President George W. Bush hands over the 
pen to his brother Florida Governor 
Jeb Bush, left, after signing an agreement... 
 9-Jan-02

Photo:

  
 
Recent Developments

Recent home 
News         
Press Releases
Litigation
Regulations
Case Law
Law Review Articles
Reports
Research
Conferences      




New Legislation


Links    The Florida Legislature

19 April 04

Governor not guiding growth, critics say
After two years of planning, Bush has only two weeks to get a Wekiva River proposal passed.
By Joe Newman
©
Orlando Sentinel
TALLAHASSEE -- After pledging during his 2002 re-election campaign to make growth management a priority, Gov. Jeb Bush so far has little to show for those promises. An ambitious plan to make Secretary of State Glenda Hood his growth czar stalled. The Department of Community Affairs, which oversees how land is developed and would have been merged with Hood's office, instead is grappling with its uncertain fate and revolving-door leadership. Critics say no meaningful growth-management legislation has passed during
Bush's second term -- and the few statewide measures in front of the Legislature this year have been criticized for actually loosening growth controls.
And now, a bill that would protect the fragile Wekiva River ecosystem from rampant development is in doubt for the second year in a row. Read more

 

18 April 04

Ocala's race
Will legislation open the field for a track...
BY RYAN CONLEY
©
Ocala Star-Banner
OCALA - For those following the saga surrounding a proposed Marion County racetrack, recently introduced Senate legislation is clearly viewed as a momentous step toward the creation of a horse race track in Ocala. It was so momentous and so swift that many inside the industry and outside have scarcely had time to get adjusted to the idea, let alone understand the complex proposal. But even if the amended bill should somehow pass before the current legislative session ends in two weeks -- and the early odds say it is a longshot -- a daunting myriad of challenges must be overcome to make way for the Ocala jewel envisioned by racing giant Magna Entertainment Corp. Read more

01 April 04

Legislators Promote Better Ocean Stewardship with Introduction of Clean Cruise Ship Act of 2004
Members of Congress act to protect marine ecosystems from cruise ship pollution
Press Release
Gregg M. Schmidt
Telephone:  202-857-1685
Email:  gschmidt@oceanconservancy.org
Washington, DC – The Ocean Conservancy applauds the bi-partisan group of legislators led by Senator Richard J. Durbin (D-IL), California Congressman Sam Farr (D-17th), and Connecticut Congressman Christopher Shays (R-4th) for introducing the Clean Cruise Ship Act of 2004. As cruise ships have continued to grow in popularity, capacity and number, so has their impact on our ocean ecosystems. This new measure will establish clear and reasonable environmental standards for a largely unregulated industry.
The cruise ships of today carry thousands of passengers, and produce waste equivalent to that of small cities. Yet they are not governed by the same anti-pollution laws as municipalities of comparable size on land. Right now, cruise ships are not subject to regulations that would help protect the beautiful and inspiring ocean ecosystems and marine wildlife that attract many cruise ship travelers. “Cruise ships have largely escaped pollution regulations, and The Ocean Conservancy believes it is time to adopt legislation that brings cruise ships in line with 21st century pollution control practices,” said Roger Rufe, President of The Ocean Conservancy. “With the large expansion in the cruise industry, the Clean Cruise Ship Act of 2004 provides an appropriate solution to a preventable problem.” 

31 March 04

Legislature may take up water reservation issue during session
By CHARLIE WHITEHEAD
©
Naples News
The issue of how water reservations for the environment balance with water for future growth may yet be addressed through legislation this session in Tallahassee.
Environmentalists, developers and now Lee County will be watching carefully to see if a bill that the Association of Florida Community Developers may propose finds state cooperation and a legislative sponsor. The bill is borne of a controversy over the Department of Environmental Protection's effort to change a rule that would expand the list of environmental uses for which it could reserve fresh water. Currently water use rules allow the state to reserve water for wildlife protection and for Everglades restoration. The new rule would allow reservations for aquatic preserves, Outstanding Florida Waters and state parks and public lands. It would also allow prospective reservations, meaning it could reserve water from future resource restoration projects. Read more

