee protection areas because such zones require slower boat speeds. The areas include a refuge on Lee County's Caloosahatchee River, where manatees frequently die in boat collisions, another in the St. Johns River and a third in the area of the Halifax and Tomoka rivers in Volusia County. The Fish and Wildlife Service stalled for several months in designating the three protection areas. Last year, the agency bowed to a request from Gov. Bush to wait until Dec. 1, 2003, to set aside the safe havens. After the Fish and Wildlife Service continually postponed action and missed deadlines, U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan threatened for a second time to hold Interior Secretary Gale Norton in contempt for the agency's failure to designate the protection areas. The judge said there was no justification for the delay other than Gov. Bush's request, which manatee protection groups charged was timed to keep the issue out of the public eye until after the election last fall.  Read more

Supreme Court to Hear Everglades Case
By Associated Press
© Miami Herald
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court said Friday that it would consider a case involving the endangered Florida Everglades that tests the federal government's power to fight pollution. Justices will consider next term how much authority the federal government has in controlling water pumping across the Everglades basin. The Bush administration urged the court last month to reject the appeal from Florida water managers who argued they should not be required to get federal permits for water pump facilities. An appeals court had sided with environmentalists and an Indian tribe in ordering the South Florida Water Management District to apply for permits. James Edward Nutt, the district's attorney, told justices in a filing that the ruling would affect a wide range of people, from private landowners and farmers to government water managers. Solicitor General Theodore Olson, the Bush administration's lawyer before the Supreme Court, said the federal and state government are working together to restore the Everglades and the case could be moot.  Read more

Blazing a trail
Plans call for 23-mile path along creek
By Tom Germond, News-Gazette Staff Writer
© Oceola News-Gazette
Local governments are seeking federal funding for a proposed 23-mile trail that would snake along the headwaters of the Everglades in Orange and Osceola counties. Orlando, Kissimmee, Orange County and Osceola County governments are applying for $8 million to build nine miles or four segments of the Shingle Creek trail that would serve bicyclists, joggers, in-line skaters and hikers. The South Florida Water Management District and other agencies involved in the project said the trail would showcase Shingle Creek's environmental
values as well as provide recreational and transportation benefits for residents and tourists.
"We see the trail as an environmental educational opportunity," said Orlando project manager Jeff Arms at an information session Tuesday night. According to the grant application, each government entity is applying for $2 million for its section of the trail, which eventually could run between Lake Toho-pekaliga in Osceola County and Conroy Road in Orlando.  Read more

Shingle Creek
© South Florida Water Management District
Shingle Creek Swamp covers more than 7,000 acres in southern Orange and northern Osceola Counties. It is a major receiving body for storm water runoff from areas south and southwest of Orlando. The Orange County portion of the swamp is more than 1.5 miles wide, and is dominated by cypress, loblolly bay, and red maple. Water depths of 24" during much of the year are common. The swamp is bisected in the north-south and east-west directions by an Orlando Utility Authority transmission line and access road. Shingle Creek itself was channelized in the 1920's and it borders the eastern edge of the swamp. Most of the floodplain in Osceola County is intact, but adjacent uplands, which historically were wiregrass/longleaf pine-dominated systems, have been cleared and planted as improved pasture.  Read more

80-year-old judge fights to preserve his Everglades legacy
By Catherine Wilson, Associated Press
© Environmental News Network
MIAMI — The legacy of William Hoeveler may be 15 years spent policing a complex lawsuit mired in biology and hydrology that is intended to restore the Everglades to its bygone days as a free-flowing, slow-growth marsh. Best known as the judge who sent Panamanian dictator Manuel Noriega to prison in 1992, the 80-year-old jurist returned to the headlines in the spring by saying a new Everglades law heralded by Gov. Jeb Bush was "clearly defective" even before it was signed. The law would extend some of the deadlines for Everglades restoration. Stiffened by a stroke and back trouble but still ramrod straight in person and in deed, the judge insists the federal and state governments are bound by their commitments to him in a 1992 consent decree — no matter what state lawmakers concoct. Read more

26-June-03

Letter to the Editor:  Cleanup timetable 'flexibility' may end up choking Everglades
By Mark D. Perry, Executive Director of the Florida Oceanographic Society
© Palm Beach Post
Here are a few points that the public needs to know about the new law (SB 626) signed by the governor that rewrites the Everglades Forever Act. On March 12, the South Florida Water Management District governing board overwhelmingly endorsed the draft conceptual plan for achieving long-term water-quality goals in the Everglades Protection Area tributary basins. The board made two modifications to this plan: It "acknowledged the need for flexibility in achieving the water-quality goals in the Everglades and changed the plan objective to obtain, to the maximum extent practicable, a predicted long-term geometric mean phosphorus concentration in discharges to the Everglades Protection Area" and defined a more realistic pace toward achieving the phosphorus criterion. The board directed staff to implement a
second 10-year phase (2017-2026) of continuous improvement in phosphorous reduction as necessary to achieve the plan objective. The "long-term plan" referred to above (more than 500 pages) is embodied in the new law. The "glitch bill" may have removed the phrase "to the maximum extent practicable," but the "second 10-year phase" still will allow the phosphorous pollution to continue until 2026, 23 years past the 2003 original deadline.
Read more

EPA May Ease Its Drinking Water Rules
By Neil Johnson
© Tampa Tribune
TAMPA - Every day, 640 million gallons of sewage in Florida is injected deep underground, where it's supposed to stay far away from drinking water supplies. But what goes down is coming up, migrating into portions of the aquifer that cities and counties tap for their water supplies, a violation of current federal regulations governing drinking water. Officials from the federal Environmental Protection Agency were in Tampa on Wednesday to get public opinion about a controversial proposal to relax those rules and allow what's called deep-well injection of sewage to continue, even if the treated effluent is mixing with drinking water. Changes are opposed by environmental groups, but utilities - mainly in South Florida - want the regulations altered. The change would apply only to Florida. Although the vast majority of the injected sewage is in Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach counties, St. Petersburg uses that method to dispose of an average of 20 million gallons a day - about 3 percent of the state's total and almost exclusively during the rainy season when demand for its reclaimed water hits bottom. Either of two changes the EPA is considering could cost the city's sewer customers dearly.  Read more

Sugar's bitter aftertaste
Editorial
© Orlando Sentinel
Our position: The mistake made by the governor and legislators is creating trouble for the Everglades. For weeks, the sugar industry and the Bush administration pooh-poohed threats by congressional appropriators that an odious bill delaying Everglades restoration for a decade could imperil federal funding. Drawing once again from their bottomless pit of arrogance, the sugar barons dismissed the warnings as so much ill-informed chatter. Gov. Jeb Bush followed suit, signing the bill into law despite repeated federal objections. Well, the consequences of their "we-know-best" attitude now are becoming manifest. A powerful House subcommittee last week attached strict stipulations to Everglades funding, requiring the state to honor prior commitments to improve the quality of water flowing into the fabled River of Grass or risk federal participation in the restoration effort.  Read more

Letter to the Editor:  Laws help Everglades
By Michael Collins, SFWMD Governing Board Member
© Key West Citizen
Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. The Citizen is awfully quick to falsely accuse state legislators of "shirking responsibility" regarding funding for Everglades cleanup, when, in
reality, the newspaper is shirking its own responsibility to get the facts straight before publishing inaccurate and uninformed tirades. When stories and editorials are based primarily on quotes from Audubon professional lobbyists and master media manipulator Mary Barley, the newspaper's readers are sure to be shortchanged when it comes to a balanced
perspective of the issue. As these and other environmental extremist groups are well aware, the amended Everglades Forever Act did not shift the funding burden away from sugar growers and onto the public. It is not some kind of veiled -- or overt -- attempt to let the sugar industry off the hook. In reality, it continues the shared responsibility concept of the original law which recognizes that we all, in one way or another, contribute to the problem and, therefore, must contribute to the solution. It is important to note, however, that the new law does increase and extend the funding obligations of area farmers. 
Read more

Florida Panther Lawsuits Filed
News Release
© National Wildlife Federation 
WASHINGTON, D.C. - The National Wildlife Federation, the nation's leading conservation education and advocacy organization, and two Florida conservation groups today filed two separate legal actions in Federal District Court here seeking action to protect the rapidly diminishing habitat of the severely endangered Florida panther. In one action, the National Wildlife Federation (NWF), the Florida Wildlife Federation (FWF) and the Florida Panther Society (FPS) are asking the court to order the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) to stop construction of the Florida Rock Industries'
Ft. Myers Mine #2 until the mine's effect on the Florida panther is more thoroughly investigated. In a second action, NWF and the Florida Panther Society are challenging the
Corps' use of the Clean Water Act's permitting process which has resulted in the loss of substantial tracts of habitat deemed essential to the panther's survival. In the Ft. Myers Mine case, government wildlife biologists have identified the land the Corps has approved for development as important panther habitat. "Both the law and sound science argue persuasively against the Corps decision to authorize this substantial sacrifice of habitat panther need just to have a chance to survive," said John Kostyack, NWF senior counsel.
Read more

Alliance still willing to negotiate
Martin County Commissioners rejected a settlement Tuesday.
By Jim Turner
© Stuart News
MARTIN COUNTY - Time is running out on efforts to settle an environmental group's challenge to the county's Comprehensive Plan, because a judge is expected to rule on the case soon, the group said Wednesday. The Martin County Conservation Alliance has challenged changes to the public facilities section of the Comprehensive Growth Management Plan that make it easier to build public facilities such as schools and fire stations by waiving strict development regulations. The County Commission on Tuesday rejected a settlement proposal and voted to continue negotiations for another two weeks. Alliance members said Wednesday they are still open to a settlement. However, they don't expect to reach a deal before an administrative law judge releases his ruling on the case.
Read more

Sulfurous stink no cause for alarm in PSL
The smell comes from water being treated with a new product at the city's water treatment plant
By Robin Campbell
© Stuart News
PORT ST. LUCIE - Residents who may have detected a hint of rotten eggs in the air the past few days can quit sniffing around the home and yard looking for leftover Easter goods. The smell is Florida's natural water being treated by one of the city's neighborhood water treatment plants. The city's utility department on Wednesday began testing a new product at
its Reverse Osmosis Water Treatment Plant on Ogden Lane that is designed to dissipate the natural rotten egg-like smell of water taken from Florida's aquifer. During the 30-day trial some residents within a couple of blocks of the plant could detect the natural odors while utility crews perfect the new process. "It's like a pinch of this and a dash of that. We've got to get the formula right," said Donna Rhoden, public information manager for the city's utility
department. "The smell is a transitional period while we're fine-tuning the process."
  Read more

Carol Browner Elected National Audubon Society Chair
© National Audubon Society
New York, NY, June 26, 2003 - Carol M. Browner, the longest serving administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency, has been elected chair of the National Audubon Society Board of Directors. Browner will be the first woman to chair Audubon, and is one of few women to hold such a position at a major conservation organization. "It is truly a privilege to help lead such a distinguished organization," Browner said at the announcement of her election. "Audubon has been at the forefront of environmental issues since the turn of the century when two determined women founded the first Audubon Chapter. Today, it is again leading the way, educating a whole new generation of Americans about the need to protect bird and wildlife habitat and to fight for clean water and clean air." Browner will replace Donal C. O'Brien when he retires this fall after having served 12 years as Audubon Chair. Browner joined the Audubon Board in 2001 and currently oversees its Public Policy Committee. Browner served as EPA Administrator from 1993 to 2001. Throughout her tenure at the EPA, Browner was guided by the philosophy that safeguarding the environment meant protecting where people live and how they live. She partnered with business leaders, community advocates, and all levels of government to promote common sense, cost-effective solutions to the nation's most pressing environmental and public health problems.  Read more

 

25-June-03

Spin cycle can't rinse out pollution
By Sally Swartz, Editorial Writer
© Palm Beach Post
I seldom find much to applaud about the way the Bush brothers handle environmental issues. But President Bush, Gov. Bush -- and sometimes officials at their environmental agencies, which are supposed to be impartial -- are experts at "spin." They are masters at altering facts, changing rules and standards and complicating simple information so that
truth is either elusive or invisible. Last week, the White House altered a section of the Environmental Protection Agency's report on the state of the environment to reflect the views of the energy industry on global warming. The EPA's own views, based on scientific
studies, warned that pollution from automobiles and factories is affecting the environment and public health. The Bush administration rewrite decided global warming is a "theory." In Florida this week, watch for more spin on the need to pump wastewater underground. The EPA is holding hearings on whether to change rules that allow treated sewage to be pumped deep below the Earth's surface, despite evidence that the polluted wastewater is moving, contaminating drinking-water supplies and surfacing on the ocean floor, feeding algae that
smothers reefs. The federal agency is cooperating with Florida's Department of Environmental Protection to try to weaken standards only in South Florida, which has more deep-injection wells than any other part of the United States. If the EPA doesn't change its rule, said Scott Randolph, attorney with the Legal Environmental Assistance Foundation, it would have
to enforce the law and shut down the disposal wells that are leaking. 
Read more

Buoy system could save manatees
By Bob Keefe
© Palm Beach Post
SAN DIEGO -- Using technology designed for fish-finders and submarine tracking equipment, researchers here are developing a floating warning system that would alert Florida boaters to slow down whenever a manatee is near. The system would be connected to flashing buoys in areas where manatees are common, creating something like a school-crossing zone to protect the slow-moving mammals. "It would be just like when the kids get out of school and the flashing lights go off warning people to slow down," said Jules Jaffe, a research oceanographer at Scripps Institution of Oceanography who is helping lead the project. Also participating is the Hubbs-SeaWorld Research Institute. Last year, more than 300 manatees died in Florida waters, according to state figures. About 30 percent of those deaths were attributed to boats. The sonar system is one of six manatee avoidance projects being funded by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission's Florida Marine Research Institute. The Florida Legislature two years ago agreed to spend $200,000 on such research through the institute in an effort to reduce the number of manatees killed or injured by boats.
Read more

Water managers won't close library
By Robert King
© Palm Beach Post
A second state library has escaped the chopping block -- this time, the 54-year-old reference center at the South Florida Water Management District. Water managers said Tuesday they will keep the collection of more than 50,000 documents intact at the district's headquarters in suburban West Palm Beach, rather then sending most of it to Florida Atlantic University in Boca Raton. The district had considered dismantling the library to save money and space.
But workers in the 1,800-employee agency wanted the documents to stay, Executive Director Henry Dean said. "There are a lot of staff members who really do use the library and
expressed a keen interest in having it remain," Dean said. So did scientists and scholars outside. As a compromise, he said, the district will install rolling shelves that reduce the number of aisles needed between the stacks. That will let the district chop 6,000 square feet from the library, which now occupies 12,600 square feet. 
Read more

Wishing for reservoir fishing
Basin proposal excludes recreational use
By Byron Stout
© News-Press


John Denby of Punta Gorda teaches his grandchildren, Trevor Schuler, 14,
back left, and Adrianna Denby, 13, front left, both from Punta Gorda, and
Amber Radli, 10, of West Palm Beach, how to fish at Webb Lake in Charlotte
County. Webb Lake, in the Babcock/Webb Wildlife Management Area, is an
example of a manmade lake helping the environment and being used for water-related
recreational purposes. The reservoir to be built in Hendry County doesn’t call for any
water-related activities.
TODD STUBING/news-press.com


Fishermen and fishery managers beam as if in the glow of a Christmas tree when they hear a 31-square-mile reservoir — potentially the seventh-largest lake in the state — soon will be built in Southwest Florida. “We’re not creating large lakes in the state of Florida anymore. It could be very exciting,” said Ed Moyer, director of freshwater fisheries for the state’s Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission. Unfortunately, the news might be exciting for birdwatchers and hikers but not for angling advocates. Project engineers don’t see fishing in the reservoir’s future. Any recreational uses, and they are all non-water related, are secondary to the reservoir’s main functions. The C-43 Basin Reservoir is billed as a Caloosahatchee River restoration project. Its main purpose will be to catch massive water releases from Lake Okeechobee that have been destroying the river’s ecosystem. Those waters then will be used for agricultural and urban uses, and for environmentally appropriate releases back into the river. Even though the plans don’t include fishing, anglers and other recreation enthusiasts can give their opinions at public hearings scheduled today and Thursday in Fort Myers and Clewiston by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the South Florida Water Management District.  Read more

Related Links:
Everglades Restoration Page
   http://www.news-press.com/news/local_state/030406gladesmain.html
Fishing page:
   http://cityguide.news-press.com/fe/Fishing/Search.asp
Outdoors page:
   http://cityguide.news-press.com/fe/Recreation/Search.asp
Envrinonment page:
   http://www.news-press.com/news/environment/index.html

Fla. Judge Fights To Preserve Everglades
By Catherine Wilson, Associated Press Writer
©
Guardian Unlimited- United Kingdom
MIAMI (AP) - The legacy of William Hoeveler may be 15 years spent policing a complex lawsuit mired in biology and hydrology that is intended to restore the Everglades to its bygone days as a free-flowing, slow-growth marsh. Best known as the judge who sent Panamanian dictator Manuel Noriega to prison in 1992, the 80-year-old jurist returned to the headlines in the spring by saying a new Everglades law heralded by Gov. Jeb Bush was
``clearly defective'' even before it was signed. The law would extend some of the deadlines for Everglades restoration. Stiffened by a stroke and back trouble but still ramrod straight in person and in deed, the judge insists the federal and state governments are bound by their commitments to him in a 1992 consent decree - no matter what state lawmakers concoct. The agreement with the state dictates a 2006 deadline for cleaning up the quality of water flowing into Everglades National Park from the broader Everglades ecosystem above it. But sugar growers say Hoeveler's 15 years of policing the Everglades is long enough. Claiming the judge has turned into a bully with a political bent, they asked two courts to throw him off the case for bias. They don't want him in charge of any more Everglades hearings.
  Read more
Judge Hoeveler News Page

Senators Keen to Reform Endangered Species Act
By J.R. Pegg
© Environmental News Service


Section 7 is designed to protect endangered species - like the pygmy owl -
from the negative impacts of federal agency actions. (Photo by Robin
Silver courtesy Center for Biological Diversity )


WASHINGTON, DC, June 25, 2003 (ENS) - Some Republican senators believe the requirement that federal agencies consult with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service to ensure their actions do not jeopardize endangered species has become too costly and time consuming. The process is burdening federal agencies without producing measurable conservation benefits and should be reformed, the senators said today at a subcommittee hearing. This process needs "major surgery," said Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski, a Republican. "The potential for abuse remains inherent in the statute as written." Under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act (ESA), all federal agencies must consult with either the Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) or the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) if they believe any proposed action may affect the continued existence of any endangered or threatened species. Murkowski and other critics of Section 7 say that it is a mass of red tape and is needlessly delaying federal projects and permits, bogging down agencies with paperwork, and costing private citizens and companies considerable money. "The services are expending colossal resources on a process that produces a lot of paperwork without a lot of positive impacts on recovery," said Senator Michael Crapo, an Idaho Republican and chair of the Senate Subcommittee on Fisheries, Wildlife and Water.  Read more

Ringleaders must stop risking 'Glades funding
Editorial
© Keynoter
Waiting for the other shoe to drop on Everglades funding? The wait ended last week when a key congressional committee revoked $32 million promised to help Florida acquire land needed for Everglades restoration. Worse than the loss of $32 million is the ominous warning that came with the rebuke. The budget gatekeepers said future federal dollars pledged - about $4 billion of the estimated $8.4 billion restoration cost - are also in jeopardy because it looks as if Florida is stalling on its promised timetable to clean up the River of Grass. The U.S. House Interior Appropriations Subcommittee, which controls the flow of dollars critical to this massive 30-year restoration effort, delivered the message after earlier warnings from GOP leaders in Congress fell on deaf ears.  Read more

 

24-June-03

Sugar's role in cleanup rapped
By Libby Wells, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
STUART -- There was a lot of talk about sugar Monday night at a public workshop on Everglades restoration. But none of it was sweet. Florida's sugar industry has left a bitter taste in the mouths of Treasure Coast residents, judging by the comments at a forum organized by the Marine Resources Council that was held at the Blake Library. The recent signing of a bill into law allowing for a delay in the Everglades cleanup, which was supported by sugar growers, and the industry's criticism of the now-stalled Indian River Lagoon restoration plan have left many people fed up with Big Sugar. "We've got to go into the national arena and stop the subsidy for sugar," said Stuart resident Charles Pierce. "There are politicians around the U.S. who don't like the sugar subsidy," added Bill Thornton of Palm City.  Read more


23
-June-03

Federal judge scrutinized over Everglades remarks
Sugar industry: Comments show bias
By Jay Weaver and Curtis Morgan 
© Miami Herald
In the spring, a federal judge accused state legislators of messing with the court-ordered Everglades cleanup, saying their bill was ''clearly defective'' and that the governor was being ``misled by persons who do not have the best interests of the Everglades at heart.''   Senior U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler is about to learn whether his unusually provocative comments will cost him the job of enforcing the cleanup agreement that he orchestrated a decade ago.  The sugar industry is seeking to have the prominent Miami judge pulled off
the case, claiming his ''bully pulpit'' comments in court and to reporters betray a bias against sugar interests.
 Several legal experts say Hoeveler may have entered the realm of impropriety when he spoke with reporters about the Everglades case, but they stress it's
rare for a federal judge to be removed over an issue of fairness -- unless he says something flagrantly prejudicial.
  Such removals are uncommon, because federal judges rarely talk publicly about their cases. Possible punishment ranges from a public reprimand to
removal from a case.
  Read more   
Judge Hoeveler News Page

One more chance
Editorial
© Orlando Sentinel
Our position: Gov. Bush can save the Wekiva basin by declaring it a "critical concern." The future of the Wekiva River basin, completion of a beltway around Orlando and the containment of urban sprawl north of Apopka rest in the hands of Gov. Jeb Bush. He alone has the ability to determine Central Florida's destiny, to provide the environmental protections and mobility options that Rep. Fred Brummer of Apopka almost single-handedly scuttled during this year's legislative session.  To do so, however, Mr. Bush must take decisive action -- and soon. Further study of 17 recommendations issued by a gubernatorial task force that
thoroughly examined how best to protect the Wekiva won't do the trick. That's what land speculators and a handful of money-grubbing local officials want. Led by Apopka Mayor John Land, those folks couldn't care less if development robs the Wekiva of its water resources. They just want the additional property tax revenues to bloat municipal coffers.  Read more

 

More library woes
Water Management District wants to dismantle its library, too
Editorial
© Stuart News
This has been a tough year for libraries. First Gov. Jeb Bush pushes plans to eliminate the state library and archives in Tallahassee by giving them to Nova Southeastern University in Broward County, and now the board of the South Florida Water Management District wants to close down its libraries. Both moves are touted as cost-saving initiatives. The economic argument is shortsighted. Any savings realized from closing down the libraries would be more than offset by the need for government staffers and researchers to spend more time hunting down sources and bits of information. Only someone who doesn't read much, and has no need to research a specific issue, would make such a proposal.  Read more

 

22-June-03

Everglades' Straitjacket
Editorial
© The Ledger
Members of Congress warned Florida legislators and Gov. Jeb Bush that if the state tampered with its agreement to clean up the Everglades, the federal-state partnership to fund the $8 billion project would be jeopardized. They weren't kidding. The first batch of federal money to get the cleanup started -- about $1 billion thus far -- was sent to the state to spend in whatever way officials thought would move the plan forward. But last week, Congress attached so many strings to future payments that they look like a marionette's nightmare.
Read more

Report card
Editorial
© Orlando Sentinel
Our position: Legislators don't have a very high average for this year's sessions. Lawmakers and the governor properly hold public schools accountable by assigning annual letter grades to measure performance. So it's only fair that they be similarly assessed. How are they doing? Is the state headed in the right direction? In what legislative areas can they claim success? Unlike most public schools, though, Gov. Jeb Bush and lawmakers have few
achievements to savor. After a bitter, 60-day session that produced hardly a single piece of noteworthy legislation, lawmakers since have returned twice to Tallahassee at the governor's behest to finish up their business. And last week, they failed again to rein in soaring medical-malpractice insurance costs.  Read more

 

21-June-03

An Everglades alarm
Editorial
© Palm Beach Post
Worried that a new state law means Florida won't keep its promise to clean up the Everglades, a U.S. House panel has cut some Everglades restoration money and tied strings on the rest to try to make the state keep its commitments. Gov. Bush has said he'll convince federal lawmakers the new law doesn't hurt the Everglades. Now is the time to start. But repeal might be his only tool. Members of Florida's congressional delegation had warned the Legislature not to pass the law, which the sugar industry wrote, and Gov. Bush not to sign
it. The law amends the 1994 Everglades Forever Act and threatens to violate a 1992 consent decree, muddying standards for clean water, extending the cleanup deadline and shifting cleanup costs from sugar industry polluters to state taxpayers. Florida and the federal government are splitting the $8.4 billion restoration costs 50-50, but the new state law has so unnerved federal partners not even Gov. Bush's personal visit to Washington could reassure
Congress. The U.S. House Interior Appropriations Subcommittee revoked $32 million Congress had promised the state to buy land for restoration. The subcommittee also insists Florida must follow the old law, not the
Everglades from cities and farms by the original 2006 deadline, not the state extension to 2016. 
Read more

Feds hit state in wallet for Everglades Forever Act
By Joel Eskovitz
© Naples News
WASHINGTON - Federal legislators followed through this week on their threat to the state of Florida over Everglades funding, slashing $32 million for land acquisition and attaching strings to another $68 million for the restoration effort. Members of the House appropriations subcommittee for the Interior had warned Gov. Jeb Bush in a meeting last month against signing a controversial amendment to the Everglades Forever Act that could potentially delay the state's meeting of water-quality standards. The possibility of delay led the subcommittee to shift $32 million expected to be used to purchase land for the restoration. That money will now be earmarked for a cleanup effort in the Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge. The $68 million that the panel approved - which is $44 million less than the president sought - also forces the state to jump through a few more hoops. To get the construction money in this year's budget along with up to $100 million previously approved, the state must report to four federal agencies that it is meeting water-quality standards as established in a consent
decree in the original Everglades Forever Act. 
Read more

Farmers win no new local regulation
Bush signs a bill seen by agricultural interests as crucial to their
survival, and by counties and cities as an intrusion

By Julie Hauserman
© St. Petersburg Times
TALLAHASSEE - Despite opposition from local governments across the state, Gov. Jeb Bush on Friday signed a bill into law barring cities and counties from passing new regulations on agriculture. The sweeping measure has been pushed for years by lobbyists for Florida's
citrus, timber, vegetable and cattle industries. They say local regulations are threatening their businesses. "Realistically, the governor has thrown a life preserver to the agricultural
industry in Florida," said Phil Leary of the Florida Farm Bureau. But opponents, including the Florida Association of Counties and the Hillsborough Environmental Protection Commission, say the measure strips local governments of authority. The law has already had an effect. Last month, the Citrus County Commission tabled an ordinance it drafted to regulate intensive farming. Residents demanded the new regulations after a large dairy operation was built off County Road 491. 
Read more

Everglades Restoration Utilizes Web-based Solution
Newsletter- Posted on June 21, 2003
© Accela, Inc
The South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD) recently announced it will restore, protect, and preserve more than 18,000-square miles of land with the assistance of Accela's Web-based solution, Accela AutomationTM. Specifically, the solution will be utilized to track land acquisition associated with the restoration of the Florida Everglades. The SFWMD will acquire $41 billion of land in support of the restoration of the Florida Everglades over the next 40 years, with the goal of returning the land to a strong and vibrant natural environment. The solution will provide a streamlined process, as well as public access to land acquisition
data. Charged with managing the water supply of 16 central and southern Florida
counties, the Agency is leading the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan (CERP). The Plan is designed to the restore the unique ecosystem of the Everglades to its original state. 
Read more

 

20-June-03

Premise for river-pollution checks criticized
By Libby Wells
© Palm Beach Post
STUART -- A system for deciding which of Florida's water bodies are the most polluted came under criticism Thursday during a sparsely attended public hearing held by the state Department of Environmental Protection. The DEP presented a list of St. Lucie and Loxahatchee river basins that are high in contaminants or have problems such as low oxygen levels that imperil marine life. The draft list included 31 sites such as the C-23 and C-24 canals, Ten Mile Creek and various points along the north and south forks of the St. Lucie
River. The DEP will approve a final list this fall, then establish strategies for cleaning the worst water bodies as part of a plan to comply with the federal Clean Water Act. But the premise of the program -- to establish the highest levels of pollutants a water body will tolerate before it's no longer safe for animals or people -- doesn't make sense to some.
"That doesn't jibe with what we're trying to accomplish for cleaning up our waters," said Mark Perry, executive director of the Florida Oceanographic Society. "Why figure out a maximum amount of pollution to go into water and still have its designated uses? Why should we be allowing any pollution in a water body?" 
Read more

Related Links:
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
http://www.dep.state.fl.us
The Watershed Management Program is responsible for fostering better
stewardship of Florida's ground and surface water resources. Working with

private sector, the bureau coordinates the collection, data management, and
interpretation of monitoring information to assess the health of our water
resources; develops watershed-based aquatic resource goals and pollutant
loading limits for individual water bodies; and develops and implements
management action plans to preserve or restore water bodies. These
activities are undertaken using the rotating basin approach that assures
that the watershed plans for each of the state's watersheds are evaluated
and updated every five years.
http://www.dep.state.fl.us/water/watersheds/index.htm
Florida Water Quality Assessment -- 305(b) Report
The 305(b) report is a biennial assessment of the water quality of Florida's
waters. It provides a summary of water quality by water body type, i.e.
good, fair, poor and is displayed on maps organized by Hydrological Units.
The report also identifies sources and causes of pollution for each water
body type and summarizes pollution prevention programs, management programs,
restoration and rehabilitation activities, monitoring activities, and
provides an evaluation of ground water quality.

http://www.dep.state.fl.us/water/305b/index.htm

Corps of Engineers Pressures Homeowners to Sell by Threatening to Condemn Their Land
By National Center for Public Policy Research
© Cybercast News Service
An 8.5-square-mile area along the eastern edge of the Everglades National mostly of Cuban descent - who live on small, family owned farms. The community contains about 320 homes. Residents grow fruit, vegetables and flowers and raise pigs, goats, chickens and horses. A proposed Army Corps of Engineers' levee and seepage canal would require the taking of about 100 homes and would bisect the community. In 1989, Congress passed the Everglades National Park Protection and Expansion Act. It requires that the Corps, which controls the flow of fresh water in the Everglades area, "improve water deliveries into" the park. If these changes adversely affect the area, the Act requires the Corps to "construct a flood protection system for that portion of presently developed land within such area." The Corps' original 1992 plan sought construction of a levee on the western edge of the area. This plan would have protected all residents of the area and not condemned any homes. In 2002, the Corps, along with the U.S. Department of Interior (DOI), decided on an alternative plan that would put the canal and levee right through the middle of the community, forcing residents out of all homes in the canal's path and north and west of the canal. The Corps pressured affected homeowners to sign "offers to sell" by asserting that the Corps had
the authority to condemn their land if they did not voluntarily sell. Some homeowners, thinking they had no other choice, sold their land to the Corps. Seven homeowners, with the support of a local organization, the 8.5 Square Mile Legal Defense Foundation, filed a lawsuit against the Corps. 
Read more