29 March 04

Water rule challenge may end through agreement
By CHARLIE WHITEHEAD
© Naples Daily News
There may be an agreement in the works that would settle a developer group's challenge of a state rule to expand reservations of fresh water for environmental purposes.
Local developers still aren't saying how they feel about the Association of Florida Community Developers' challenge of the proposed Department of Environmental Protection rule. Some Lee County commissioners raised a stink about the challenge this week, demanding to know where local members of the association — Bonita Bay Group, Collier Enterprises, Barron Collier, Ginn Development and WCI — stand. As of Friday, none had returned calls or made statements. Cathy Vogel, lobbyist for the association, says there might be a settlement in the works. Vogel says the challenge was filed simply to allow continued work on the new rule. The state currently can reserve fresh water for the environment to implement Everglades restoration, potentially withholding it from proposed development. The change would expand allowable reservations to include Outstanding Florida Waters, parks, preserves and public lands. Read more

28 March 04

Environmental groups upset over wetlands rules changes
By CATHY ZOLLO
© Naples Daily News
Recent changes in the way the federal government regulates wetlands and other waterways and a push in the Florida Legislature to test the dumping of treated sewage water in canals has state and national environmental groups alarmed.
The League of Conservation Voters, Florida Public Interest Research Group, Earthjustice, Natural Resource Defense Council, Citizens for the Bay, Clean Water Network and the Sierra Club Florida Chapter have banded together to call attention to their concerns. "We are, collectively, calling on the Bush administration to reverse its current policy and uphold the Clean Water Act by applying its protections to all waters of the United States," said Sandra Diaz of the League of Conservation Voters Education Fund. The groups say the administration and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers are backing off from protecting certain wetlands and waterways, such as canals. Meanwhile, they say, a bill under consideration in Tallahassee will require a pilot project to test the dumping of treated sewage water in those canals. Read more

27 March 04

Groups Target Water Limits
By MIKE SALINERO
©
Tampa Tribune
TALLAHASSEE - Several powerful developer groups are trying to change provisions of Florida law that allow the state to reserve water for the environment. The target of the developers' lobbying efforts is a seldom-used statute that allows state agencies to reserve water for ``protection of fish and wildlife or the public health and safety.'' That law has been used only once, when the St. Johns Water Management District reserved water for the Paynes Prairie State Preserve just south of Gainesville.
But the law is slated to play a crucial role in the $8.4 billion Everglades restoration project, which depends on massive water storage projects. Developers are worried that the effort to capture water and reroute it across the Everglades won't leave enough for development in South Florida. ``We're not opposed to the idea of water reservations, but there has to be a certain equity in the legislation that takes into account the needs of agriculture, community development, as well as environmental uses,'' said Ken Plonski, spokesman for WCI Communities Inc., developers of Sun City Center. Read more

01-March-04

Proposed special districts linked to Ave Maria expected to get OK from Legislature
By LARRY HANNAN
© Naples Daily News
Barring a huge surprise, bills creating two independent special districts in Collier County should easily sail through the Florida Legislature this spring.
"These districts have the support of local government," said state Rep. Mike Davis, R-Naples. "They have been well supported throughout this entire process and that is something that matters to the
Legislature."
Barron Collier Cos. wants a special district to build and maintain community services for Ave Maria University and its companion town, while Collier Enterprises is seeking a similar district to control what would be called the Big Cypress Stewardship District for lands west of the proposed Ave Maria district. Both proposed districts are east of Collier Boulevard and south of the Immokalee area, totaling more than 30,000 acres. Read more

Legislature 2004: Environmental projects may get funding boost
By ERIC STAATS
© Naples Daily News
Environmental restoration projects from Lake Trafford to Naples Bay are in the mix for a funding boost from the state Legislature this year.
Local legislators in the state House and Senate are pushing $12.3 million worth of projects in Collier County on behalf of the South Florida Water Management District. The session gets started Tuesday in Tallahassee although the fate of the funding requests probably won't be known for months. The session lasts 60 days. Similar requests during the 2002 session went unfunded in a late-hour scramble to adopt the state's annual budget with funding tight. That left the Water Management District to fill the gap, sending $1 million to kindle Naples Bay restoration. Read more

06-January-04

Florida must review water management
Saunders’ senate bill a good idea
Editorial
©
Ft Myers News-Press
Should Florida move ahead with a statewide review of its water management structure, knowing that powerful business interests are hoping such a study will open the door to possible privatization of water in the state, and controversial interregional transfers? The answer has to be yes. Studying Florida water needs on a statewide basis makes sense.
Demand is soaring, and while the current system of regional water management districts has worked so far, it may not be adequate for the future.
It would be blind to refuse to put all the issues on the table for discussion. Those include privatization and the transfer of water from areas rich in the resource to those where demand will outstrip supply. Read more

 

19-December-03

Bill would kill water transfer proposal
Rep. David Russell aims to prevent water being moved from the state's north to its south.