Related Links:
Fortin Paper - Pariah, Florida

http://www.sfaa.net/eap/fortin/fortin.html
Standoff ensnares Everglades
.... Fortin and other holdouts want to see Everglades restoration happen, but
without touching a single home.
http://www.propertyrightsresearch.org/standoff_ensnares_everglades.htm
All I Did Was Buy A House
.... In the Everglades, according to Fortin, "Over half the tree islands in
the central Everglades are dead, killed by unnaturally high water."
http://www.mountaincoalition.org/articles/all_I_did.htm
Property Rights Violated......Rural America Under Siege
.... Madeleine Fortin on her land in Florida. I live in a small community in
Southeast Florida, on the eastern edge of Everglades National Park called
the 8.5 ...
http://www.cse.org/informed/issues_template.php?issue_id=1101
The Madeleine Fortin Story
http://www.scamsandscandals.com/MadeleineFortin.htm
Pariah, Florida: Feds Use Water as Weapon
Letter to Paragon Foundation
March 4, 2002
by Madeleine Fortin
http://www.aldenchronicles.com/archives/archives_paragon_fortin.html
A Plea For Help
Madeleine Fortin, president, East Everglades Legal Defense Foundation
http://www.paragonpowerhouse.org/a_plea_for_help.htm

Expert says regular Lake Okeechobee water releases needed
Too much fresh water from the lake can have detrimental effects on coastal
estuaries as far away as Estero Bay
By Chad Gillis
© Naples News
Freshwater releases from Lake Okeechobee into Lee County estuaries are going to be annual events in the region, at least until restoration projects can better deal with excess rainwater. That was one of the messages Trudi Williams, a member of the South Florida
Water Management District's governing board, delivered to a regional watershed monitoring group on Thursday. Williams spoke to members of the Southwest Florida Watershed Council about a variety of topics, from lake management to water reservations for natural systems to the possible future implementation of a stormwater utility for this region. "The top of the lake is only 21 feet, but the dam has been known to spring a leak," Williams said of a dike system that helps contain water within Florida's largest lake. "You can't have (18 feet) of water pushing against the walls around the lake. Were the walls to break, those (nearby) areas would be in major trouble." The 18-foot level Williams referred to is the height water managers say the
River and other systems. Releases have been controversial on this coast for years. Too much fresh water from the lake can have detrimental effects on coastal estuaries as far away as Estero Bay. 
Read more

House plan slaps Florida over Glades pact
The House panel also took back funds granted to Florida to buy land for the
cleanup project
By Cory Reiss, Washington Bureau
© Gainesville Sun
WASHINGTON - A House subcommittee on Wednesday decided to withhold federal money if Florida doesn't comply with a 1992 agreement to reduce pollution flowing into the Everglades.
The decision by the Interior Appropriations Subcommittee answers those who thought Congress wouldn't jeopardize federal funding for the $8 billion Everglades restoration as many had warned. The subcommittee required Florida to comply with a water quality deal, as spelled out in a consent decree that ended federal and state litigation. Four federal agencies - the departments of Interior and Justice, the Environmental Protection Agency and the Army Corps of Engineers - would have to agree twice a year that Florida is keeping its word or money from a $113 million account would stop flowing. Rep. C.W. 'Bill" Young, the Florida
Republican who chairs the full House Appropriations Committee, supported the measure. 
Read more

Developer's proposal would take advantage of rural growth plan
By Eric Staats
© Naples News


Click on the map to full full-sized image.
Graphic © Naples News 2003


Collier County's new plan for rural growth around Immokalee didn't have to wait long for somebody to use it. Barron Collier Cos. submitted a proposal this week under which they
would give up most of their development rights across 5,300 acres in the county's eastern reaches in return for credits to develop other areas. The credits could become the building blocks for a whole new town north of Oil Well Road and west of Camp Keais Road to support the proposed Ave Maria University, a Catholic university backed by Domino's Pizza founder Tom Monaghan. The Barron Collier proposal, dated Wednesday, is the first proposal submitted under new growth rules adopted by county commissioners Monday night. Plans for the university and town have yet to be submitted. Organizers want to open the university in fall 2006. The university's timetable puts a County Commission vote on the plans in
March 2004. The development credit proposal also requires approval by county commissioners. 
Read more

Alligator presence need not be tragic
The dangerous reptiles are a fact of Florida life. Coexisting peacefully with them depends on several important rules.
By Adrienne Lu
© St. Petersburg Times


Photo © Scott Keeler, St. Petersburg Times


ST. PETERSBURG - One day last summer, Christopher Dixon took his 10-year-old son for an unforgettable fishing trip at Lake Maggiore. The boy was standing near the shore when all of a sudden, Dixon said, an alligator "came out of the water charging at my son." Dixon threw a brick and whatever else he could find at the alligator, which retreated before it could do any harm. "He told me he'll never go freshwater fishing again," Dixon, 33, said Thursday, fishing with a buddy at Lake Maggiore. It's a fact of Florida living. If you're near freshwater, be it a retention pond, stream, lake or even backyard pool, a leathery alligator could be lurking. "I don't care what kind of body of water you have in the state of Florida, you have the potential for alligators," said Louis J. Guillette Jr., a professor of zoology at the University of Florida. A 12-year-old boy was killed by an alligator in Lake County on Wednesday knew there were alligators in the river where he and his friends had been swimming. But experts say people should be cautious anywhere there's water. With the mating season wrapping up, male alligators are still in their aggressive stage, guarding territory from other males and wandering as far as they need to in search of females. The summer rain showers don't help matters, adding to the number of streams and ponds the reptiles can use to get from one place to the next, Guillette said.  Read more

21 waterways make cleanup list
By Suzanne Wentley, Staff Writer
© Stuart News
STUART - The St. Lucie Estuary, the C-24 Canal and the Manatee Pocket are just three of 21 local waterways that made a preliminary list of polluted streams, rivers and lakes, state scientists announced Thursday. Most of the waterways in the St. Lucie and Loxahatchee river basins are polluted - with nutrients, mercury or bacteria - enough to be cleaned up by
a new state program, said Eric Livingston, a scientist with the state Department of Environmental Protection. Although local environmentalists weren't able to pick out any problem waterways that didn't make the list, many expressed disappointment with the
lengthy process. Cleanup is set to begin in 2005 on some area waterways and 2010 for others. "We know what the problem is, but it's still five years down the road, six years down the road, to fix it," said Henry Caimotto, owner of the Snook Nook and a member of the Martin County Anglers. "I've lost confidence in the system." Although the draft list offered Thursday won't be final until October, Livingston said data collection that has been under way for the past few years will help establish limits on further pollution, known as Total Maximum Daily Loads, or TMDL. 
Read more

 

19-June-03

Congress pressures state on Everglades restoration
By William E. Gibson, Washington Bureau
© Orlando Sentinel
WASHINGTON -- Key members of Congress put pressure on Florida officials Wednesday by threatening to hold up funding for Everglades restoration unless the state meets federal water-quality standards. The move by appropriators, who hold the purse strings for the massive restoration project, was the first substantive backlash to a controversial bill passed by the state Legislature that pushed back the deadline for cleaning up pollution in the Everglades. The U.S. House Interior Subcommittee added language to an appropriations
bill that would require federal agencies to certify the state is meeting water-quality standards before money can be released for a "water modification project." The project, designed to restore a flow of fresh water to Everglades National Park and Florida Bay, is an essential step before construction begins on an $8 billion replumbing of the Everglades over three decades. 
Read more

State loses oversight of Everglades project
By Mike Salinero
© Tamba Tribune
TALLAHASSEE - Congressional budget writers agreed Wednesday to send $68 million to Florida for Everglades restoration, but the money comes with plenty of strings attached, reflecting concerns that a new state law will postpone the swamp's cleanup. The appropriation brings to about $1 billion that the federal government has spent on restoring the Everglades to its pre-development splendor. The money of restoring the natural flow of water across the marsh. Until now, Congress has not seen fit to restrict how the money is used. That changed Wednesday when the House Appropriations Committee placed the state's
restoration efforts under federal oversight. Now, before the money can be released, Florida must establish that it is meeting its obligations under a federal court consent decree to clean up water entering the Everglades. The order calls for strict phosphate limits in the Everglades to be met by December 2006. The state Environmental Regulatory Commission is expected to set the limit at 10 parts per billion this year. The state's yearly progress report must be approved by the Department of
Engineers and the U.S. attorney general. ``I would characterize this as the state being put on a very short leash,'' said Charles Lee of Audubon of Florida. 
Read more

Miccosukee Tribe wants 'Glades judge to stay
By Neil Santaniello, Staff Writer
© Sun-Sentinel
Florida's sugar industry hasn't mustered sufficient proof U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler is too biased to continue his oversight of the Everglades cleanup, the Miccosukee Tribe said in a legal motion filed Wednesday. Instead of being disqualified from the case, Hoeveler should be commended for the restraint he has shown in the case, the tribe said in a response to U.S. Sugar's attempt to have chief District Judge William Zloch force Hoeveler out of his decadelong duty policing the state-run cleanup. Tribe attorney Dexter Lehtinen also argues in the response that U.S. Sugar lacks standing to seek the judge's ouster -- the intent of a motion it filed June 4 in Miami. That's because the Clewiston sugar grower is not one of the original parties to the 1992 federal-state settlement Hoeveler approved that spells out how the state will halt agricultural pollution pouring from fields into the northern Everglades, the tribe contends. The tribe's motion is the second filed in defense of Hoeveler in the wake of
two sugar industry court maneuvers to have the judge recused. Audubon of Florida said in a response it filed last week that U.S. Sugar's removal motion fails "on several counts," including falling short of proving the
judge is prejudiced against the industry. 
Read more

Everglades money cut
By Robert P. King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
Florida lawmakers' postponement of deadlines for cleaning the Everglades will cost the state at least $32 million in federal money -- and possibly billions more, congressional budget leaders said Wednesday. The U.S. House's Interior Appropriations subcommittee decided to revoke $32 million Congress had promised to give Florida to buy land for the restoration. The panel cited "the potential for delay" created by the new state law, and said the money should go instead to federal projects meant to help the Arthur R. Marshall Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge in south-central Palm Beach County. The subcommittee also warned that future federal spending on an $8.4 billion Everglades restoration project will depend on Florida meeting its promises to finish the cleanup first. Congress promised three years ago to pay for half of the restoration. As a start, the panel said it will halt spending on a separate water project in Everglades National Park unless four federal agencies tell Congress every six months that the state is cleaning the runoff that flows into the park and the refuge. Stopping that project would halt crucial parts of the $8.4 billion restoration.  Read more

Panel imposes Glades oversight
Under U.S. Rep. Young's plan, federal restoration money will be tied to certification by four agencies that Florida's doing its part.
By Craig Pittman and Bill Adair
©
St. Petersburg Times
WASHINGTON - Although the Florida Legislature delayed the deadline for cleaning up the Everglades, U.S. Rep. C.W. Bill Young is using the power of the purse to hold the state to its original commitment. Before any more federal money is spent restoring the River of Grass, the leaders of four federal agencies must certify that the state is really cleaning up the pollution, a subcommittee Young oversees decided Wednesday. Young, R-Largo, chairman of the powerful House Appropriations Committee, said he had the panel attach those strings to the $68-million appropriation because some lawmakers were concerned the state might break its promise to clean up the Everglades. "The members of the subcommittee were a little put out by the Legislature doing what we consider breaking the agreement," Young said. "We are very much concerned about the quality of water." Similar strings will be attached to a $120-million Everglades appropriation slated for a vote in July, Young said. Under Young's plan, the heads of the Environmental Protection Agency, Department of the Interior, Army Corps of Engineers and Justice Department will be required to review the state's progress on cleaning up the Everglades.  Read more

Glades money comes with a catch
Panel: State must follow earlier law
By Curtis Morgan
© The Miami Herald
A powerful congressional committee on Wednesday set aside $68 million for Everglades restoration but with a significant catch: The state will have to stick to an earlier pollution cleanup law, not a controversial revision, to cash the whole check. The move comes after repeated warnings from leaders in Congress about a new Florida law backed by the sugar industry, which critics contend could weaken a plan to sharply reduce tainted runoff from farms and suburbs. ''What we're doing is putting a string on the money. That's the only
responsible thing to do,'' U.S. Rep. Ralph Regula, an Ohio Republican, said. ``We just want to make sure that they'll live by the original agreement because obviously they've changed their mind.'' The action, taken by a House subcommittee working on an appropriations bill
for the U.S. Interior Department, is a long way from becoming law but at the very least it intensifies the political sparring between Florida and Congress over the nettlesome issue of ensuring the massive $8 billion Everglades restoration effort isn't undermined by dirty water flowing into the system. 
Read more

State touts filtering system
Stormwater areas used to reduce phosphorous ratio
By Pamela Smith Hayford
© News-Press


Stormwater Treatment Area 3/4 is under construction in the Everglades
Agricultural Area and will be the largest constructed wetland in the 
world, with nearly 16,500 acres. - AMANDA INSCORE/news-press.com

The state is showing off its latest "green" technology for filtering damaging amounts of phosphorus from water destined for the Everglades - this in the wake of controversy over Everglades cleanup deadlines. The South Florida Water Management District's plan to use this technology may also reduce harmful flushes to the Caloosahatchee River. PSTA, pronounced pasta, may sound more like it should be under meatballs and sauce instead of water, but scientists swear by the periphyton-based Stormwater Treatment Areas. Periphyton is a spongy mat of algae and other microorganisms that absorb phosphorus.
The district's small man-made marshes with periphyton have proven effective and lowered phosphorus levels to 10 parts per billion, the limit proposed by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Five-acre field tests have been slightly less effective for the district,
lowering phosphorus to 10 to 15 ppb. These experiments have been ongoing for a few years, but now the state has the money to create a much larger PSTA, which the district said costs
$31,000 an acre, in one of six stormwater treatment areas at the head of the Everglades thanks to the same legislation that environmentalists said delays cleanup. The legislation includes $650 million over the next 13 years for advanced water treatment tools like PSTA.
Read more

Fitch Affirms Port of Palm Beach Dist, FL Improvement Revenues 'A-'
By Corey S. Modeste, Fitch Ratings
© Business Wire
NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 19, 2003--Fitch Ratings affirms the 'A-' rating on approximately $50.6 million Port of Palm Beach District, FL (the Port or the District) revenue improvement bonds. The Rating Outlook is Stable. Fitch initially assigned the rating to the Port's series 1999 bonds. The bonds are secured by a pledge of gross port operating revenues. The series 1999 bonds have a final maturity in 2024 and were underwritten by a syndicate led Raymond James & Associates. Other banks in the syndicate include Mesirow Financial, Inc. and LM Capital Securities, Inc. The 'A-' rating reflects the District's consistent operating performance, overall positive cargo and cruise passenger trends and moderate debt load. Total 2002 District operating revenue was $12 million, with $6.2 million in operating expenses. Operating margins at the District have averaged 50% each year since 1998, and 2002 debt service coverage on the District's total outstanding bonds was 1.3 times (x). Debt service is level at $4.3 million. Though debt service coverage has declined in recent years as series 1999 debt service came on line, debt coverage remains above the District's 1.25x rate covenant.  Read more

Colony of 11 Endangered Bats Found in Fort Myers Area
Associated Press
© Tampa Tribune
FORT MYERS, Fla. (AP) - The largest recorded colony of endangered Wagner's mastiff bats has set up home in a suburb of this southwest Florida city, a bat conservation group said Friday. Eleven of the bats were found in a special bat house designed by the Organization for Bat Conservation, the Bloomfield Hills, Mich.-based group said. The previous largest recorded colony of the Wagner's mastiff, also known as the Florida mastiff, was eight, recorded in 1983. The bat has a wingspan of up to 21 inches, the largest of Florida's 19 species of bats, and is listed as endangered by the Florida Fish and Wildlife Commission.  Read more

Related Links:
Eumops glaucinus (Wagner's Mastiff Bat)
http:
//animaldiversity.ummz.umich.edu/accounts/eumops/e._glaucinus$narrative.html
http://www.floridabats.org/Wagners.HTM
http://fwie.fw.vt.edu/WCS/BATS/050970.HTM

Caloosahatchee Reservoir to take 20,000 acres
By Tracy Whirls
© Newszap
Corps of Engineers will acquire the projected 170,000 acres of land needed for the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project remains to be answered, officials from Glades and Hendry County got a preview of what sites are being looked at for one portion of the project. C-43 Basin Storage Reservoir Project Manager Agnes Ramsey told those
attending the joint meeting held in Clewiston June 2 that the C-43 basin storage reservoir is expected to take up 20,000 acres in Hendry, Glades or Lee Counties, intended to store 160,000 acre feet of water at a depth of up to eight feet. The purpose of the project is to capture C-43 Basin runoff and water released from Lake Okeechobee, reducing the loss of water released to the Caloosahatchee from the Lake during high lake levels, protecting the
Caloosahatchee Estuary, as well as preserving fresh water to supply to the estuary during drought. The reservoir will provide additional water supply, some additional flood prevention and will produce water quality benefits by reducing salinity and nutrient impacts of large quantities of runoff to the estuary. In determining where the C-43 basin reservoir storage areas will be constructed, Corps and SFWMD staff and others reviewed a total of 180,874
acres in Lee, Hendry and Glades Counties. Some of those sites, Ms. Ramsey said, will likely be rejected because they failed to "make it out of the gate," due to the potential of their locations as significant habit for threatened and endangered species, significant wetlands, avoiding cultural
resources and avoiding safety problems. 
Read more

 

18-June-03

EPA candidate under fire
By Robert P. King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
David Struhs: polluters' pal or overzealous enforcer? To the Sierra Club, Gov. Jeb Bush's environmental secretary is a former energy industry consultant who weakened the Everglades cleanup and tried to sell South Florida's water supply to Enron. To property rights activists, Struhs is a bureaucrat from Boston who championed air pollution limits in the Northeast and favors expanding the power of the federal government. The criticism from both sides of the eco-political spectrum comes as the White House seeks a replacement for Christie Whitman, the departing administrator of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Struhs -- with a long environmental résumé, a nimble grasp of policy and a brother-in-law who is President Bush's chief of staff -- was once a top candidate for the post, according to published news reports. But The New York Times and the environmental news service Greenwire have reported that Struhs is no longer among the front-runners, who include such
anti-regulation stalwarts as Idaho Gov. Dirk Kempthorne. Environmentalists say they believe Struhs' credibility as a candidate suffered because of his support for a new state law that postpones the final deadlines for cleaning the Everglades. The law also annoyed congressmen from both parties, which could lead to sharp questioning in confirmation hearings before the U.S. Senate. Environmental and sugar industry lobbyists say Struhs took part in early discussions of the Everglades legislation in March, although he has said he
didn't see it until April. Struhs later championed a revised version that he said would strengthen the $1 billion cleanup. 
Read more

Cranes Prepare For Migratory Whoopla
By Jim Tunstall
© Tamba Tribune
CHASSAHOWITZKA - The whooping crane Class of 2003 is starting to assemble in
Wisconsin.
Ten of the 18 endangered cranes chosen for this fall's migration are expected to begin flight school this weekend at Necedah National Wildlife Refuge, Heather Ray, a spokeswoman for Operation Migration, said this week. The cranes are hatched from eggs in a Maryland breeding center. They learn to identify an ultralight, equipped to make sounds like a crane, as a surrogate mother. They follow the aircraft, and the first place they see from the air is their summer home, she said. To minimize exposure to humans, their trainers dress in hooded gowns that to cranes make them look like other cranes. The 10 birds will be joined by eight from Maryland this month or early July. If all goes as planned, the flock and aircraft will begin the more than 1,200-mile journey to their winter home at Chassahowitzka National Wildlife Refuge in western Hernando and Citrus counties in early October. Ray and other wildlife officials hope the 21 surviving cranes from the first two migration experiments will return to Florida on their own. The five remaining cranes from the Class of 2001 came south last fall and returned north this spring. Sixteen from the Class of 2002 also returned to Wisconsin in the fall. The goal is to have 25 migrating breeding pairs east of the Mississippi
River by 2025. 
Read more

 

17-June-03

Pollution-reduction warriors battle on in Everglades
By Maya Bell, Miami Bureau
© Orlando Sentinel

 
© Maya Bell, Orlando Sentinel 2003.  Click on the map
thumbnail to view full-sized image.


CLEWISTON -- Standing in a sugar-cane field, Mitch Murphy watches a backhoe scoop up rich black muck from a ditch and deposit it on the bank, where it will be reused. About 30 miles east, Tracey Piccone stands on a bridge near the Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge, marveling as 24,000 gallons of water a second rush under her feet into one of the largest man-made wetlands in the world. Murphy and Piccone are foot soldiers in the battle to stop phosphorus from destroying the Everglades, and even as a firestorm rages over amendments to the law mandating cleanup of the fabled River of Grass, they remain proud of their court-ordered accomplishments. And for good reason: They're paying off. For Murphy, it's tedious work, but the maintenance supervisor with the U.S. Sugar Corp. is doing his part to keep even more pollution out of the Everglades and keep his paycheck coming. "I'm in farming, but I'm also an avid hunter and fisherman, and I want to clean up the water as much as I want to protect my livelihood," the lifelong Clewiston resident said. Piccone, an environmental engineer with the South Florida Water Management District, is equally proud to know that the wetlands -- or stormwater-treatment areas -- like the one constructed near the refuge are absorbing more harmful phosphorus than expected from waters draining from farms, urban lawns and Lake Okeechobee. "That's why all the people throwing stones at us is so hurtful," the fifth-generation Floridian said. "They know what we've done."  Read more

Letter to the editor- Lawmakers rub our noses in sugar
By David A. Schwartz, Boca Raton
© Sun-Sentinel
It's bad enough that the state government of Florida is bought and paid for by the sugar industry, but do they have to rub our noses in it by mailing fliers that proclaim themselves champions of the environment? Can I expect the same from the oil and coal industries? I guess I can expect to be enlightened about the environmental benefits of drilling in the Gulf of Mexico. Perhaps a treatise about how deficits are now good and surpluses are bad? If a bill that the public consistently polled in the 80 percent range against can be passed without even an attempt to hide who the Legislature works for (and passes off $400 million to taxpayers instead of Big Sugar), please have the decency to do it in the middle of the night in a smoke-filled room.  Read more

Rain, Land Acquisition Slow Kissimmee River Restoration
By Nancy Vickers-Pyle
© Tampa Tribune
CORNWELL - Restoration of a river scarred by man can be as slow as a long summer day. It has been more than a decade since the state and federal governments agreed to restore the original, twisting course of the Kissimmee River - a course that drove steamboat captains crazy a century ago. Though slowed by heavy rains and land acquisition, the nearly $600 million project is making progress on the Kissimmee, and the completed first phase is showing signs of success. Environmentalists say the near arrow-straight canal that replaced the natural river channel decades ago did a terrific job of draining wetlands and opening flood plains to agriculture and development. But those same wetlands helped filter out pollution that made its way into Lake Okeechobee and the Everglades. On a recent morning construction crews had to repair damage caused by downpours that hampered the building of a bridge over the Kissimmee River flood plain at U.S. 98 in Cornwell, a community east of Lorida. The bridge is part of the second phase of restoring the Kissimmee, which flows from Lake Kissimmee to Lake Okeechobee. The first phase restored the river from about U.S. 98 to Bluff Hammock Road, a stretch connecting Highlands and Okeechobee counties. The lead scientist for the project, Lou Toth, said crews are rebuilding the bridge and installing culverts so wetlands can be created along the river. ``Ultimately the culverts and the bridge will allow a sheet flow of water under the bridge and the road when that section of the river is restored,''
he said. 
Read more

Wildlife corridor funding lined up
The Martin County water manager has submitted a grant application for 50 percent of the cost of the first 1,200 acres of the corridor
By Suzanne Wentley
© Stuart News
Martin County planners are working to preserve almost 3,000 acres of pasture land that is the missing link for a continuous wildlife corridor in southern Martin County from the Atlantic Ocean to Lake Okeechobee. The property, which is known as Pal-Mar East because it is between Jonathan Dickinson State Park and the Pal-Mar preserve, would also be necessary for preliminary plans to divert stormwater from the St. Lucie Canal into the freshwater-starved Loxahatchee River. "It will be a multi-beneficial project," said Kim Love, Martin County's water resource manager. "We'll be able to restore wetlands and maybe use it for water management purposes." This week, Love submitted a grant application to the Florida Communities Trust for 50 percent of the cost of the first 1,200 acres of the property. County planners will find out at the end of summer whether they receive the grant funding. The land is valued at $8.6 million, of which the state would pay $4.3 million. Martin County would chip in $2.15 million in a 1 percent sales tax and the South Florida Water Management District would pay the rest, Love said.  Read more

 

16-June-03

Manatees' Voices Could Trigger Warnings For Dangerous Boats
By Jim Tunstall
© Tampa Tribune
HOMOSASSA SPRINGS - Researchers hope the voices of manatees can help them develop a visual warning system that one day will reduce the number of sea cows killed and injured by boat collisions. They say the experiment is prompted by the soaring number of boat-related deaths, which reached a record 95 last year. ``We thought if we could pick up the sounds of manatees, we could warn boaters of their presence,'' said Deke Beusse, a University of Florida veterinarian who heads the Marine Mammal Medicine Program. Beusse, assistant engineering Professor Chris Niezrecki and some graduate students used hydrophones earlier this year to record manatees at Homosassa Springs State Wildlife Park in Citrus County. ``When we played it back, they started vocalizing more - three times as much as normal - and approached the speakers,'' Beusse said. Beusse's team hopes that in the wild, speakers can be placed in channels, where they would prompt and intensify manatee vocalizations.  Read more

$243 million in land purchases
By Tracy Whirls
© Newszap
Hendry and Glades County officials got a preview June 2 of what the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Program may mean for the area. With 80,000 acres of the estimated 140,000 acres to be acquired by the South Florida Water Management District and US Army Corps of Engineers in hand, the primarily agricultural communities around the lake are looking at losing 60,000 acres of productive ag land to water storage projects. Much of the land which will be purchased under the CERP program is likely to be located in Hendry and Glades Counties. "There's very limited land available on the lower east coast," U.S. Army
Corps of Engineers Program Manager for Ecosystem Restoration Dennis Duke told those attending a joint county meeting with South Florida Water Management and Corps of Engineers representatives June 2, specifically concerning the proposed C-43 Basin Storage Reservoir and other CERP projects. Much of that land is expected to be purchased within the next three to eight years. Unlike many federal projects, the CERP project calls for the land
acquisitions to be made early in the process, Mr. Duke said, "before it can be bought up for other uses." 
Read more

State lawmakers shirked responsibility to enforce Polluters Pay
Editorial
© Key West Citizen
It's been seven years since Floridians -- 68 percent of them -- voted for a constitutional amendment that requires Everglades polluters to pay for the cleanup of the "River of Grass." 
Since then, environmentalist Mary Barley has filed a class action suit that has been heard by the Florida Supreme Court. Barley demands that the state carry out the wishes of the state's voters when they passed the Polluters Pay Amendment. The constitutional amendment says that those responsible for elevated levels of phosphorus -- such as sugar growers who use it in fertilizer -- should pay to restore the Everglades to its natural level of phosphorus. Despite the clear message from Florida voters, Florida's taxpayers, and not corporate polluters, continue to bear the bulk of the cleanup costs. South Florida Water Management District collects a tax from 6 million property owners in 15 counties that equals more than three times the amount collected from the agriculture industry, which pays just $24.89 per acre.
Read more

 

15-June-03

Lake Okeechobee water releases have far-ranging effect on ecosystems
By Chad Gillis
© Naples News
Summer rains typically mean one thing for the Caloosahatchee River estuary and other nearby bays: freshwater pulse released from Lake Okeechobee. This year is no different. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the South Florida Water Management District were expected to finish a release to the river Saturday, and start a second release today. Under level one, the releases consist of rates of 1,000 cubic feet per second on the first day, 2,800 cubic feet per second on day two, 3,300 cubic feet per second on day three and then taper off to 500 cubic feet per second on days nine and 10. The releases can have profound effects on nearby estuaries, which require a brackish mixture of fresh and saltwater in order to maintain the critical marine habitats. And while water from the lake is sent through the
Caloosahatchee on the west coast, scientific studies suggest that the freshwater from the lake eventually reaches water bodies as far away as Estero Bay. "It's very clear the there's been a definite change in clarity in the river in the last week," said Jim Beever, chairman of the Estero Bay Agency on Bay Management, of the Caloosahatchee. "And that affects seagrass beds." Beever gave a presentation in front of ABM members on Monday that showed how waters as far south as Bonita Springs can be impacted by the releases.
Read more

Bay's visionary
Ex-Senator's Dream of Restoration 30 Years Ago Still Unrealized
By Anita Huslin, Staff Writer
© Washington Post
When he stepped ashore at the Annapolis City Dock on a hot summer day 30 years ago, Charles McC. "Mac" Mathias looked and sounded more like a khaki-clad naturalist than a U.S. senator from Maryland. Just returning from a five-day expedition around the Chesapeake Bay, Mathias had seen for himself the fading plenitude of the world's richest estuary. He
had a vision, however, to restore its muddy, polluted waters and return the bay's fish, crabs and oysters to abundances not seen in more than 300 years. As he stood on the dock with a map of the Chesapeake as a prop, Mathias explained to a small gathering of reporters his ambitious plan: a three-year, $15 million examination of the bay. He could not have imagined that it would grow into the most studied and complex environmental restoration project in history, with a vaunted voluntary effort by the neighboring states and with a price tag that
eventually would exceed the $15 billion cost of the Florida Everglades project. Nor could he have foreseen how far the effort would be falling short 30 years later. 
Read more

FIU scientist offers 'Glades pollution solution
By Neil Santaniello, Staff Writer
© Sun-Sentinel
The water Ron Jones peers into is inches deep, and below it, he'll swear, grows the final answer in the contentious battle over how to clean up the Everglades. It happens to carpet the bottom of a 10-foot-by-100-foot concrete trough, a golden brown and solidly woven mat that the Florida International University microbiologist has been perfecting and testing for months at an outdoor laboratory west of Wellington. No biotech wonder here, just your typical been-around-for-ages Everglades-type pond scum. "It's actually quite beautiful under a microscope. It's really quite neat," said Jones, a slim, animated scientist who can talk on end, and with religious fervor, about the pancake-thick pond scum and its prospects for
saving the Everglades from phosphorus pollution. Technically, the scum is a combination of algae and other microorganisms called periphyton. It grows beautifully in shallow water, over a bed of limerock, the Everglades' natural stony foundation. In months of experiments underwritten by the Army Corps of Engineers, Jones has harnessed this combination of lowly algae and limerock to impressively purge stormwater of phosphorus, the fertilizer ingredient changing the mix of Everglades plants and making the marsh less wildlife-friendly. His $2 million project at a fenced-in compound next to Flying Cow Road, just south of Southern Boulevard, has knocked phosphorus concentrations of 65 to 70 parts per billion down to 10 or below -- the Everglades water quality goal endorsed by state environmental officials and Florida's environmental groups. 
Read more