By DAN DeWITT
© St. Petersburg Times
BROOKSVILLE - For State Rep. David Russell, preparing a bill that ties water use to development has become an annual ritual. The general idea has always been the same, that local governments should make sure water is available to any development they approve. He first introduced it in 2001 and, the following year, a version passed that gently prodded cities and counties to identify sources of water. A tougher bill stalled in the 2003 session. The Brooksville Republican will introduce it again this spring, he said, with an important addition. His new bill will attempt to stop the controversial plan to ship water from rural areas of the northern part of the state to densely populated South Florida. "People around the state . . . are very concerned with the proposals made by the Committee of 100," Russell said, referring to the business group that introduced the plan earlier this year.  Read more

 

09-December-03

Safety valve on water
Editorial
© http://www.pbpost.com

Sometimes, the best thing to do is nothing, a hard concept for state legislators who may want to tinker recklessly with water policies. The Florida Council of 100's report urging new policies probably will spawn new attempts to remove Florida's water supply from public ownership. The council, a group of corporate leaders who advise Gov. Bush, recommends changes that could lead to privatizing the water supply and moving water from the springs and rivers of North Florida to serve rapid growth in Central and South Florida. Senate Natural Resources Committee Chairman Al Lawson, D-Tallahassee, has held hearings around the state on the council's suggestions, and he found that 99 percent of people who attended oppose the proposals. House members are calling for their own hearings. Opponents of the council's plans are watching for legislation similar to Baxter Troutman's bill that failed this year.  Read more

 

26-November-03

Collier legislators to push for special districts
By LARRY HANNAN
© Naples Daily News

The Collier County legislative delegation will work to create two new independent special districts during the 2004 legislative session in Tallahassee.
On Tuesday, the delegation unanimously agreed to support a local bill that would create the independent special districts. The special districts will encompass Ave Maria University and the rural lands west of Ave Maria, near Immokalee. A local bill only affects a local area and does not have an effect statewide. The tradition in the Legislature is that a local bill is pushed by legislators from the area the bill will affect. Read more

 

10-July-03

Florida Law Limiting Citizens' Right to Dispute Challenged
© Environmental News Service - ENS
TALLAHASSEE, Florida - Attorneys for the nonprofit public interest law firm Earthjustice opened their case today on behalf of two Florida groups who are challenging a Florida law that restricts the rights of ordinary citizens to dispute government decisions that affect the environment. The bill at issue passed in the final hours of the last legislative session, after being cobbled together with an unrelated bill that was likely to pass. The lawsuit, filed on behalf of the Environmental Confederation of Southwest Florida and Manasota 88, claims that the law violates the Florida Constitution because it deals with two unrelated topics. "This law seeks specifically to favor the interests of large corporations over the ordinary Floridian," said David Guest of Earthjustice. "All citizens have the right to question their government, and we don't intend to let an unconstitutional law take that right away." After repeated attempts to get the bill, Senate Bill 270, passed in previous sessions, sponsor state Senator Jim King attached it to an Everglades restoration bill that was widely supported. The package was signed into law in May 2002. Read more


2002


02-Dec-02               

Bush Signs Bill to Preserve Wetlands
WASHINGTON (AP) -- President Bush, hoping to burnish his environmental record, signed legislation Monday to continue a program aimed at preserving America's wetlands.  ``The federal government will continue its partnership with land owners, conservation groups and states to save and improve millions of acres of wetlands,'' the president said in a White House ceremony.  Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  NY Times, AP online  All rights reserved.

25-July-02


BILL WOULD RESTORE PROTECTION TO ISOLATED WETLANDS
Legislation introduced in Congress today would restore federal protection for millions of acres of wetlands that provide habitat for birds and other wildlife. Supporters of the legislation say it will restore the original intent of the Clean Water Act of 1972 by overriding a Supreme Court decision that removed federal protection for isolated wetlands.
U.S. Senator Russ Feingold, a Wisconsin Democrat, was joined by Representatives James Oberstar of Minnesota and John Dingell of Michigan, both Democrats, to introduce the Clean Water Authority Restoration Act of 2002. Read more...
Copyright  © 2002  Environment News Service (ENS) All Rights Reserved.