Save Everglades library
Editorial
© Palm Beach Post
Some things everybody likes. Clean water and open libraries are on the list. So if there is a way for the South Florida Water Management District to wade out of its recent decision to restrict and possibly disperse its library of documents related to the Everglades, the district should wade as fast as it can. First, the district acknowledged that, to save money, it might dismantle its unique collection of maps, reports, studies and observations collected since
1949. The district's retiring reference librarian said of the 50,000 documents, "I don't think they're being treated with respect." In practice, the collection, once used by Marjory Stoneman Douglas, had been open to anyone. But just after The Post reported about the possible transfer of documents, the district started requiring visitors to be accompanied by a
district escort. The district says that always was the policy and that the material still will be available. But the clear impression is that district officials don't want to make it easy for the public to study documents that critics might use to challenge current policies that many suspect are hurting the Everglades and connected wetlands and waterways. 
Read more

County, state join on land policy
Corridors of land between tracts that are already protected from development are in line to receive their own new safeguards
By Dan DeWitt, Times Staff Writer
© St. Petersburg Times
The Citrus and Croom tracts of the Withlacoochee State Forest are among the area's most secure hedges against development pressing north from Tampa Bay. The gap between them, though, is mostly farms, some of it in the large parcels most attractive to builders of shopping centers and subdivisions. Now, local governments are working with the state on a plan that might protect those vulnerable open spaces and create a bridge between the larger
tracts of preserved land. "We want to work with Hernando and possibly Citrus County on a cooperative project to close some of these gaps," said Tom Hoctor, a University of Florida researcher who has worked on a state project to identify the most environmentally sensitive of these connections in the state. On the local level, the work started about a year ago, when Hernando decided to scrap its old approach to acquiring natural lands and adopt a new one.
Instead of using its limited funds to buy small parcels around the county, the Environmentally Sensitive Lands Committee focused on setting aside 2,700
acres stretching from the Citrus Tract of the Withlacoochee State Forest, which are in turn joined to the Croom tract. The idea was based on a well-established principal - that buying land to connect larger parcels is more beneficial to wildlife than isolated parcels. The County Commission approved the plan a month ago. 
Read more

When have waterways had enough?
By Steven D. Barnes, Sentinel Correspondent
© Orlando Sentinel


© Steven D. Barnes, Orlando Sentinel 2003


SANFORD -- Rapidly growing cities, poor farming practices and inadequate pollution controls have despoiled hundreds of Florida waterways. But how much is too much? How much pollution can a body of water absorb before it no longer functions the way nature intended?
The Florida Department of Environmental Protection is trying to answer those
precious natural resources. For the past 18 months, the agency has been systematically evaluating
Florida's waterways to determine which should be listed as "impaired" -- a first step in a multiyear process that could trigger big changes in the way farms, businesses and government handle the pollutants that find their way into local waters. The process uses scientific methods to set limits on a range of pollutants and to establish benchmarks for dissolved oxygen levels. The agency recently released a draft list of Central Florida waters it
thinks are so polluted that they may be unfit, or on the verge of being unfit, for swimming, fishing or other uses. 
Read more

 

14-June-03

The deep well problem
Editorial
© Palm Beach Post
There are no perfect solutions for disposing of treated sewage in Florida, but both federal and state agencies should require better treatment of wastewater before it further endangers both people and the fragile coastal reefs. Dumping treated sewage into the ocean can be dangerous because microorganisms that cause disease can infect swimmers or contaminate fish. Wastewater also is dumped into wetlands to recharge the surficial aquifer, another questionable disposal method. The other "solution" for disposing of treated wastewater has been to pump it deep underground -- an estimated 500 million gallons a day in 120 wells
throughout the state. But evidence is mounting that the trillions of gallons dumped deep into the Earth over the past decades are surfacing. Ammonia is showing up at the edges of at least 20 of the state's drinking-water supplies, including a well Seacoast Utilities Authority owns in Palm Beach Gardens. Nutrients from treated wastewater are seeping onto Florida's coastal reefs, including those off Palm Beach County, possibly feeding algae that chokes the reefs and covers the ocean floor. On the Treasure Coast, the "green tide" of invasive seaweed is advancing into the Intracoastal Waterway. 
Read more

 

13-June-03

Bad attempt by Sugar
Editorial
© Orlando Sentinel
Our position: The court was right to turn down the sugar industry's attempt to derail judge. A federal appeals court this week properly rejected transparent attempts by the sugar industry to influence judicial oversight of Everglades restoration efforts. One sensible ruling down. One to go. Senior U.S. District Court Judge William Hoeveler has presided over Everglades restoration for 15 years. And there's no reason to replace him, as the sugar industry now wants. He is a respected, indeed revered, arbiter in judicial circles -- unimpressed by sugar-backed efforts to delay restoration of the Everglades another 10 years.  Read more

It's not an open book
By Bob King
© Palm Beach Post
You don't need a library card, but you need a specific reason and an escort to browse the stacks at the South Florida Water Management District. Spokesman Randy Smith said that's long been the policy, aimed at protecting rare documents. But retiring librarian Cynthia Plockelman called it a change from four decades of open-door policies, a shift that emerged Wednesday after the Palm Beach Post printed an article on the library's possible closing.   "Anybody has been able to walk into the reference center anytime they wanted," she said. A memo Wednesday, reminded Plockelman that only employees and contractors can use the library in suburban West Palm Beach, and anyone else must submit a records request.

EPA and Florida Continue with Water Restoration Plan
Federal agency concurs with state's impaired waters list
By Deena Wells, DEP, and Carl Terry, EPA
© Florida Department of Enviromental Protection
TALLAHASSEE: The Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced today another milestone in restoring water quality in Florida's rivers and lakes. EPA and Florida agreed on the waterbodies that are identified as impaired as well as those that require further evaluation. Florida is working with federal and local governments, water management districts, public and private utilities,
industry, agriculture and environmental groups to clean up pollution in state waters. 
Read more

The Case Against Dave Struhs
Sierra Club Special Report
© Florida Sierra Club
When Department of Environmental Protection Secretary David Struhs was hired by Governor Jeb Bush, Struhs had agency letterhead etched with his personal slogan, “More Protection, Less Process.” But four years later, it is plain that Floridians have “less protection
and no process,” under the administration of David Struhs. Volunteer activists, professional staffers and former Department of Environmental Protection agency staff are telling the same story: David Struhs is not protecting Florida’s environment. “Less process” means the
diminishment of public participation and the expansion of backroom deal making, of privatization as a way to reward friends and campaign supporters of Jeb Bush. Dozens of documents, news accounts, and interviews show that David Struhs, a former utility consultant, has shown a pattern of deception and manipulation to the public, the press, and to federal and state lawmakers. 
Read more
          Related Link:     PDF Report (4 pages)- http://florida.sierraclub.org/ex13laj55.pdf

Lee, Collier now under year-round water restrictions
By Chad Gillis
© Naples News
The southwest coast became the first region in south Florida to be placed on year-round irrigation restrictions Thursday when the state's water management district officially adopted a water conservation rule aimed at Lee, Collier and the southern tip of Charlotte counties. Property owners will be allowed to water lawns and landscaping three days a week from 4 p.m. to 10 a.m. the following morning with no watering allowed on Friday. Addresses that end in even numbers can irrigate only on a Tuesday, Thursday and Sunday rotation while even addresses will be allowed to water on Monday, Wednesday and Saturday. Golf courses and
sports playing fields are exempt from the restrictions. "It's in effect, but it really shouldn't change anyone's life right now," said South Florida Water Management District spokesman Kurt Harclerode. "No one should need to irrigate now that we're in the rainy season. The timed sensors should probably be shut off." 
Read more

Bush: I won't fire environmental chief
By Lesley Clark
© The Miami Herald
TALLAHASSEE - Florida conservationists Thursday called on Gov. Jeb Bush to jettison his environmental chief, accusing David Struhs of cozying up to big business, rewarding his friends and selling out the Everglades to Big Sugar. But Bush said he's not about to can the Department of Environmental Protection secretary, one of the few holdovers from Bush's first term. ''No, hell no!'' Bush told reporters Thursday morning, according to The Associated Press. Struhs had been considered a front-runner to replace outgoing Christie Todd Whitman at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, but the New York Times reported Thursday that Struhs' environmental record in Massachusetts -- his posting before Florida -- has been questioned by conservatives and he's no longer on the short list. A spokeswoman for the vacationing Struhs said the secretary believes ''he has the best environmental job in Florida'' and plans to stay as long as the governor wants him."  Read more

Coalition wants DEP chief fired
The environmental groups say Secretary David Struhs is too friendly with industry
By Julie Hauserman, Times Staff Writer
© St. Petersburg Times
TALLAHASSEE - A coalition of environmental groups on Thursday called on Gov. Jeb Bush to fire David Struhs, his Department of Environmental Protection secretary, saying Struhs has been too cozy with polluters. "No. Hell no," Bush said when asked whether Struhs should go. The environmental groups, which include the Florida Chapter of the Sierra Club, the Florida League of Conservation Voters, the Friends of the Everglades, the Clean Water Network, and 11 others, cited several instances in which they say Struhs has favored industry over the environment. Among the groups' concerns was a controversial 1999 settlement Struhs engineered dealing with pollution from Tampa Electric Co. Federal
regulators said Florida's deal didn't do enough to safeguard public health. Struhs' deal also specified that TECO try a technology marketed by a friend of Struhs - whom he later hired at DEP. TECO opted not to use the technology, but environmentalists said it was a sweetheart deal designed to enrich a friend of the DEP secretary. 
Read more

DEP Secretary's Reaction to Everglades Bill
© Florida Government Headlines
Tallahassee - The Department today joins Florida's environmental advocacycommunity in applauding Gover-nor Bush's signing of a bill that will makeup to $800 million of funding available to restore America's Everglades. The Governor's commitment to ensuring that Florida continues to pay its half of the project costs has been critical to maintaining an equivalent share of federal funding. Today's action by the Governor continues this pattern. We would have preferred the Governor’s original funding proposal which would have put $250 million in cash directly into the Everglades Restoration Trust Fund and provided additional bonding authority. However, given budget constraints and other legislative priorities, we wel-come this alternative which will also allow Florida to fully meet its Everglades funding commitment.  Read more

Corps official affirms commitment to Everglades restoration
Earlier this week, the DEP issued a press release outlining the state's continuing commitment to the $8.4 million restoration.
By Alan Scher Zagier
© Naples Daily News
Some soldiers on the front lines of Everglades restoration traveled to Naples on Thursday to offer their assurances that, despite a new state law rolling back phosphorous cleanup deadlines, the commitment remains steadfast to a cleaner River of Grass. Speaking at the annual meeting of the Florida Association for Water Quality Control, held at The Registry Resort, the federal government's point man for Everglades restoration said he's not worried about a decline in state oversight. "There has been no backing off on the part of the state" regarding water quality standards, said Dennis Duke, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers'
program manager for Everglades restoration. Duke was joined by Ernie Barnett, director of ecosystem projects for the Florida Department of Environmental Protection; Barbara Miedema, a spokeswoman for the Sugar Cane Growers Cooperative of Florida; and April
Gromnicki, Everglades policy coordinator for Florida Audubon. Barnett said the amount of phosphorous entering the Everglades has decreased from 270 metric tons in 1990 to current levels of 80 metric tons, with a further reduction to 30 metric tons anticipated by 2006. "We've ended up far exceeding the first phase of water quality restoration," he told an audience of 30 engineers and hydrologists. A sugar industry-driven bill signed into law recently by Gov. Jeb Bush gives the state and agricultural interests more wiggle room to meet rigorous emission standards first established as part of a federal-state consent agreement following a 1988 lawsuit brought by the federal Department of Justice against Florida. The agreement calls for a reduction of phosphorus in the Everglades to 10
parts per billion by 2006. Too much phosphorus, used in agriculture as fertilizer, has changed parts of the River of Grass into dense fields of cattails that choke water flow. The new law extends that deadline to 2016; a clause offering the option of extending the deadline to "the earliest practicable date" was later eliminated. The law also has wording that makes the water quality standards less rigid, requiring the water essentially to be made as clean
as is technically possible. 
Read more

Groups rip environmental chief
By Rafael Lorente and Linda Kleindienst, Washington Bureau
© Orlando Sentinel
WASHINGTON -- Florida's top environmental regulator, mentioned as a possibility to head the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, is coming under increasing attack on his home turf for not protecting the state's natural resources. David Struhs, secretary of Florida's Department of Environmental Protection, has been named as a potential replacement for Christie Whitman, who resigned as EPA administrator last month. However, he is now the target of a "Dump Struhs" campaign by a host of Florida environmental organizations, including the Sierra Club, the Everglades Trust, the Clean Water Network and the Florida League of Conservation Voters. His role in a recent revision of the Everglades Forever Act, which could stall a cleanup plan for the River of Grass, already has drawn staunch criticism from Congress, likely making him vulnerable in required confirmation hearings before the U.S. Senate. With Democrats on Capitol Hill looking for ways to attack what seems to be a Teflon-coated president, whoever the nominee is could be in for a long, bumpy ride. Struhs already has come under attack by Republican congressional leaders unhappy with his handling of the Everglades bill approved by the Florida Legislature. "If he went to Washington, it would be good for Florida but bad for the EPA," said Mary Barley of the Everglades Trust. "We need to dump him because he's dumping on the state of Florida and our environment." Gov. Jeb Bush, who tapped Struhs for the DEP job in 1999, has been a staunch supporter of how Struhs has run the agency. Asked if he would consider firing his top environmental regulator, Bush replied: "No. Hell no."  Read more

Bush refuses to fire Struhs
Environmental coalition calls for removal of DEP secretary
By Bruce Ritchie, Staff Writer
© The Tallahassee Democrat
Gov. Jeb Bush used few words Thursday in response to a call to fire David Struhs, secretary of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. "No. Hell no - that's my comment," Bush told reporters. The Sierra Club's Florida chapter and a coalition of 16 other fire Struhs. They released a report that they said documents his deception and backroom deal-making. The coalition includes the Florida Consumer Action Network, the Florida League of Conservation Voters, the Clean Water Network and the Everglades Trust. The groups say Struhs has sacrificed Florida's environmental treasures, including the Everglades and the Ichetucknee River in North Florida. They also blame him for new rules that led last year to some waterways being dropped from the state's "impaired waters" cleanup list. Bush and Struhs recently supported a state bill to remove a 2006 deadline for the sugar industry to clean up Everglades pollution. And in 1999, DEP the Ichetucknee River. The Sierra Club said both issues were examples of deception and private deal-making. Struhs is on vacation this week and was not available for comment, DEP spokeswoman Deena Wells said earlier this week. She also said Struhs' critics were engaging in "personal attacks" and that the accusations against him were "ridiculous." Struhs was named DEP Secretary by Bush in 1999 after serving as chief of the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection. He has been rumored as a possible replacement for Environmental Protection Administrator Christine Todd Whitman, who is resigning.  Read more

Letter to the editor-  Help the 'Glades:  Stop buying sugar!
By Gayle Rogalski, Delray Beach
© Sun-Sentinel
Well, the sugar barons just have no limit to their blatant bully tactics when it comes to avoiding their responsibility in cleaning up their mess in the Everglades. It's not bad enough that they're pulling the strings on the puppet in the governor's mansion, but now they're threatening a respected judge whose goal is to save the Everglades from destruction they
are in large part responsible for. Those who are infuriated by these actions, as many of us are, do have a way of making our own statement to the sugar industry. All we have to do
is stop buying sugar. Not only would you be retaliating against the sugar barons, but you would be doing yourself a great service because sugar is very bad for your health. 
Read more

 

12-June-03

Pols want Jeb to put Everglades bill on hold
By Jasmine Kripalani
© The Miami Herald
Seven South Florida Democratic legislators stood on a patch of grass near the Everglades on Wednesday, and asked Gov. Jeb Bush to delay implementation of a new Everglades cleanup law. Leading Congressional Republicans, environmentalists and even a federal judge have been critical of the Everglades measure, which Bush signed into law in May. On Tuesday, Bush signed a second measure removing language environmentalists had found troubling. Still, the Democratic legislators called for Bush to reconsider the law, saying that it jeopardizes a federal-state agreement to split the cost of an $8 billion Everglades restoration project. Airboat motors revved in the background at Everglades Holiday Park off of U.S. 27 and Griffin Road, as the state senators and representatives warned that the river of grass behind them could one day turn into a wasteland. Efforts are underway to rid the Everglades of pollutants including phosphorous, which drains into the Everglades from urban areas, the sugar industry and other agriculture. ''Our state's most natural treasure is in peril,'' said Rep. Ron Greenstein, D-Coconut Creek who voted for the bill during the regular session. ''The reason I voted for it was a work plan to put in front of the judge. I thought the judge had the option of throwing it out,'' Greenstein said, referring to U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler, who is overseeing the Everglades cleanup.  Read more

Alvin B. Jackson, Jr. prepares message of opportunity for NAACP Conference
By William Graf
© Orlando Sentinel
Whether it's taking on a part of the $8 billion Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Palm winning a contact for work on the $500 million Kissimmee River Restoration, or work on local government water resource partnerships in Central and South Florida, the time has never been better for doing business with the South Florida Water Management District. With that message of opportunity, Alvin B. Jackson, Jr., is the keynote speaker at this year's "Women in the NAACT" Breakfast at the annual Florida State Conference of NAACP Branches to be held June 20-21 at Orlando's Rosen Plaza Hotel. With so much business to share with the private sector, Jackson is leading the way to ensure that women- and minority-owned businesses enjoy an unprecedented piece of that economic pie. "In 2002, I'm pleased to report, the South Florida Water Management District did $65 million in business with minority-owned businesses," Jackson said. "That's a 168-percent increase over the previous year. And we're on track for additional improvements this year." Likewise, the South Florida Water Management pursues a philosophy that a diverse work force strengthens its ability to serve the diverse communities of Central and South Florida. The District employs 1,771 people who work in the 16 counties of the greater Kissimmee -Okeechobee - Everglades watershed that begins in Orlando and stretches all the way to the Florida Keys.  Read more

Related Links:
Avlin B. Jackson, Jr.
Deputy Executive Director for Corporate Resources
South Florida Water Management District
http://www.sfwmd.gov/gover/3_jackson.html
National Association for the Advancement of Colored People
http://www.naacp.org
Florida NAACP Branches
http://www.naacp.org/locally/contact45.shtml#florida

7 legislators to Gov. Bush: Put Glades bill on hold
© The Miami Herald
Seven South Florida Democratic legislators stood on a patch of grass near the Everglades on Wednesday and asked Gov. Jeb Bush to delay implementation of a new Everglades cleanup law. Leading congressional Republicans, environmentalists and even a federal judge have been critical of the Everglades measure, which Bush signed into law in May. On Tuesday, Bush signed a second measure removing language that environmentalists had found troubling. Still, the Democratic legislators called for Bush to reconsider the law, saying that it jeopardizes a federal-state agreement to split the cost of an $8 billion Everglades restoration project.  Read more

 

11-June-03

Water district may close library
By Robert King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
South Florida's past may be running out of future. That's the fear of Cynthia Plockelman, who has spent 40 years assembling a one-of-a-kind archive of bird books, plant guides, pioneer lore and century-old game warden reports detailing the region's past as a watery wilderness. Marjory Stoneman Douglas, queen of the Everglades activists, browsed the documents in the 1970s. Scientists and scholars from as far away as South Africa rely on the collection today. It's open to anyone wishing to peruse the engineering plans, congressional reports and pump blueprints that helped create the realm of suburbs and shopping malls we dwell in now. But Plockelman retires this month as reference librarian at the South Florida Water Management District in suburban West Palm Beach. And to save money, the district is considering dismantling the library's collection of tens of thousands of documents -- perhaps sending much of it to Florida Atlantic University in Boca Raton. District leaders say they haven't made any decisions, but promise all the documents will be preserved and remain available to the public. But Plockelman is convinced the collection is in danger. "Once it's gone to Boca, it's totally out of our control," she said. "Things can be lost, stolen, not catalogued." "I care deeply about what happens to this material," she added. "This isn't my private property. These are the district's records, and I don't think they're being treated with respect."  
Read more

Judge to remain on Glades case
By Curtis Morgan
© The Miami Herald
A federal appeals court Tuesday threw out one of two legal efforts by the sugar industry to remove a Miami federal judge from his longtime role of overseeing Everglades cleanup. 
Sugar companies said Senior District Judge William Hoeveler had overstepped his bounds by publicly criticizing an Everglades cleanup bill passed by the Florida Legislature this year. The bill postponed the deadline for reducing Everglades pollution from sugar farm and urban runoff. On Tuesday, Gov. Jeb Bush signed the bill, which was tightened from an earlier version that Everglades activists and even some Republican congressmen thought was too lenient. Environmentalists hailed the appeals court's decision as a victory for Hoeveler, a venerable jurist they consider the last, best defense of tough pollution standards in the Everglades. ''The court obviously saw through their ruse and sent them packing,'' said
Thom Rumberger, an attorney for Audubon of Florida. But sugar growers stood by their cases, arguing the decision by the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta was based on a technicality. Another motion to remove the judge remains pending. ''They didn't rule on the merits of the case,'' said Jorge Dominicis, vice president of Florida Crystals, whose affiliate, New Hope Sugar Co., filed the petition last week in Atlanta. That petition, like a separate motion filed in District Court in Miami by the United State Sugar Corp., argued that Hoeveler had overstepped his judicial authority over the past few months by issuing criticisms of the sugar-supported legislative overhaul of Everglades pollution laws. 
Read more
Judge Hoeveler News Page

Democrats urge Bush to delay Everglades act
By Holly Hickman, Associated Press Writer
© Herald Tribune
Flanked by the vast river of grass they said they want to protect, several Democratic state legislators implored Gov. Jeb Bush on Wednesday to stop implementation of the recently signed Everglades Restoration Act. The legislators said the law threatens both the wetland itself and the $8 billion cleanup partnership with the federal government. They said some
Democrats voted for the bill last month only because they were duped by the Department of Environmental Protection. Agency officials denied the accusation and noted that measure passed by an "overwhelming majority" in the Legislature. "The title 'Everglades Restoration Act' is a misnomer given what we, the state of Florida, have just done," said Rep. Nan Rich, D-Weston. "We're not restoring. We're destroying a historic partnership. By signing this
act without their input, the governor has thumbed his nose at our federal partners." She pointed to a recent letter written to Bush by U.S. Rep. David Hobson, R-Ohio, [shown below] which urged the governor to create "a sense of confidence that the coalition of shared interests ... has not been irreversibly damaged." The letter also called on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to investigate whether Florida is meeting the specific environmental requirements outlined in previous state-federal agreements. Hobson spokesman Chris Galm said that the governor must prove that Florida "has not reneged on its commitment to the restoration" if the state is to receive the $4 billion federal grant earmarked for the mammoth
project. State Sen. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, D-Pembroke Pines, likened the current
state-federal relationship to a marriage. "If you don't want a divorce, you sit down and work it out," she said. "If you do want a divorce, you go down the road Jeb Bush is going down."
Read more

Letter from Terry Rice to Governor Bush
Press Release
Governor Bush ... I routinely comment to you on correspondence such as the below letter that you recently received from Congressman Hobson.... I normally take the time to logically evaluate and amplify the points made as I've done for you many time in the past ... but, after 4 years-plus of corresponding with you, I am convinced that I have confirmed one of your predictable characteristic ... when you have made up your mind, you rarely change it ... the fight appears to become winning regardless of new information, refuted facts, or whatever ... although most everyone recognizes that changing a decision for the right reasons is prudent, there seems to be an innate force in you that precludes this from happening. Some confuse this condition with decisiveness ... this is not decisiveness as changes of decision can be made decisively.  Read more

 

10-June-03

Bush signs bill he says will address Everglades concerns
The Herald Tribue/Associated Press
Gov. Jeb Bush signed a bill Tuesday intended to ease concerns of environmentalists and members of Congress about the state's commitment to cleaning up the Everglades. The bill, passed during a special session last month, was meant to tighten language in a measure he earlier signed into law earlier that critics said would delay by a decade or more the cleanup of phosphorus pollution running into Everglades National Park from sugar farms and suburban sprawl. "Florida's commitment to restoration of America's Everglades continues," Bush said in a release issued by the Department of Environmental Protection. "We have the plan and we're providing the money to make restoration a reality. We're keeping our promise to the famed River of Grass." Environmentalists said the original bill created wiggle room on a deadline for completing the restoration and the degree to which water in the Everglades had to be clean. The bill allowed for cleanup to be done at the "earliest practical date" and to the "maximum practical extent," rather than setting out a hard deadline. Congress also was watching the issue closely. It's paying half the $8 billion cleanup cost, and several members have warned that if the state's guarantee continued financial support.  Read more

Good Everglades news overlooked
Opinion, submitted by Governor Jeb Bush
© Sun-Sentinel
The South Florida Sun-Sentinel's May 29 article, "Everglades bill raises taxes, critics argue," proves that it is impossible to satisfy some people. Instead of celebrating the unprecedented progress and success of Everglades restoration, some will create a reason -- without regard to the truth -- to complain and criticize this monumental project. Meanwhile, the real news about Everglades restoration went virtually unreported last month. The Florida Legislature committed $225 million in cash -- more than twice the amount originally anticipated this year -- and another $800 million in bonding authority to keep Everglades restoration on schedule and on budget. Florida's total financial commitment to restore water flow now tops $1.5 billion. Florida is also keeping its commitment to restoring water quality. Since enactment of the 1994 Everglades Forever Act, more than $600 million has been invested in cleaning up the famed River of Grass. Today, 90 percent of the water in the Everglades is clean.  Read more

Letter to the editor- Polluters don't pay
By Rep. Ron Greenstein
© The Miami Herald
When voters approved a 1996 constitutional amendment requiring polluters to pay for the cost of cleaning up the Everglades, I am sure the last thing on their minds was the possibility that the Legislature would be billing them, rather than the sugar industry, for the cleanup.
Well, in the strange Republican world of Tallahassee, that is exactly what happened. Every Floridian feels a responsibility to restore the Everglades. As the father of an infant, it is my hope that my son will grow up to know and love an Everglades that is fully restored, and like every other resident of South Florida, I am willing to do my part. However, the polluters must do their part, too. That is why I proposed a minor increase in the fee that sugar farmers pay to grow crops near the Everglades. The fee increase would have been negligible, just $5 to $7 per acre, but it would have provided significant funding for the cleanup. 
Read more

FLORIDA LEGISLATORS TO GOVERNOR BUSH:  STOP IMPLEMENTATION OF EVERGLADES BILL TO DELAY IMPLEMENTATION OF EVERGLADES BILL
Press Advisory
FOR MORE INFORMATION, CONTACT:
Julia Lopes (Sen. Wasserman Schultz) (954) 704-2934
Dawn Vihrachoff (Rep. Greenstein) (954) 956-5600
WESTON, Fl---     Members of the Florida Legislature will hold a press conference on Wednesday to call on Governor Bush to issue a moratorium delaying the implementation of the recently signed Everglades Act. Florida Legislators are calling for the moratorium in response to a recent announcement that Congressman David Hobson (R-Ohio), Chair of the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Energy and Water Resources, will ask the Army Corps of Engineers to undertake a study to determine whether the recently passed legislation will “result in an abrogation of the cost-sharing agreement and end the Federal contribution for any such project features.” Congressman Hobson’s prouncement indicates the real possibility that Florida could lose some $4 billion in federal funding for Everglades restoration.  Read more

Record New Funding To Save the Everglades
Florida keeps money flowing into River of Grass
Florida Department of Environmental Protection Press Release
Contact: Deena Wells, (850) 528-2155
Tallahassee - Governor Jeb Bush today signed Senate Bill 54A that clarifies amendments made to the Everglades Forever Act during the Regular Session this year. The legislation also provides the bonding authority for an additional $800 million for Everglades Restoration. Including the record $225 million appropriated in this year's budget, Florida's total financial
commitment to restore water flow through the famed River of Grass now tops $1.5 billion.
"Florida's commitment to restoration of America's Everglades continues," said Governor Jeb Bush. "We have the plan and we're providing the money to make restoration a reality. We're keeping our promise to the famed River of Grass." The legislation signed today eliminates specific language within the amended Everglades Forever Act that has been a source of concern to Florida's federal partners. Since the law has been the subject of intense debate and scrutiny, Governor Bush asked the Legislature to clarify specific language in the bill. 
Read more

 

09-June-03

Bush policies harm the environment
By Bob Graham
© Boston Globe
THE NEXT MAJOR environmental showdown in America will be the nomination of a new EPA administrator. While this selection could be a strong signal of where the Bush administration is on environmental policy, the experience of the outgoing administrator is a perfect example of my skepticism when it comes to the ability of the Bush White House to make a commitment to real environmental protection. After 28 months as head of the Environmental Protection Agency, Christie Whitman called it quits on May 21. Known as a political moderate, Whitman's departure may have been the result of frustration after repeatedly losing out to big business, big coal, and big oil. Her tenure at the agency has been defined by environmental rollbacks announced at 5:30 on Friday. Finding her replacement will give the White House the opportunity to decide if it is committed to environmental protection or Friday night raids on the environment. Over the last two years, these environmental rollbacks have included allowing open access to snowmobiles in Yellowstone National Park, delaying needed action to reduce the impact of global warming, and undermining the cleanup of America's lakes, rivers, and estuaries. These rollbacks, combined with lack of action by EPA and other environmental agencies, threaten our national parks, our air, and our water. The administration's hostile environmental policies are undermining projects that have traditionally lacked partisan rancor. For example, the restoration of the Everglades, which became law with the  help of Democrats and Republicans, is threatened by lack of action on the part of the EPA and the Interior Department. In 2000, historic legislation paved the way for restoration and solidified a commitment between the state and federal government to restore the River of Grass.  Read more

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) today announced the release of its draft report on groundwater at the Stauffer Chemical site in Tarpon Springs, Florida
Press Release
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) today announced the release of its draft report on groundwater at the Stauffer Chemical site in Tarpon Springs, Florida. A copy of the report is available for public review at the Tarpon Springs Public Library, 138 East Lemon Street in Tarpon. [ Tarpon Springs Public Library - http://snoopy.tblc.lib.fl.us/tarpon/ ] The Groundwater Study was specifically focused on evaluating certain groundwater characteristics that are of concern to the community and may impact the future remedy. The objectives of the study included: determining ocean tides effect on groundwater flow; determining a connection between the surficial aquifer and the deeper Floridian aquifer; and evaluating groundwater movement beneath the site and  possible contaminant transport away from the site. EPA entered into an enforceable agreement with the Stauffer Management Company that required the company to conduct geophysical studies, evaluate the effect of groundwater on the remedy, and conduct treatability studies on the solidification portion of the remedy before the Agency makes a final decision regarding the remedy for the site.  Read more

Related Links:
Public health assessment of the Stauffer Chemical Co. site
http://cisat1.isciii.es/NEWS/tarponspringsfl040203.html
ATSDR - Stauffer Chemical Company Site - Tarpon Springs, Florida .
http://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/NEWS/staufferhealthresponse.html
EPA Region 4 Florida NPL/NPL Caliber Cleanup Site Summaries, ...
.... The Stauffer Chemical Company obtained the plant from Victor Chemical in 1960 and ... The 160-Acre site (130 acres dry) is situated along the Anclote River ...
http://www.epa.gov/region4/waste/npl/nplfln/stautsfl.htm
[PDF]STAUFFER CHEMICAL - TAMPA
http://www.dep.state.fl.us/waste/quick_topics/publications/wc/sites/summary/094.pdf
[PDF]Stauffer Chemical Company
http://response.restoration.noaa.gov/cpr/ wastesites/PDFs/StaufTS.pdf

 

08-June-03

Polluters not paying as much as taxpayers
By Travis James Tritten
© Key West Citizen


© SHERI LOHR / Special to The Citizen
Changes to the Everglades Forever Act mean Monroe County property owners will now 
pay $2 million or more annually for the next decade to clean up farm runoff.