20-Jan-02  

Growth Management bill (CS-SB 382)
GROWTH PROPOSALS
     

Here are some key provisions of the growth management bill (CS-SB 382)
approved by the Senate Comprehensive Planning, Local and Military Affairs
Committee:

*    Local comprehensive plans must include a work plan covering at least 10 years for building water supply facilities to serve existing and new development.  
*    Local governments and school boards must enter interlocal planning agreements, unless they have declining school populations, with deadlines to be set by the Florida Department of Community Affairs between March 1, 2003, and Dec. 1, 2004.     
*    Local governments and school districts that fail to meet their deadlines for completing interlocal planning agreements will face sanctions that include withholding of state revenue sharing dollars and at least 5 percent of their state school construction money.     
*    Local governments could levy the 0.5 percent local option sales tax for infrastructure projects by a super majority -- a majority plus one -- instead of holding a referendum.      
*    School boards could levy the 0.5 percent local option sales tax for school capital outlay by a super majority -- a majority plus one -- instead of holding a referendum.
Copyright  © 2002  AP  All rights reserved.

09-Jan-02

COMPREHENSIVE EVERGLADES RESTORATION PLAN
ASSURANCE OF PROJECT BENEFITS AGREEMENT

       WHEREAS, the Everglades ecological system is unique in the world and one of the Nation's great treasures;  
       WHEREAS, the Central and Southern Florida Project as originally authorized in 1948 has had unintended consequences on the Everglades and South Florida Ecosystem;  
       WHEREAS, the Water Resources Development Act of 1992 authorized a Comprehensive Review Study (Restudy) of the Central and South Florida Project;  
       WHEREAS, as required by the Water Resources Development Act of 1996,
the Restudy was submitted to the Congress of the United States on July 1, 1999;  
       WHEREAS, the Restudy, renamed the Comprehensive Everglades Restoration Plan, was authorized by the Congress in the Water Resources Development Act of 2000

Read more..

 

2001



2000


 
New Bills

Senate action:

9/26/00 - Glades restoration project approved
9/24/00 - Canady takings bill rejected

•  Congress to Prepare Everglades Restoration Bill
Copyright © 2000 Everglades Conservation Network  All rights reserved.  Posted 01-Jun-00

•  H.R. 2372 to be voted on 
H.R. 2372, Rep. Canady's [R-FL] "Private Property Rights Implementation Act" (TAKINGS BILL) will be MARKED-UP and VOTED on by the Full HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE on WEDNESDAY, MARCH 8 and is likely to come to the Floor of the full House of Representatives the following week.

• 
Search Thomas 

07-July-00

Senate Now Reviews Everglades Bill
It's a historic moment for the Everglades. After being approved by a Senate committee, the full Senate is now poised to vote on a bill which would give $7.8 billion to restore the Everglades, and activists know that now is a crucial time.  "The clock is ticking for the Everglades," said Michael Bauer, Director, Everglades Project Office. "It's now or never. The American people should let their Senators know that we're not going to allow this unique wilderness area to die."  On June 26, 2000, the Senate Environment and Public Works committee approved the bill, which will pay for the first 10 projects of the restoration plan.
Copyright  © 2000 National Wildlife Federation  All rights reserved.

28-June-00

Huge Step Toward Restoration
Everglades Bill Heads Toward Senate
The National Wildlife Federation (NWF) applauded today's Senate Environment and Public Works Committee vote for legislation to restore the Everglades. "Senate Committee Chairman Robert Smith (R-NH) said it would happen and it did. One day after its introduction, S-2797, the Everglades Restoration Act, has moved out of committee toward a vote by the full Senate," said Michael Bauer, Director of NWF's Everglades Project Office.  S-2797 authorizes $7.8 billion to be spent on Everglades restoration over a 20 year period. Once a healthy eight-million acre "river of grass," the Everglades has been reduced to half its original size by a century of agricultural growth, urban sprawl and unwise water management.  "The 17-1 bipartisan vote in favor of restoration mirrors America's concern for and dedication to preserving this natural treasure," said Bauer. "We applaud Senator Smith for his leadership and his commitment to saving America's 'River of Grass,' and thank Florida Senators Bob Graham and Connie Mack for their efforts. Though not perfect, the bill clearly sets the stage for serious long-term work to save and restore this threatened national treasure."  The full Senate is expected to take up the restoration bill shortly after reconvening July 10. "The clock is ticking for the Everglades," added Bauer. "It's now or never. The American people should let their Senators know that we're not going to allow this unique wilderness area to die."
Copyright  © 2000 National Wildlife Federation  All rights reserved