Floridians felt so strongly that polluters -- not taxpayers -- should pay for a cleanup of the Everglades that 68 percent voted to add the rule to the state constitution in 1996. Seven years later, South Florida property owners are paying nearly three times more than the agricultural industry responsible for most of the phosphorous pollution that flows into the swamp. And changes to the Everglades Forever Act passed last month by the Legislature and signed by the governor extends the burden on taxpayers for another 10 years. Monroe County property owners will now pay $2 million or more annually for the next decade to clean up farm runoff. "Orlando to Key West would have had the tax dropped" in 2004, said Charles
Lee, senior vice president of Audubon of Florida. "The effect of this bill is to re-impose that tax on the homeowners, who have nothing to do with phosphorous pollution." Residents will pay about an extra $20 a year on a $250,000 home until 2014 under the new amendments to the Everglades Forever Act. In 2001, the cleanup tax raised $1.94 million from the Florida Keys, Tax Collector Danise Henriquez said. That amount will most likely increase over
the years due to soaring property values. About 6 million residents in 15 South Florida counties will be affected by the property tax extension, which is levied by the South Florida Water Management District.  

TIMELINE:

1994 -- The Florida Legislature passes the Everglades Forever Act, which 
requires phosphorous levels in the swamp to be reduced to natural levels. 
Property owners are taxed to pay for the cleanup.

1996 -- Sixty-eight percent of Floridians vote for a constitutional
amendment that requires polluters to pay for the Everglades cleanup, not
taxpayers. The agricultural industry is given tax breaks for decreased
phosphorous levels.

1997 -- The state Supreme Court rules that the amendment requires polluters
to pay "100 percent" of the cost for reducing pollution. Yet taxes collected
from non-polluters pay the majority for the first construction of wetland
treatment areas that cleanse farm runoff.

1998 -- A class action suit is filed by Mary Barley challenging the
constitutionality of taxing property owners for the cleanup.

2002 -- The Florida Supreme Court rules that the Polluter Pays amendment
must be clarified by the Legislature before taking effect.

2003 -- The Legislature renews the Everglades cleanup tax on property owners
for another decade.

Read more

80-yr-old jurist fights to preserve his Everglades legacy
By Catherine Wilson, Associated Press
© Naples News/AP


©  Wilfredo Lee, Associated Press 2003
District Judge William Hoeveler poses near an oil painting of the Everglades that hangs over 
his desk in his chambers in Miami. Best known as the federal judge who sent Manuel Noriega to 
prison, the 80-year-old jurist returned to the headlines this spring by saying a new Everglades 
law heralded by Gov. Jeb Bush was "clearly defective" even before it was signed.

MIAMI — The legacy of William Hoeveler may be 15 years spent policing a complex lawsuit mired in biology and hydrology that is intended to restore the Everglades to its bygone days as a free-flowing, slow-growth marsh. But sugar growers say that is long enough. Claiming the federal judge has turned into a bully with a political bent, they are asking other judges to throw him off the case. Best known as the federal judge who sent Panamanian dictator Manuel Noriega to prison, the 80-year-old jurist returned to the headlines this spring by saying a new Everglades law heralded by Gov. Jeb Bush was "clearly defective" even before it was signed. Stiffened by a stroke and back trouble but still ramrod straight in person and in deed, the judge insists the federal and state governments are bound by their commitments to him in a 1992 consent decree — no matter what state lawmakers concoct. His dogmatic position comes as no surprise to those who know him. Federico Moreno, who tried cases in front of Hoeveler before joining the Miami federal bench, considers him "a judge's judge." Moreno's thoughts veered to "The Wizard of Oz," saying Hoeveler possessed the attributes treasured by Dorothy's friends: courage, heart and intellect. Kevin Martin, a member of the Federal Communications Commission and former Hoeveler clerk, said the judge "was very sharp, was very deliberative, one of the most fair-minded people I've ever known."  Read more
Judge Hoeveler News Page

 

07-June-03

Congressman questions Glades law
By Lesley Clark
©  The Miami Herald
TALLAHASSEE - Citing ''genuine alarm'' over the controversial Everglades law, another leading Republican congressman is questioning Gov. Jeb Bush's commitment to cleaning up the River of Grass. U.S. Rep. David Hobson, an Ohio Republican who has sway over federal money for energy and water projects across the United States, wrote a letter Friday to the Republican governor saying the new law gives him ''reason to doubt'' the state is ''bound or committed'' to cleaning up the water in the Everglades fast enough to allow an $8 billion restoration project to go forward. The letter is the starkest warning yet that the sugar industry-backed law could put at risk the federal government's $4 billion share of the massive restoration project. ''I am told that the failings of this legislation may render water flowing through the South Florida system unsuitable for Everglades restoration for several more years,'' said Hobson, one of several congressmen Bush met with last month on a trip to Washington, D.C., in an effort to appease his critics.  Read more

Judge postpones Everglades hearing
By Robert P. King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
A federal judge, under fire from the sugar industry, has indefinitely postponed a hearing at which he could have appointed an overseer for the $1 billion Everglades cleanup. In a terse order late Friday, U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler said the hearing, scheduled to begin Tuesday in Miami, is postponed "until further notice." Sugar lawyers this week asked Chief U.S. District Judge William Zloch in Miami and an appellate court in Atlanta to remove Hoeveler from the case, charging that he has become biased in favor of environmentalists. "Sugar's fusillade gained them a delay," said Charles Lee, senior vice president of Audubon of Florida. "And of course, sugar is the master of seeking and gaining delays." Judy Sanchez, spokeswoman for United States Sugar Corp., said she hadn't read the order and could not comment. Thom Rumberger, chairman of the environmental group Everglades Trust, said the delay left him "upset and hurt." "I just wish we could go forward," he said.
Read more

EVERGLADES UNDER THREAT
By Gerad Tubb
© Sky News- United Kingdom


© Sky News
Under the new legislation, alligators are now in danger.


In the steamy heat of the Florida Everglades, the American alligator is trying to compete with the American sugar industry - and it's losing, writes Sky's Gerard Tubb. Florida - the sunshine state, and one of the UK's top foreign holiday destinations, is polluting the Everglades with run-off from sugar cane fields. It causes plants to grow unnaturally fast, turning the pristine waters black and crowding out the wildlife. The pollution was due to stop in 2006. An agreement between Florida and Washington would have released four billion dollars of federal funds to save the Everglades from further destruction and providing a better supply of fresh water for South Florida's population. But a critical water quality standard of 10 parts per billion of phosphorous was going to be difficult to reach. The rich sugar industry
spent millions of dollars lobbying to get the standard scrapped. Florida Governor Jeb Bush sided with the industry and signed a bill last month allowing the pollution to continue till 2016. To see the damage caused by the pollution, the Audubon Society, one of
Florida's leading conservation groups, took us on a two-hour trip into the river of grass. The Everglades are dominated by this 60 mile wide, 300 mile long ribbon of water stretching from the Kissimmee River to Florida Bay. It's a unique habitat, rarely more than two feet deep, and accessible only by canoe and the flat-bottomed airboats with massive aircraft propellers
that pushed us over lily ponds and through the sawgrass.
  Read more

Big Sugar wins delay on 'Glades
By Neil Santaniello
© The Sun Sentinel
Florida's sugar industry prevailed Friday in one part of a legal attack it launched on U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler after he ripped state legislation overhauling Florida's Everglades cleanup law. The federal judge Friday postponed until further notice a hearing he had set for Tuesday to consider appointing a special master to oversee his 1992 court mandate on the Everglades. That action spurred the state to initiate a 9-year-old program to clean polluted sugar and vegetable farm water pouring into the Everglades. U.S. Sugar Corp. filed a motion Wednesday to have the hearing stayed until chief U.S. District Judge William Zloch could act on its request to remove Hoeveler from his longtime role in the Everglades pollution case. The same day, Florida Crystals filed a motion with the federal appeals court in Atlanta seeking Hoeveler's ouster.  Read more

Sugar Tries Legal Ambush Of Everglades Cleanup Judge
© The Tampa Tribune
The sugar industry's effort to remove the federal judge who has overseen the Everglades restoration effort for 15 years is a clear attempt to stall progress. The growers claim U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler is biased because he publicly questioned the wisdom of an industry-promoted bill that weakens Everglades water quality standards. But Hoeveler only stated the obvious. The measure changes the standards established in his court order and agreed to by the state. Hoeveler has presided over the cleanup effort since former federal attorney Dexter Lehtinen sued the state in 1988 for not enforcing its own water quality laws by allowing tainted runoff to flow into the Everglades. Hoeveler is scheduled Tuesday to assign a special master to the cleanup and has stated his intent to maintain the cleanup standards. The sugar industry is not even a party to the court order. The judge is simply presiding over the consent order to which the state agreed to comply.  Read more
Judge Hoeveler News Page

WMD seeks $50 million
By Robert P. King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
Water managers expect to have a record amount of cash next year, but they're still struggling to plug a $50 million hole in their $800 million-plus proposed budget. The casualties could include programs to help Lake Okeechobee, the St. Lucie River, the Indian River Lagoon and various flood-control projects, along with 15 jobs at the South Florida Water Management District. "We're definitely having to do some belt-tightening," said Executive
Director Henry Dean. Despite the tightness, Dean said the district intends to plunge ahead with this year's installment of the $8.4 billion, four-decade Everglades restoration project. The restoration is entering its most expensive phase, including an effort to finish buying more than $2 billion worth of land in the next several years. Dean also is recommending that the district spend $1.5 million annually for the next three years to help Palm Beach County create a nearly $35 million water treatment plant for the Glades. That would provide
carcinogen-free water to Pahokee, South Bay and other farming towns around the lake.
Read more

 

06-June-03

Letter from David Hobson to Governor Bush
Press Release
I am writing to express my concern over the current state of the effort to save the Everglades, and to urge you to begin the task of restoring a sense of confidence that the coalition of shared interests dedicated to carrying out this work has not been irreversibly damaged by recent legislative actions taken by the State of Florida.  As governor of Florida, you have stewardship of a number of national treasures.  The national significance of the Everglades has been highlighted, in part, by the large commitment of Federal revenues representing an investment from taxpayers all over the country and the human resources of several Federal agencies working on this project.  As Chairman of the Appropriations Subcommittees primarily responsible for the wise commitment of taxpayer funds to this and other energy and water projects in Florida and across the nation, I must insure that the continued provision of funds for the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan (CERP) represents their best possible use.  Read more

 

05-June-03

Sugar companies want judge off Glades case
By CRAIG PITTMAN          
© St. Petersburg Times           
Two sugar companies say the federal judge overseeing the cleanup of the Everglades has been talking too much, both in court and to reporters, and should be booted off the case.  In separate motions filed in two federal courts Wednesday, U.S. Sugar and a subsidiary of Flo-Sun Sugar criticized tough-talking U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler, 80, for giving interviews to several newspapers, including the St. Petersburg Times, that show he no longer is impartial.  "The judge has become an advocate," U.S. Sugar vice president Robert Coker said.  The sugar companies also want overturned a pair of blunt orders Hoeveler sent out criticizing a sugar-backed bill that flew through the Legislature and delays the deadline for cleaning up Everglades pollution by a decade.  One order called an emergency hearing because the judge said he'd been reading news accounts about the legislation "with considerable apprehension."  Then, after that hearing, Hoeveler issued an order in which he called the bill "clearly defective" and said Gov. Jeb Bush was being "misled" by people
who did not care about the Everglades.  Bush signed the bill anyway.  
Read more  
Judge Hoeveler News Page

Brochure rewards Everglades sellout
Editorial
© Tampa Tribune
If you receive a brochure praising your lawmaker for supporting Everglades legislation, there is something you should know. The brochure was paid for by a nonprofit group with close ties to the sugar industry. As the Tribune's Mike Salinero found, the law firm that formed the Everglades Forever Partnership, which mailed the brochure, represents the Fanjul family, owners of Flo-Sun sugar conglomerate. There is something else you should know. While the pamphlet, adorned with photographs of birds and wetlands, praises the legislators who voted for the bill as ``leading the fight for Everglades restoration,'' the measure actually endangered the cleanup effort. It delays by 10 years water quality standards for runoff that flows from agricultural lands onto the Everglades. The court-approved plan had mandated that growers reduce phosphorus levels below 10 parts per billion by 2006. At the urging of a platoon of sugar industry lobbyists, lawmakers pushed back the deadline until 2016. They did this even though members of Congress warned that the legislation could jeopardize congressional support for the 20-year, $8 billion cleanup plan.  Read more

State of Glades
UF project to examine phosphorus levels
By Greg C. Bruno, Sun Staff Writer
© Gainsville Sun


© Greg C. Bruno, Gainville Sun 2003
In much of the northern Everglades’ so-called water conservation areas, 
high levels of phosphorus are threatening to wipe out native plants and wildlife.

WEST PALM BEACH- Last month, amid vocal opposition from state environmentalists, Gov. Jeb Bush signed legislation that some say will delay a deadline for the reduction of phosphorus pollution in the Everglades by a decade, from 2006 to 2016. Critics of the move said it was a nod to the sugar industry and could jeopardize federal funding for the $8 billion project. Supporters point to recent allocations of money as proof of their continued support, adding that previous deadlines were scientifically unrealistic. But while lawmakers continue to debate the controversial bill, a pivotal question remains unanswered: Just how widespread is phosphorus in Florida's fabled River of Grass? New research by the University of Florida aims to find out. Armed with a South Florida Water Management District grant, university
soil and water scientists are embarking on a monumental Everglades mapping project — a one-year, $500,000 phosphorus survey of the marshland’s entire 1.7 million acres. “This will be the newest and the biggest,” said Todd Osborne, 29, a graduate student in the university's soil and water science department, part of UF’s Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences, who is leading the project’s field sampling efforts. For years, nutrient research in Florida's southern freshwater marshes centered primarily on the northern regions of the Everglades basin, so-called water conservation areas south of Lake Okeechobee established 40 to 50 years ago. 
Read more

Latest Everglades move is such a sweet deal
By Howard Goodman, Commentary
© The Sun Sentinel
Probably like most of you out there, I can't wait to check my mailbox for the latest on the new Everglades bill. I'm expecting a flier that features a photo of my state representative or
senator, some colorful pictures of wildlife and prose about the new law's benefits: "Science-based plan that works ... Tough standards ... No new taxes." Guess they didn't want to say, "Pushes deadlines back 10 years ... Increases taxpayer share of cleanup cost." The fliers are going out to an unknown number of communities around the state. What's interesting is, the highlighted legislators aren't paying for them. The sponsor is the Everglades Forever Partnership, a clever name for a front group for the sugar industry. The mailing is a sweet little thank-you to legislators who, in a moving display of bipartisanship, ignored party divisions to stand as one and sell out the Everglades. So we come full circle: The sugar industry gives at least $1.02 million to politicians in Tallahassee in the past two years. Legislators vote almost unanimously for an industry-backed bill that relaxes requirements to clean up the pollution the industry produces. Now the industry sends out campaign-like material in the legislators' names. It's almost like getting a calling card saying, "This Florida representative/senator is brought to you by Flo-Sun and U.S. Sugar."

Read more

SWFMD to seek perpetual payment
By Tracy Whirls
© Glades County Democrat 
South Florida Water Management District Executive Director Henry Dean told an audience of Hendry and Glades County officials that he will assist the counties in seeking perpetual payment in lieu of taxes for lands being taken off the counties' tax rolls as part of the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Project and other state and federal conservation project[s]. Saying it's apparent that the citizens and governments of Hendry and Glades
are facing "undue adverse impact from land acquisitions," Mr. Dean told
. Reservoirs in Clewiston Monday that Lake-area landowners and governments should not bear the brunt of Everglades Restoration. "I'm not sure it was well thought out to take land off the tax rolls to
create reservoirs t ensure the water supplies for the lower east coast and the three million acres of Everglades marsh," Mr. Dean said. "I'm prepared to work with you as hard as I know how, to go the legislature next spring and insist that perpetual payment in lieu of taxes be made on all the land that's being taken off the tax rolls," Mr. Dean said. Mr. Dean pointed out that the 140,000 acres proposed to be acquired by the CERP project is less than half of the 352,000 acres that the state has acquired or is in the process of acquiring by the Trustees Internal Improvement Fund. Mr. Dean said the payment in lieu of taxes could be based on a need criteria based on population, tax revenue and mean income over 50 years to insure
perpetual funding. In the meantime, Mr. Dean said he would ask SFWMD's Governing Board to draft a memorandum of understanding between Dade, Broward and Palm Beach Counties
to have a portion of their ad valorum taxes paid to SFWMD rebated to Hendry and Glades Counties for providing water to those areas.
"We're talking about fairness, equity and what's right," Mr. Dean said, noting that the urban areas and the Everglades will receive the benefits
from the water storage projects, while inland rural counties, already designated areas of critical economic concern are struggling to pay for schools, road, emergency medical and other services. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers project manager Dennis Duke said the District
and the Corps of Engineers have already begun a study of the potential economic impact of the CERP project, as workers are displaced by ag land acquisitions. Mr. Duke said some jobs may be replaced by expanded operations of the new water storage structures and more jobs could be created through recreation opportunities. Mr. Duke said the project team is working on a master recreation plan to capitalize on bass fishing and other recreational opportunities with the 200,000 acres of land that will be acquired under CERP. Hendry County Commissioner Bill Maddox said Monday's meeting was the first he has attended where officials have admitted that Hendry and Glades County
lands are being acquired to provide water for the coast.. He proposed that a task force be create to work with SFWMD and the Corps to secure the payment in lieu of taxes funding and address the economic impacts of the plan. "We understand the need to have land to store water," Commissioner Maddox said. "But it's kind of like how you would feel if somebody brought your backyard for an interstate." 

Big Sugar: Oust judge in Glades cleanup
©  The Miami Herald
The sugar industry launched a legal attack Wednesday against U.S. District Senior Judge William Hoeveler, an outspoken critic of Florida's controversial overhaul of pollution laws protecting the Everglades. In separate but similar motions filed in federal court in Miami and Atlanta, the state's biggest sugar companies asked that Hoeveler be removed from a landmark case that he has overseen for more than a decade -- the original lawsuit that forced the state's environmental regulators to stop allowing farm and urban runoff to taint the River of Grass. The motions contend the judge overstepped appropriate judicial oversight to play politics, issuing rulings in April and May critical of efforts by sugar industry lobbyists and the Florida Legislature to revise the 1994 Florida Forever Act and suggesting Gov. Jeb Bush had been misled about the bill. Bush later signed the bill into law.  Read more

 

04-June-03

EPA to Permit Florida to Pollute Drinking Water Supplies
By Donald Sutherland
© RiskWorld.com News Report
Before EPA Administrator Christine Todd Whitman resigned from her office she had decided to sign off on a rule-making decision drawn up by EPA water administrators declaring Florida exempt from certain provisions of the Safe Drinking Water Act. Published in the Federal Register on May 5, 2003, the exemption will permit Florida to legally pollute drinking water aquifers with inadequately treated waste through municipal underground injection control (UIC) wells.  Read more...

Letter to the Editor: Wellington boy's science promising for Everglades
By HENRY DEAN, executive director   South Florida Water Management District, West Palm Beach
© Palm Beach Post
The South Florida Water Management District congratulates Patrick Geer on his first-place win at the prestigious Intel International Science and Engineering Fair ("Wellington High student cleans up water, competition," May 18). As the agency responsible for Everglades water quality cleanup, we want to commend Mr. Geer and his inspirational teacher, Ann Henderson, for conducting scientific research on phosphorus removal techniques. The use of
constructed wetlands to naturally cleanse farm runoff is a key component of our efforts to meet water-quality mandates. Mr. Geer's independent research supports the benefits and effectiveness of utilizing "green technology" to achieve our long-term goals. 
Read more

Brochure on Everglades Irks Environmentalists
By Mike Salinero
© The Tampa Tribune
TALLAHASSEE - Sugar companies and other agricultural interests are saying thanks to state legislators who voted in favor of a controversial Everglades bill by sending colorful brochures to voters in the lawmakers' districts. The mailings are from the Everglades Forever Partnership, a nonprofit group set up April 3. The law firm that formed the corporation also
represents the Fanjul family, owners of Flo-Sun sugar conglomerate. Sugar company executives did not return calls for comment. Otis Wragg, a spokesman for U.S. Sugar Co., said the partnership is a ``broad- based coalition.'' The brochures, featuring photographs of wading birds, cypress trees and saw grass, tout the legislators as ``leading the fight for Everglades restoration.'' Environmentalists call the postcards free political advertising and the
sugar industry's payback to state lawmakers who supported flawed legislation. 
Read more

Be fair to Glades
Editorial
© Palm Beach Post
"How do you come up with $30 million?" asked Palm Beach County Commission
Chairwoman Karen Marcus. In this case, any way you can. This case is the need for a regional water treatment plant in the Glades area along the south shore of Lake Okeechobee. The cities can't afford to build one. Without a new plant, which will cost about $35 million,
residents of these poor towns will continue to drink water that everyone agrees has dangerously high levels of trihalomethanes, which can cause cancer. Ideally, the state would pay much or all of the cost, since state policies have allowed the fouling of Lake Okeechobee. The cities draw their water from the lake, and the material that has fouled the lake reacts with chlorine to form the suspected carcinogens. But these days, the Legislature has no conscience, only a good memory for who gave campaign contributions. Annual per-capita income in Belle Glade, Pahokee and South Bay averages about $10,000.

Read more

Letter to the Editor: Sugar industry doesn't want to delay cleanup
By Judy Sanchez, United States Sugar Corporation
© Stuart News
As a stakeholder in the Everglades region, we strongly support the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Program. We support the restoration of the Indian River Lagoon as well. We certainly have no interest in delaying or in any way interfering with the success of this project. The United States Army Corps of Engineers is responsible for the planning
and approval process of each individual CERP project. After the local Corps office proposes a project, the Jacksonville District in this case, it is sent to the Corps' Washington headquarters for review and approval. Part of the approval process involves the chief's office sending out requests for comment on the proposed project to all stakeholders. In that
capacity, a consultant in Washington for many agriculture interests, who is a former acting assistant secretary of the Army, reviewed the project. Based on his experience, he noted several significant problems in the proposal. 
Read more

Butterworth suggested for Everglades master
By Bob King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
Five months after retiring from public life, former state Attorney General Bob Butterworth could return as federal overseer of the Everglades cleanup. The Sierra Club and seven other environmental groups are nominating Butterworth to serve as the cleanup's special master, who would help a federal judge decide whether the state is keeping its promises. U.S. District Judge William Hoeveler in Miami said last month that he intends to appoint a special master, a step he had resisted for years. Hoeveler said he's alarmed by the state's support for a bill postponing the cleanup's December 2006 deadline -- legislation he called "clearly
defective." Butterworth said Tuesday that he didn't even know that environmentalists
had nominated him, but he's willing to serve if Hoeveler wants. "I would be honored to do anything for Judge Hoeveler," said Butterworth, now dean of St. Thomas University Law School in Miami. "I think that he's the finest jurist that I've ever worked with." 
Read more

 

03-June-03

Letter regarding the expedited implementation of PASTA
to
Colonel James G. May
By David B. Struhs and Henry Dean
Water in 90 percent of the Everglades is clean. Governor Jeb Bush is committed to accelerate cleanup of the remaining 10 percent. As you know, Florida is already implementing proven technologies, including construction of Stormwater Treatment Areas and implementation of Best Management Practices, that guarantee continued progress for improving water quality over the next decade. However, until now, funding was not available for advanced treatment technologies. As a result of amendments to the Everglades Forever Act made by the Florida Legislature just last month, the South Florida Water Management District is able to use an estimated $650 million over the next 13 years in existing revenue to implement advanced water treatment tools to reduce phosphorus entering the Everglades. Now that the funding is available, the South Florida Water Management District is accelerating implementation of a promising new technology, Periphyton-Based Stormwater Treatment Area (PASTA), in Stormwater Treatment Area 3-4. The District has been testing this new technology, which uses algae and microscopic organisms to naturally cleanse phosphorus from the water, since 1999. These test results show great promise and build on our efforts to achieve the stringent water quality stand throughout the Everglades Protection Area.  Read more

Seminole tribe inaugurates new leader
St. Petersburg Times/ Associated Press
HOLLYWOOD, Fla. The Seminole Tribe of Florida has its new leader in place. Mitchell Cypress, the tribe's former vice chairman, was inaugurated Monday as the tribe's new chairman. He was elected to the post last month, becoming the first new chairman since James E. Billie was elected in 1979. Cypress will lead the tribe and its $300 million gambling empire. He also controls an annual allotment of $15 million. Cypress took an oath of office Monday to uphold the U.S. Constitution and the Seminole one. The new Tribal Council and board of directors also were inaugurated. They vowed to protect the best interests of the 2,800-member tribe. Cypress said he plans to focus on issues such as education, housing and preserving the tribal languages. "I think the new elected officials are going to be working together -- the board and the council," he said after a 90-minute ceremony that about 500
people attended. "Whatever we accomplish, it is going to benefit the tribal members." Billie, 59, was ousted by the Tribal Council in March for alleged shady financial practices. After he was unsuccessful in seeking to be reinstated, he insisted that he should be able to run in the election. But the tribe said no.

 

01-June-03

Protests swamp Florida's Jeb Bush for relaxing Everglades 
pollution law

By Jacqui Goddard
© Scotland on Sunday
The brother of the US President - Florida governor Jeb Bush - has become embroiled in a furious row over a relaxation of pollution controls in the mangrove swamps of the Everglades. Political analysts said a growing backlash against the decision to allow phosphorous from large sugar farms to run off into the world's largest sub-tropical wetland could seriously damage George W Bush's campaign for re-election in the crucial swing-vote state. The new law, which was signed into the statute books by his brother, extends the deadline for reducing phosphorous levels in the world-famous Everglades from 2006 to 2016, undoing a strict timetable previously laid down by the 1994 Everglades Forever Act. Phosphorous run-off from sugar farms kills algae, allowing non-native plants, such as cat-tails, to spread rapidly and crowd out native species, fatally altering the habitat for wildlife.  Read more...

Water crisis clues come early, often
By Tom Palmer
© The Ledger


© Jeff Spence, The Ledger 2003


BARTOW -- Polk County water users are pumping water from the aquifer faster than rainfall can replenish it, a group of experts told the County Commission before an overflow crowd. That's a recap of a meeting that occurred in 1968. For anyone who has been here long enough and was paying attention, there were plenty of clues that the water supply was not inexhaustible and that sooner or later the water problems the region confronts today would become too critical to ignore. Perhaps the earliest and most-cited omen occurred in 1950, when Kissingen Springs, a popular swimming area south of Bartow, quit flowing because of
heavy groundwater pumping in the area. It never recovered and today is a dry, weed-covered depression near the Peace River. By 1965, the aquifer had declined so much that the historic flow of the aquifer into the Upper Peace River was reversed. Water in the section of the river between Bartow and Fort Meade was flowing into the aquifer instead of water from the aquifer flowing into the river. That condition was quite visible during the 2001-02 drought when sinkholes near Bartow swallowed that section of the river's entire flow. Textbooks used in local public schools as long ago as the early 1950s warned that drainage and overpumping combined to deplete the freshwater aquifer and encourage saltwater intrusion. 
Read more

Large preserve created along Intracostal Waterway
St. Petersburg Times/ Associated Press
MATANZAS MARSH, Fla. The recent state purchase of 8,465 pristine acres north of Faver-Dykes State Park creates a 16,000-acre preserve along the Intracoastal Waterway
of undisturbed marshfront land. The acquisition will protect wildlife habitat and water quality in
shellfish harvesting areas, according to the St. Johns River Water Management District. And the public will be able to use the land for hiking, camping and horseback riding. State officials and St. Johns County residents celebrated the $40 million purchase of the Matanzas Marsh last month at Faver-Dykes. Using Florida Forever Funds, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection contributed 75 percent of the cost, and the Water Management District contributed the rest. The land was purchased in December. Cluttered with oak hammocks, palms, pines and cypress trees, the Matanzas Marsh is an expansive wildlife habitat with about 70 animal species, including two bald eagle nests and a wood stork rookery. It's located between the Intracoastal Waterway and U.S. 1 south of State Road 206.

Read more

DEP, WMD Partner in Land Acquisition Creating 16,000-Acre Conservation Corridor
Press Release
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
PALATKA -- The Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) joined with St. Johns River Water Management District (WMD) in the purchase of 8,465 acres of environmentally significant land in St. Johns County, creating a 16,000-acre conservation corridor.
Read more

Author of Everglades bill murky
By Robert P. King, Staff Writer
© Palm Beach Post
This year's controversial Everglades bill had plenty of powerful supporters -- but nobody willing to admit writing it. Not David Struhs, Gov. Jeb Bush's top environmental aide, who insists he didn't see the legislation until after it emerged April 1 in the state House. Not House Speaker Johnnie Byrd, who told reporters he let a committee chairman lead on the issue. Not the committee chairman, who refuses to talk about it. And not the sugar industry, whose dozens of lobbyists supporting the bill included an old pal of Byrd's, a union leader and a former top aide to Gov. Lawton Chiles. But all had a hand in the legislation, according to public documents and the recollections of people involved in weeks of negotiations:
Read more

 

Return to Top

 

Revised:  11/16/03

University of Miami School of Law Library
Everglades Litigation Internet Initiative Director
1311 Miller Drive
Coral Gables, Florida 33146
(305) 284-4093
  2003 University of Miami School of Law.
All Rights Reserved.
Requests for information
Send comments / technical feedback.