28-June-00

NWF Praises Everglades Bill
Statement by Michael Bauer, Director, NWF Everglades Project Office
"The legislation introduced today by Senator Robert Smith is a bold and critical step toward the restoration of the Everglades. Though not perfect, it clearly sets the stage for long-term serious work to save and restore this threatened national treasure.  "The National Wildlife Federation applauds Senator Smith for his leadership and his commitment to saving America's 'River of Grass.' We are looking forward to working with him to remedy some of our continuing concerns with the legislation, most notably the need for provisions to ensure that the natural system receives the water needed for rehabilitation. Once such provisions for the restoration of the natural system are in place, we would wholeheartedly support this legislation.  "The time to restore the Everglades is now. This vast community of wildlife and critical source of water for Florida, can't wait any longer. This legislation is a bi-partisan starting point from which the Congress and the Administration can work to conserve a critical natural system on which both people and wildlife depend. It's a tremendous opportunity for Congress to demonstrate its commitment to conserve and protect an irreplaceable national treasure. The ball is now in their court."
Copyright  © 2000 National Wildlife Federation  All rights reserved.


 
Congressional Testimony

•  Subcommittee on Water Resources & Environment

01-Mar-00
•  Hearings & Testimony: Restoration of the Everglades and South Florida Ecosystem 

WITNESSES

PANEL I

Representative E. Clay Shaw, Jr.
Representative Carrie P. Meek
Representative Peter Deutsch
Representative Porter J. Goss
Representative Mark Foley

PANEL II

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
Honorable Joseph W. Westphal, Ph.D.
Assistant Secretary of the Army
(Civil Works)
Washington, D.C.
Accompanied by: Mr. Michael L. Davis
Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Army
for Policy and Legislation
Washington, D.C.

U.S. Department of the Interior
Ms. Mary E. Doyle
Counselor to the Secretary
Washington, D.C.

PANEL III

Florida Department of Environmental Protection
Honorable David B. Struhs
Secretary
Tallahassee, Florida

South Florida Water Management District
Mr. Michael Collins
Governing Board Chairman
West Palm Beach, Florida

Miccosukee Tribe
Mr. Billy Cypress
Chairman
Miami, Florida

PANEL IV

U.S. Sugar Corporation
Mr. Malcolm S. (Bubba) Wade
Senior Vice President
Clewiston, Florida

The United States Property Owners & Friends of the
8.5 Square Mile Area, Inc.
Ms. Ibel Aguilera
Director
Miami, Florida

Audubon of Florida
Dr. Stuart D. Strahl
President & CEO
Miami, Florida

 

1999  

Senate Bill 0908c2
A Bill Relating To Florida Forever Program
A bill to be entitled: An act relating to the Florida Forever Program; creating s. 259.202, F.S.; creating the Florida Forever Act; providing legislative findings; prohibiting the use of certain funds in the Conservation and Recreation Lands and Water Management Lands Trust Funds for land acquisition;


11-May-98
House Bill 4141er
ENROLLED 1998 Legislature CS/CS/HB 4141

An act relating to water resources
; creating s. 373.45923, F.S.; providing legislative findings and intent; authorizing the South Florida Water Management District to participate as local sponsor for the Restudy of the Central and Southern Florida Project; providing duties of the Joint Legislative Committee on Everglades Oversight; providing for public hearings; providing reporting requirements; providing for project cooperation agreements; providing for legislative authorization; providing an effective date...


11-May-98
House Bill 4071er
ENROLLED 1998 Legislature CS/HB 4071, Third Engrossed

An act relating to environmental protection
; amending s.373.4137, F.S. bill includes provisions that would increase land acquisition costs for restoration effort by 30% - 50% by requiring that compensation to landowners take place under state, rather than federal laws.

 

Credit      

Photo by Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP 

 

 

Revised:  04/21/04

 

University of Miami School of Law Library
Alberto F. Montero Valdes        
1311 Miller Drive
Coral Gables, Florida 33146    
Copyright, 2003 University of Miami School of Law.
All Rights Reserved.
Send comments / technical feedback.